Last year, 10 percent of doctors younger than 30 and 7 percent of doctors between the ages of 30 and 35, practicing in Darrenville, made at least one avoidable error during a medical procedure. On the other hand, only 2 percent of doctors 60 and older made such an error. These findings make it clear that the advanced experience and learned propensity for caution possessed by doctors in the 60 and older group make them far more reliable than younger doctors are.
s
Which of the following is an assumption on which the argument depends?
Conclusion : that advance experience ( >=60 ) years aged doctors are reliable and have low error during procedure
Use negation technique
(A) The difference between the error rate of doctors under 30 and of those between 30 and 35
cannot be attributed to the higher level of medical experience possessed by the older doctors. does not weaken the conclusion
(B) Doctors 60 years and above
do make up a meaningfully larger fraction of physicians in Darrenville than doctors between the ages of 30 and 35 do. does not weaken the conclusion
(C) Doctors 60 years and above
are more likely than are doctors 35 and younger to perform medical procedures under circumstances that significantly heighten the risk of errors. does not weaken the conclusion
(D) Doctors 60 years and above, on average,
do , treat a considerably lower number of patients per year than doctors 35 and younger do. breaks the conclusion
OPTION D is correct(E) For all age bracket is the error rate lower than it is for doctors 60 and older.
does not weaken the conclusion
OPTION D is correct