Bunuel
In the city of Velburn, a steep increase in the number of homes with Wi-Fi-enabled security systems over the past five years has coincided with a rise in residential burglaries. Surprisingly, the neighborhoods with the highest concentration of these security systems have seen the greatest increase in burglary rates, even though the systems are designed to promptly alert homeowners and law enforcement to suspicious activity.
Which of the following, if true, most helps to explain the apparent contradiction?
A. Some homeowners in Velburn disable motion or sound sensors to avoid false alarms, unintentionally leaving parts of their homes less secure.
B. Police response times have increased in Velburn due to a surge in non-critical emergency calls.
C. Several regions in Velburn frequently face intermittent internet connectivity issues that disrupt real-time data transmission.
D. Burglars often operate during daytime hours, when security systems are more likely to be left unarmed by homeowners.
E. A large portion of security systems in Velburn rely on cloud-based services that automatically update during nighttime hours.
Gift
12 Days of Christmas Competition
This question is part of our holiday event
Win $40,000 in prizes: courses, tests, and more
In the city of Velburn, over the past five years, the houses have started to enable wifi enabled security system (WESS). This increase is coincided with steep increase in residential burglary.
Another interesting fact is, neighbourhood surrounding the highest concentration of WESS has shown increased burglary rates. This means there is something technically wrong with the product, or malfunctioning could have also be a reason.
The WESS is designed to promptly alert the home owners as well as the Law enforcement agencies, in case of any suspicious activity.
The contradiction here is : WESS is designed to protect crimes, but the neighbourhood surrounding WESS is experiencing increased burglary rates.
A) If some owners disable the sensors or alarms intentionally, then this doesn’t answer why the crime rates are increasing. Hence, Wrong.
B) The Resposne time increase is not mentioned enough to determine the duration of delay. Secondly, this doesn’t explain why the burglary rates have increased. Hence, Wrong.
C) If several regions in Velburn face intermittent (erratic) connectivity issue, which was not manually planned. This connectivity issue has hindered real time data transmission.
If it’s an erratic issue that occurs throughout the region, how did the robbers knew which house WESS has failed now. This raises lots of questions. Does the robber also live in the same locality as they are aware which regions face connectivity issue.
D) Whether the act of burglary has occured in day time or night time is immaterial to the context. The issue is a system which was in place to prevent the crime has failed. Did the WESS perform its job? Why had the burglary rates increased. Neither of this is answered. Hence, Wrong.
E) If large portions of security systems go through the update process at night times, as the systems are connected to a common cloud. This explains the reason, why thefts are rising in a particular locality, that too confined to a particular neighbourhood. This option addresses the neighbourhood experiencing increasing rates of burglary as well as the failure of WESS. Hence, Correct answer.
Option E