Summer is Coming! Join the Game of Timers Competition to Win Epic Prizes. Registration is Open. Game starts Mon July 1st.

It is currently 20 Jul 2019, 11:14

Close

GMAT Club Daily Prep

Thank you for using the timer - this advanced tool can estimate your performance and suggest more practice questions. We have subscribed you to Daily Prep Questions via email.

Customized
for You

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History

Track
Your Progress

every week, we’ll send you an estimated GMAT score based on your performance

Practice
Pays

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History

Not interested in getting valuable practice questions and articles delivered to your email? No problem, unsubscribe here.

Close

Request Expert Reply

Confirm Cancel

A recent study of college students shows that, contrary to predicted

  new topic post reply Question banks Downloads My Bookmarks Reviews Important topics  
Author Message
TAGS:

Hide Tags

Find Similar Topics 
Intern
Intern
avatar
Joined: 18 May 2008
Posts: 3
A recent study of college students shows that, contrary to predicted  [#permalink]

Show Tags

New post Updated on: 10 Oct 2018, 05:00
5
17
00:00
A
B
C
D
E

Difficulty:

  95% (hard)

Question Stats:

41% (02:00) correct 59% (02:06) wrong based on 869 sessions

HideShow timer Statistics


A recent study of college students shows that, contrary to predicted results, special nutritional planning does not positively affect students’ grades. Sixty students, half of whom were given a nutritionally balanced diet, had grades no higher than did those students who were not placed on the diet plan.

Which of the following, if true, is most useful in determining the accuracy of the study described above?


(A) Performance of business executives was shown to improve drastically after major alterations were made in their diets.

(B) Honors students, after altering their diets, maintained that they did not change their study habits.

(C) Students who participated in various fitness regimens found that their grades improved appreciably after they altered their exercise habits.

(D) High school students who previously had low grades found that after they altered their diets, their grades improved dramatically.

(E) All of the college students who volunteered for the study were either in their first or second year of college.

I marked the answer at ii), because if no changes were made to the study habits then we can conclude that there was no effect of study habits on the study, hence effect of diet can be correctly determined (Whether it had some effect or not). But this answer is wrong :(. Can anybody explain the correct answer).

Originally posted by bhatiasanjay01 on 06 Jul 2008, 18:16.
Last edited by Bunuel on 10 Oct 2018, 05:00, edited 1 time in total.
Renamed the topic and edited the question.
Most Helpful Community Reply
VP
VP
User avatar
Joined: 05 Jul 2008
Posts: 1174
Re: A recent study of college students shows that, contrary to predicted  [#permalink]

Show Tags

New post 06 Jul 2008, 18:25
6
contrary to predicted results, special nutritional planning does not positively affect students’ grades

Predicted results would have been special nutritional planning positively affect students’ grades

C & E are out of scope

Among A, B and D

A is using business executive performance improvement. We don't know whether we can relate real time performance improvement to grades (ironically like GMAT and real time) Still I would hold it for now

I agree with your reasoning on B but we simply don't know whether it had any effect or not. But it sounds as if diet did not had any effect Also, we are talking about a subset of students

D is saying low grade HS students with the new diet improved their grades

Look at the Q again.

Which of the following, if true, is most useful in determining the accuracy of the study described above?

D stands on the expected side of results. Probably study is wrong or this case of college students is an anomaly

D is my answer
General Discussion
VP
VP
User avatar
Joined: 03 Apr 2007
Posts: 1082
Reviews Badge
Re: A recent study of college students shows that, contrary to predicted  [#permalink]

Show Tags

New post 07 Jul 2008, 09:54
5
1
Conclusion: special nutritional planning does not positively affect students’ grades.
Evidence:Sixty students, half of whom were given a nutritionally balanced diet, had grades no higher than did those students who were not placed on the diet plan.

The evidence here is weak becuase it provides no details about the student's grade before and after the intake of special diet.Only D brings in information to say students with previously lower grades performed well after they started takin in special diet and refute the conclusion that special diet donot affect student's growth. This answer choice can used to measure the accuracy of this conclusion made in the argument.

D
GMAT Tutor
avatar
G
Joined: 24 Jun 2008
Posts: 1728
Re: A recent study of college students shows that, contrary to predicted  [#permalink]

Show Tags

New post Updated on: 07 Jul 2008, 09:59
1
Interesting question.

bhatiasanjay01 wrote:
A recent study of college students shows that, contrary to predicted results, special nutritional planning does not positively affect students’ grades. Sixty students, half of whom were given a nutritionally balanced diet, had grades no higher than did those students who were not placed on the diet plan.


In blue, I've highlighted the conclusion that is drawn. Is this conclusion part of the study? We don't know. In any case, it's a strange conclusion: from a study of only college students, the writer concludes that nutrition "does not positively affect students’ grades" in general. If you wanted to weaken the conclusion, answer D is a clear choice:

bhatiasanjay01 wrote:
iv) High school students who previously had low grades found that after they altered their diets, their grades improved dramatically.


But weakening the conclusion is not what we're asked to do. The question is:

bhatiasanjay01 wrote:
Which of the following, if true, is most useful in determining the accuracy of the study described above?


I highlighted the part of the stem that refers to the study in red. We're asked to assess the accuracy of the study itself, not the conclusion. We can ignore what I've highlighted in blue. The only answer that refers to the methodology of the study (research methods, population that was studied, etc), is E:

bhatiasanjay01 wrote:
v) All of the college students who volunteered for the study were either in their first or second year of college.


Those studied were volunteers- the sample isn't random- and they were from a particular subset of the overall population. This could affect the vailidity of the study; a properly conducted study might reveal different results. So I agree with gixxer here; the correct answer should be E.
_________________
GMAT Tutor in Toronto

If you are looking for online GMAT math tutoring, or if you are interested in buying my advanced Quant books and problem sets, please contact me at ianstewartgmat at gmail.com

Originally posted by IanStewart on 07 Jul 2008, 09:58.
Last edited by IanStewart on 07 Jul 2008, 09:59, edited 1 time in total.
Manager
Manager
User avatar
Affiliations: University of Tehran
Joined: 06 Feb 2011
Posts: 186
Location: Iran (Islamic Republic of)
Grad GPA: 4
Concentration: Marketing
Schools: Wharton
GMAT 1: 680 Q45 V38
GPA: 4
WE: Marketing (Retail)
Re: A recent study of college students shows that, contrary to predicted  [#permalink]

Show Tags

New post 01 Aug 2011, 09:58
2
Wait... So the fight is so hot b/w D and E. Let us analyze the weak points and strength points of each choice in "determining the accuracy of the study described above":

E: What makes this choice suitable is the fact that it points at some weaknesses in the methodology. Right. So let's put this choice aside for now since it may be the best choice. So, this choice helps us evaluate the accuracy of the study by evaluating the methodology. The methodology in part determines the accuracy of a study.

D:
The problem with E is that since it talks about a test result that was drawn about HIGHSCHOOLS students, it may be considered IRRELEVANT. BUT, on it's good side, choice E states a result from another study-no matter with what kind of subject/sample, that directly stands AGAINST that of the main study. Right? IanStewart, you are right that choice E is an obvious weakener to the conclusion, but what's wrong with it? This fact can not prevent this choice from "determining the accuracy of the study described above"? Not only it's not prevented but also weakening the results, and determining the accuracy of the results of a study are two concepts so close to each other. If we can weaken a conclusion, the perceived accuracy will be decreased.

The golden point is this: Look at the stem again; it says: A recent study of college students shows that, contrary to predicted results, special nutritional planning does not positively affect STUDENT'S grades. The counterargument (what we are to determine the accuracy of the results of a study against it) is about students' performance in general, NOT just performance of COLLEGE students. So a hypothesis about any kind of STUDENTS' performance can be tested by studying ANY KIND of students.

In sum, my choice is D. Though both D and E aim at accuracy of the conclusion, while E focuses on the defects of methodology, D focuses on the DIRECT opposite results found from another VALID study. Do not forget the point: we are talking about a conclusion about ALL students.

What is the source of this question?
_________________
Ambition, Motivation and Determination: the three "tion"s that lead to PERFECTION.

World! Respect Iran and Iranians as they respect you! Leave the governments with their own.
Veritas Prep GMAT Instructor
User avatar
D
Joined: 16 Oct 2010
Posts: 9446
Location: Pune, India
Re: A recent study of college students shows that, contrary to predicted  [#permalink]

Show Tags

New post 05 Aug 2012, 21:30
Actually, there is no ambiguity in the question.

What was the study? 60 students were put on nutritious diet. 60 were not.
What was the result? The 60 students who were put on nutritious diet did not have higher grades than other 60.
What did they conclude? Special nutritional planning does not positively affect students’ grades.

Now, we need to evaluate the accuracy of the study. What will help us figure out whether what we concluded from the study is valid or not?
Because 60 students with diet plans did not get better grades, can we say nutrition does not have any positive affect on grades? Perhaps not. What if nutrition can improve low grades (by giving students more energy and making them more active) and bring them up to average (but not improve average to take them to above average since they need to work hard too)? If this were true, the conclusion of the study would not be valid. Special nutritional planning WOULD have a positive affect on students’ grades. "If grades were low, they could become better by nutritional planning"
Hence option (D) is useful in determining the accuracy of the study.

As for other options, focus on what was concluded from the study. Are they relevant to the conclusion "Special nutritional planning does not positively affect students’ grades."?

(A) Performance of business executives was shown to improve drastically after major alterations were made in their diets.
Not relevant to students' grades.

(B) Honors students, after altering their diets, maintained that they did not change their study habits.
Students saying that they did not alter their diet doesn't mean anything. It is true that they said it but did they actually maintain their study habit or not, we don't know. So not relevant. No need to think further.

(C) Students who participated in various fitness regimens found that their grades improved appreciably after they altered their exercise habits.
Nothing to do with fitness regime and grades. Only food and grades connection is our concern.

(E) All of the college students who volunteered for the study were either in their first or second year of college.
Again, not relevant.
_________________
Karishma
Veritas Prep GMAT Instructor

Learn more about how Veritas Prep can help you achieve a great GMAT score by checking out their GMAT Prep Options >
Veritas Prep GMAT Instructor
User avatar
D
Joined: 16 Oct 2010
Posts: 9446
Location: Pune, India
Re: A recent study of college students shows that, contrary to predicted  [#permalink]

Show Tags

New post 06 Jul 2014, 22:15
HarishLearner wrote:
Wouldn't the fact that Honors' students did not change their study habits remove any bias that might occur? For example if you took the diet and studied well, then the results could have been due to study habits rather than diet. So we need to know this.


We need to find the option that is MOST helpful in determining the accuracy of the study.

The study says "special nutritional planning does not positively affect students’ grades"

(D) says "High school students who previously had low grades found that after they altered their diets, their grades improved dramatically."

This is directly against the result of the study. It implies that the study is not accurate.

Option (B) talks about honors students. We do not know how many students in the study were honors students. So we don't know how relevant this information is to our study.

Hence answer is (D) only.
_________________
Karishma
Veritas Prep GMAT Instructor

Learn more about how Veritas Prep can help you achieve a great GMAT score by checking out their GMAT Prep Options >
Veritas Prep GMAT Instructor
User avatar
D
Joined: 16 Oct 2010
Posts: 9446
Location: Pune, India
Re: A recent study of college students shows that, contrary to predicted  [#permalink]

Show Tags

New post 21 Jul 2014, 23:38
dennis14 wrote:
I dont know why everybody is discussing B and D.

I think we should discuss D and E here.

I think D is useful to determine accuracy however E as well is needed to udnerstand that the sample of students are similar. They are not highest rankers in the class. Top of the top.

So im torn between D and E.

Or the question is incorrect. :|


(E) only tells you that they are 1st or 2nd year students, not 3rd or 4th year. How does that affect your study? Half of them are getting balanced diet and half are not. Even if they were 3rd and 4th year students, why would we challenge the results of the study?
_________________
Karishma
Veritas Prep GMAT Instructor

Learn more about how Veritas Prep can help you achieve a great GMAT score by checking out their GMAT Prep Options >
Manhattan Prep Instructor
User avatar
G
Joined: 04 Dec 2015
Posts: 756
GMAT 1: 790 Q51 V49
GRE 1: Q170 V170
Re: A recent study of college students shows that, contrary to predicted  [#permalink]

Show Tags

New post 22 Aug 2016, 15:08
2
Part of what makes this an unfair question is the phrasing of the sentence "Sixty students, half of whom were given a nutritionally balanced diet, had grades no higher than did those students who were not placed on the diet plan." Is it saying that there was a group of 60 students who all volunteered for the study, half of the volunteers received a nutritious diet, but all 60 (regardless of diet) had higher grades than students who weren't involved in the study? Or is it saying that of the 60 students who volunteered for the study, the half who were given a nutritious diet had the same grades as the half who didn't?

Even though the first reading seems illogical, it's what the sentence is saying, grammatically! But if the second reading is what's intended, I can understand why (E) isn't correct. If every student who volunteered for the study was in the first or second year, including both the students who were given a nutritious diet and the students who weren't, then the result could still be valid. It's not extensible to the entire college population (maybe, for some weird reason, nutrition only affects older students and not younger ones?) but it's still valid, because it's comparing two comparable groups.

(D) is certainly wrong by GMAT standards too, though. The GMAT doesn't accept answers that require that you assume that one group of people is the same as another group of people, without proving it. The argument would have to show that high school students are physiologically the same as college students, for (D) to stand a chance.
_________________
Image

Chelsey Cooley | Manhattan Prep | Seattle and Online

My latest GMAT blog posts | Suggestions for blog articles are always welcome!
GMAT Club Verbal Expert
User avatar
D
Status: GMAT and GRE tutor
Joined: 13 Aug 2009
Posts: 2676
Location: United States
GMAT 1: 780 Q51 V46
GMAT 2: 800 Q51 V51
GRE 1: Q170 V170
Re: A recent study of college students shows that, contrary to predicted r  [#permalink]

Show Tags

New post 03 Apr 2017, 14:17
1
Top Contributor
Usual disclaimer applies here: even the best test-prep companies really struggle to perfectly copy the style of the actual GMAT. And that's particularly true on CR and RC.

This one, in my opinion, is particularly off. Has anybody ever seen an official GMAT question phrased this way?

Quote:
Which of the following, if true, is most useful in determining the accuracy of the study described above?


More importantly: what does that even mean?! Accuracy of the study's conclusions? How carefully the study was conducted? The question itself makes very little sense -- and I have no idea how you would even begin to answer it.

So for anybody worrying about this one: please move on, and use the tags to find discussions of better questions. :)
_________________
GMAT/GRE tutor @ www.gmatninja.com (we're hiring!) | GMAT Club Verbal Expert | Instagram | Blog | Bad at PMs

Beginners' guides to GMAT verbal: RC | CR | SC

YouTube LIVE verbal webinars: Series 1: Fundamentals of SC & CR | Series 2: Developing a Winning GMAT Mindset

SC & CR Questions of the Day (QOTDs), featuring expert explanations: All QOTDs | Subscribe via email | RSS

Need an expert reply? Hit the request verbal experts' reply button; be specific about your question, and tag @GMATNinja. Priority is always given to official GMAT questions.

SC articles & resources: How to go from great (760) to incredible (780) on GMAT SC | That "-ing" Word Probably Isn't a Verb | That "-ed" Word Might Not Be a Verb, Either | No-BS Guide to GMAT Idioms | "Being" is not the enemy | WTF is "that" doing in my sentence?

RC, CR, and other articles & resources: All GMAT Ninja articles on GMAT Club | Using LSAT for GMAT CR & RC |7 reasons why your actual GMAT scores don't match your practice test scores | How to get 4 additional "fake" GMAT Prep tests for $29.99 | Time management on verbal
Current Student
avatar
B
Joined: 04 Aug 2015
Posts: 76
Location: India
Concentration: Leadership, Technology
GMAT 1: 700 Q50 V35
GPA: 3.39
Re: A recent study of college students shows that, contrary to predicted r  [#permalink]

Show Tags

New post 03 Apr 2017, 19:41
1
A recent study of college students shows that, contrary to predicted results, special nutritional planning does not positively affect students' grades. Sixty students, half of whom were given a nutritionally balanced diet, had grades no higher than did those students who were not placed on the diet plan.

Which of the following, if true, is most useful in determining the accuracy of the study described above?

In order to determine the accuracy of the study, we need some information which either bolsters or undermines the argument made by the study. We, also,
have to stick to the same/similar sample space.


A) Performance of business executives was shown to improve drastically after major alterations were made in their diets.

The sample space changes from Students to Executives.

B) Honors students, after altering their diets, maintained that they did not change their study habits.

If we chose this option, it will convey that we are extrapolating the study habits of honors students to improved marks.

C) Students who participated in various fitness regimens found that their grades improved appreciably after they altered their exercise habits.

But here we are talking about diets. This option compromises the setting of the study.

D) High school students who previously had low grades found that after they altered their diets, their grades improved dramatically.

This option presents an information which establishes a positive correlation between diet and grades. This shows that the study is not accurate. Maybe the students those were given nutritionally balanced diet previously scored very poor marks as compared to the other half.

E) All of the college students who volunteered for the study were either in their first or second year of college.

So what?

Thus, option D.
Manager
Manager
User avatar
S
Joined: 05 Mar 2017
Posts: 135
Location: India
Concentration: General Management, Marketing
Schools: LBS '21, ISB '20, IE '22
GPA: 3.6
WE: Marketing (Entertainment and Sports)
Re: A recent study of college students shows that, contrary to predicted  [#permalink]

Show Tags

New post 07 Jul 2019, 02:00
A recent study of college students shows that, contrary to predicted results, special nutritional planning does not positively affect students' grades. Sixty students, half of whom were given a nutritionally balanced diet, had grades no higher than did those students who were not placed on the diet plan.

Which of the following, if true, is most useful in determining the accuracy of the study described above?

In order to determine the accuracy of the study, we need some information which either bolsters or undermines the argument made by the study. We, also,
have to stick to the same/similar sample space.

A) Performance of business executives was shown to improve drastically after major alterations were made in their diets.

The sample space changes from Students to Executives.

B) Honors students, after altering their diets, maintained that they did not change their study habits.

If we chose this option, it will convey that we are extrapolating the study habits of honors students to improved marks.

C) Students who participated in various fitness regimens found that their grades improved appreciably after they altered their exercise habits.

But here we are talking about diets. This option compromises the setting of the study.

D) High school students who previously had low grades found that after they altered their diets, their grades improved dramatically.

This option presents a piece of information which establishes a positive correlation between diet and grades. This shows that the study is not accurate. Maybe the students those were given a nutritionally balanced diet previously scored very poor marks as compared to the other half.

E) All of the college students who volunteered for the study were either in their first or second year of college.

So what?

Thus, option D.
Intern
Intern
avatar
B
Joined: 23 Aug 2016
Posts: 7
GMAT ToolKit User
A recent study of college students shows that, contrary to predicted  [#permalink]

Show Tags

New post 07 Jul 2019, 11:15
Evaluate the conclusion : special nutritional planning does not positively affect students’ grades.

B (close contender): Honors students, top of the class, didn't vary their study practice. If true, it doesn't prove any 'positive result' from nutrition as there simply might not be any room left for improvement amongst these brilliant subjects. If false, that doesn't negate the conclusion either as we simply don't know whether they changed their study habits for good or for worse.

D (winner): Got a Benchmark to compare against. Low grades improved to high grades after altering diets. If true, then the conclusion is negated. If false, then conclusion is reinforced. Only hitch I found is - argument talks about 'college students', but this option talks about a different sample : 'high-school students'. But, finally conclusion is bothered about the link between Nutritional Change -> Grades, not source of the sample.
GMAT Club Bot
A recent study of college students shows that, contrary to predicted   [#permalink] 07 Jul 2019, 11:15
Display posts from previous: Sort by

A recent study of college students shows that, contrary to predicted

  new topic post reply Question banks Downloads My Bookmarks Reviews Important topics  





Powered by phpBB © phpBB Group | Emoji artwork provided by EmojiOne