theacademist
I really just dont understand the rec letter process - the schools could make a fortune more in fees by sharing letters. Rec letters are all that are limiting me at this point :/
Best of luck to everyone!
I think they don't share recommendations primarily because schools want to create as many barriers to entry as possible to keep the total number of applications down and yield up. Since applicants are so different coming into MBA programs, they want to evaluate the whole application instead of just looking at test scores. I'd have applied to 20 or so programs if the recommendations were shared, which is five times the number to which I actually applied. Assuming most people would apply to more programs, they'd either have to hire more people (which would negate some of the benefits of more applications) or not evaluate the applications as thoroughly, which isn't what an HR professional is going to want to do.
Since yield is one way to measure a program's attractiveness to students, schools want to keep that number as high as possible, especially for the schools in the tier below Harvard, Stanford, and Wharton. With fewer barriers to entry, schools like Ross, Yale, Haas, and UCLA would see a big spike in applications because people like me would apply to all four instead of just one (Ross). Since they aren't as attractive to most students, they'd have to issue more acceptance letters to fill their class, and would see yield go down as a result.
For what it's worth, I think the recommendations are kind of stupid. Everyone should be able to find 2-3 people that like them enough to say really positive things. I'm fortunate enough to have a really good friend of mine for a supervisor, so he showed me everything he did. The schools all asked similar questions, but were looking for totally different formats. Some, like Harvard, had a ton of writing while others basically asked him to fill in a bunch of boxes rating me from amazing to really poor. To do a good job, recommenders can't do 10 recommendations in a short time period.