avigutman
Roy867
I chose (E) but realised 2 mistakes.
1. 'high degree accord' is not same as 'unanimous'
- The argument says a 'high degree of both international accord'. It can be 80%, it can be 90% but doesn't say it has to be completely unanimous.
2. Inference questions require something to be inferred.
- In E we can't infer that ' international opinion must be unanimous '. Even if it was written in argument, we can't infer the same thing.
Roy867 Please also note that E is talking about what's necessary for a
blockade to be successful, whereas the text only discusses what's necessary for an
embargo to be successful.
I think most people are confusing
- embargos
For
- blockades
Given the words are inter-changeable, i was confusing the two.
I was thinking the requirements for a succesful
embargo are the same requirements for a succesful
blockade - you need a high degree of international accord in both cases
In fact - the text doesnt mention anyhting about what it takes to have a succesfful
blockadeHence
Quote:
(option E variant # 1) For a blockade of Patria's ports to be successful, international opinion must be unanimous have high international accord = this variant of option E, would be wrong as well as we are not told anything about what it takes to have a succesfful blockade
(option E variant # 2) For a embargo blockade of Patria's ports to be successful, international opinion must have high international accord = this 2nd variant of option E would be right
Quote:
option C variant #1 ) A naval blockade of Patria's ports would ensure that no goods enter or leave Patria == well, a succesful blockade may or may not. We are not told anything about succesful blockades, we are told about succesful embargos
option C variant #2) A naval succesful embargo of Patria's ports would ensure that no goods enter or leave Patria == for a succesful embargo, you need "high degree" of blockage. The blockage doesnt have to be 100 %. Hence wrong.
option C variant #3) A naval succesful embargo of Patria's ports would ensure MOST goods do not enter or leave Patria == i think this is inferable