We will have to agree to disagree. Booth may have a stronger applicant pool from the finance guys, but I doubt that's true across the board.
Chicago is alright, but nothing like a coastal city IMO. And the winters are awful.
I believe people, especially on GC, greatly exaggerate the differences between the top 15-20 schools. Agreed that H, S, and to a lesser extent W, are a cut above, but the rest are pretty interchangeable depending on the candidate's goals, living preference, and scholarship offers.
Then again, you are the guy who jerks it to brand name, so you would be the last person I'd take advice from! All due respect of course.