ozzie123
What's with the obsession of most b-schoolers with IB job anyway (at least before they implode)?
Won't the work in IM/HF/S&T/PE more stimulating than in IB? (this is an honest question)
I have a friend that went into fixed income S&T this past summer at the same firm where I was in the IB. I used to always joke with him that they were going to put him in the basement facing a brick wall to do his job. He'd always respond "C'mon, I'm not that bad", but there's a nugget of truth in the joke. S&T is highly, highly repetitive.
As others have pointed out, PE work at the big LBO shops (all the ones you've heard of) is extremely similar to IB work, and the hours at these shops are very similar to IB as well. Also, the big PE firms do the same thing over and over again, LBOs.
Now, I do find IM and HF work (for the most part different fruits from the same tree) to be more interesting, but again this depends on the job and personal preferences. A big problem with IM/PE/HF is that there is no clear career path up for MBA level students. Because of the structure of the business, there's not much need to promote people past the associate level. And, I wouldn't be all that eager to join an HF or PE firm right now. Their businesses have been crushed and we'll be seeing the wreckage for years to come (even Carlyle had to raise money recently to avoid becoming illiquid). New tax rules aren't going to help either.
The final piece of the pie is that all of these other jobs tend to be harder to land and for the most part are not open to career switchers. It's really tough for career switchers to get into S&T, and PE/HFs almost exclusively look at people who have pre-business school IB experience. Whether they are more stimulating is a matter of opinion, but getting into IB is a reasonable career goal for career switchers at the MBA level hoping to build a career in finance.
Musaabjaved, I don't think Masters in Finance is very useful for a career in investment banking. The firm I was with this past summer had about 100 summer associates and just one was from a Masters in Finance program (Princeton). Now, if you're not talking about an investment banking job, but just a job at an investment bank, there are (used to be actually) opportunities to work in quantitative analysis groups at the banks. These are really people put in the basement facing brick walls, but quants have been exposed in recent months and are really really out of favor these days.