In the correctly worked addition problem above, M, N, R, S, T and V

Question

https://gmatclub.com/forum/download/file.php?id=26553 In the correctly worked addition problem above, M, N, P, R, S, T and V are distinct digits. Is R > 3? (1) M, N and P are positive even integers. (2) S = 2 Alphametic.jpg

Ankur9 · Answer

i think answer is B
I suppose P is also distinct digit

1. M, N and P are positive even integers.
 
if R=3 then 
 M 3
 N 3
 P 3 +
_ _ 9
now take any value of M,N,P from 2,4,6,8 we will get a 3 digit(distinct) sum

if R = 4
then also for any even value of M,N,P from 2,4,6,8 we will get a 3 digit(distinct) sum.
Not sufficient

(2) S = 2
if R = 3
 take any value of M,N,P from 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9 such that there sum gives a 2 digit no with S = 2
this will also get satisfied if R=4
thus not sufficient

(1)+(2)
S=2 and M,N,P from 2,4,6,8 
only R>=7 will satisfy the condition that S(2), T, V all distinct.
i.e. take M,N and P as 4,6,8
 4 7
 6 7
+8 7
2 0 1

Naina1 · Answer

I think it would be C.
Both statements together gives R>3
1 only does not give any information. Consider M, N and P to be 2, 4, 6 respectively. It doesn't tell anything about the value of R.

2 only is also insufficent. If R=3 and M=6 N=7 P=8
It gives S=2
Also, if M=6 N=4 P=2, then for S to be 2 R has to be greater than 3.

1+2) No combination of M, N and P as positive even integers gives the sum >=20. So, in order for S=2 the extra value should come from the sum of R+R+R i.e. 3R and for that R has to be greater than 3.

fhp · Answer

Pretty sure it's D.

With statement 1, adding together any combination of three digits between 2,4,6, and 8 gives you a two digit number with the second digit being one of the already used digits from 2,4,6, and 8. For instance, 2+4+6=12. 4+6+8=18, etc. This means that the ones column, or the Rs, need to add up to be at least 10 so you can carry a 1 and avoid the redundancy between number "T" and numbers "M","N", and "P." In order to achieve that, the "R"s have to be more than 3, since 3+3+3 is 9. Therefore Statement 1 is sufficient.

With statement 2, we know that "M","N" and "P" have to add up to at least 18 (since the most we could carry over from the "R"s in the addition process would be a 2). This means that "M","N" and "P" have to either be 7-6-5, 8-7-6, or 9-8-7.
7+6+5=18, so R would have to be 7 or 9, to get 21 or 27, but both of these involve repeating numbers so they won't work.
8+7+6=21, so R can be any of the remaining numbers, but 3 is the only one that works without any redundancies.
9+8+7=24, so R can be any of the remaining numbers, but again, 1 is the only one that works without any redundancies.
Neither of those possibilities are greater than 3, so statement 2 is also sufficient.

peachfuzz · Answer

https://gmatclub.com/forum/download/file.php?id=26553

M, N, R, S, T and V are distinct digits.

R > 3?

(1) M, N and P are positive even integers
M, N, P could be 2, 4, 6, or 4, 6, 8 or 2, 6, 8
If the digits of M, N, P is 2, 4, 6, then S and T would be 1 and 2. This is not possible because M is 2 and T is 2 and that goes against the "distinct integers" 
In fact, 4,6,8 and 2,6,8 all result in a repeated digit for T.
R then must be relatively larger. in this case at least 4 in order to change the value of T to a digit that is distinct.
Sufficient

(2) S = 2
96+46+76=218
R>3? yes
90+80+70=240
R>3? no
insufficient

Answer: A

KarishmaB · Answer

A quick tip - The two statements cannot give you contradictory answers. They are a part of the same puzzle. If the question is "what is x?" Stmnt 1 cannot give you x = 4 if stmnt 2 gives you x = 5. If you get contradictory answers, it means you have messed up somewhere. Here, apparently, stmnt 1 gives you that R is greater than 3 while stmnt 2 gives you that R cannot be greater than 3 - these contradict. So you must have messed up in one of the statements. Go back to see which one.

Interestingly, four solutions above give four different answers!

yenh · Answer

Correct answer is D.
Here is my explanation:
(1) M, N, P are even integers and cannot be 0 => M, N, P can be any of the set A {2, 4, 6, 8}. In any case M + N + P > 10.
_ Assumption: R < or = 3 => 3R < 10 -> there is no 1 carried to the tenth -> M + N + P is even (sum of 3 even integers is an even integer). So far we know that M, N, P, T are 4 different even integers and cannot be 0 (sum of any 3 even integers in set A above is > 10).
_ Note that sum M + N + P always contains 10 (2+8 or 4+6) -> the unit digit of sum M + N + P will be M/N/P but not T -> contrast to the question stem.
=> Assumption is wrong => R > 3 : Sufficient.

(2) S = 2 => M + N + P + (3R / 10) >= 20. Because Max(M + N + P) = 4 + 6 + 8=18 => 3R > 20 => R > 3 : Sufficient.

Answer: D
Hope you guys can understand my answer

Udai · Answer

Its E because even f we combine both the statements we will be able to get both R>3 and R< 3

EMPOWERgmatRichC · Answer

Hi Bunuel,

Can you confirm that the question is written correctly:

Is "P" supposed to be included in the list of distinct digits or can it be a DUPLICATE of one of them?

GMAT assassins aren't born, they're made,
Rich

KarishmaB · Answer

P is also supposed to be in the list of distinct digits - all digits are distinct. I missed it in the original question.

Bunuel · Answer

Edited. Thank you both!

Bunuel · Answer

VERITAS PREP OFFICIAL SOLUTION: Solution: This is certainly harder than the PS question but our process will remain the same. First, let’s see what information we are given in the question – the units digits of all three numbers are the same. The two-digit numbers add up to give a three digit number. The hundreds digit, S, is either 1 or 2. Three two-digit numbers cannot add up to give a number 300 or more since 99 + 99 + 99 = 297. We have no information on what the value of R can be. All we know is that R cannot be 0 because 0+0+0 = 0 but V needs to be different from R. Let’s look at the statements now. Statement 1: M, N and P are positive even integers. At first, it may seem that this has nothing to do with the value of R but we must analyze what is given to be sure. M, N and P must take distinct values out of 2, 4, 6 and 8 and add up to give the units digit of T (again, distinct) Every time you add three even numbers, you will get an even number. Let’s see which combinations we can get: 2 + 4 + 6 = 12 2 + 4 + 8 = 14 2 + 6 + 8 = 16 4 + 6 + 8 = 18 Note that in all four cases, the units digit is one of the numbers but T must be distinct. This means that there must have been a carryover from the previous addition. So when we added the three Rs, we must have got a carryover. Had R been 3 or less, we would not have got a carryover since 1+1+1 = 3, 2+2+2 = 6 and 3+3+3 = 9. So R must be greater than 3. One such case would be Alphametic1.jpg This statement alone is sufficient. Statement 2: S = 2 The result of addition gives us a number which is more than 200. In statement 1 we saw a case in which S is 2 and R is greater than 3. Now all we have to do is find a case in which S is 2 and R is less than 3. One of these cases is Alphametic2.jpg So this statement alone is not sufficient. Answer (A)

verysecretive3 · Answer

Let's start by analysing the first statement
It is given that M,N and R are positive even integers. We have 4 options for this: 2,4,6,8 The sum of any three of them will give a repeat digit. For eg: 2+4+6= 12 (t=2) This is not possible as M and T must be distinct
 4+6+8= 18 (t=8) This is not possible as M and T must be distinct
For T to be different from M,N and R, it must be odd. This will happen if we have a carry-over from R+R+R=3R
3R>10 for the carry-over hence R>3. Sufficient.

(2) S=2 
This is not sufficient because we get S=2 with values of R greater than 3 and less than 3.

amit9424444 · Answer

I think It' C ,

Statement 1 :- M. N, P positive even integers by this statement we just know the result is a 3 digit number
Even numbers :- Lets see both possibilities
1 :- 82+62+42 =186 this shows r<3
2 :- 89+69+49 = 207 this shows r>3

Statement 2 :- S= 2 (We are here just taking st 2 in consideration only)
1 :- 89+79+69 = 227 R>3
2 :- 82+72+62 = 216 R<3 Both are possibilities

Taking both statement in consideration :- We know s=2 and even numbers taken into consideration.
there are 3 numbers which can be formed 204,207,201 where R has to be greater than 3

Hence it should be C

Bunuel · Answer

You can check the correct answer under the spoiler in the original post.

The stem specifies that "M, N, P, R, S, T and V are  distinct  digits". Do your examples satisfy this condition?

bumpbot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club BumpBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

In the correctly worked addition problem above, M, N, R, S, T and V

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards