ag153
Really do not understand Q5 Choice E.
MartyTargetTestPrep pls answer it the
TTP way. Really struggling with E. I think the whole passage is an answer to the "why" in E. I am not sure why passage 2 will not fit into this "why". Moreover, the passage is saying why the large plants wont lead to economies of scale and the reason is their lack of focus on intangible. I rejected A and was confused b/w C and E before choosing E
Hi ag153.
Question 5 choice (E) is a trap choice that SEEMS to be supported by the passage but actually goes in a direction different from what the passage says.
To see why (E) is not correct, we can carefully compare what the passage says with what (E) says.
The first sentence of the passage says the following:
"Manufacturers have to do more than build large manufacturing plants to realize economies of scale."
Then, continuing to read the passage, we see that the remainder of the passage to a large degree expands on what the first sentence says and adds the idea that, for realizing economies of scale, something else is needed in addition to large manufacturing plants. That something else is intangible capital.
So, what is the point of the passage? It's that, while manufacturing plants are necessary for realizing economies of scale, they are not sufficient for realizing economies of scale. So, "Manufacturers have to do more": they have to invest in intangible capital.
Now, let's look at question 5 choice (E).
(E) explain why large manufacturing plants usually do not help manufacturers achieve economies of scaleNotice that what choice (E) says is quite different from what the passage says. Whereas the point of the passage is that manufacturing plants ARE NECESSARY BUT NOT SUFFICIENT for realizing economies of scale, choice (E) is saying that the point of the passage is that manufacturing plants DON"T HELP AT ALL with realizing economies of scale. So, whereas the direction of what the passage says is that the plants have a role in achieving economies of scale, choice (E) is saying that the point is that the plants have no such role.
Thus, choice (E) is clearly incorrect.
Now, let's consider choice (A).
(A) point out the importance of intangible capital for realizing economies of scale in manufacturingWhile there's more we could do to support choice (A), what we have discussed here indicates that choice (A) accurately describes the primary purpose of the passage.
The correct answer is (A).