SALAKSHYA wrote:
I think the answer is wrong here.
My reasoning for C to be must true is
Most movie critics dislike Hollywood blockbusters. and Some people who dislike Hollywood blockbusters are huge fans of theater.
As per my limited understanding, Option a does not need to be true. My reasoning is:
the arguments does mentions :
If someone dislikes Hollywood blockbusters they are a snob
but reverse need not to be true. There may be some "snob" who does not dislike Hollywood blockbuster
Please correct me if i am wrong.
SALAKSHYA, perhaps quantifying things would help here.
1. A scenario where option C does not have to be true.
->Number of movie critics = 100, no. of movie critics that dislike Hollywood blockbusters = 60 (
most means more than 50%)
->Total number of people who dislike hollywood busters = 10,000,000 (Note that there is no limitation to the number of people who dislike hollywood busters).
->The relevant statement given in the question -
Some people who dislike Hollywood blockbusters are huge fans of theater.
Some means more than 1.
->Now think about it, why would C need to be true? Consider that there are only 2 people (out of the 10 million that dislike hollywood busters) that are fans of theatre. Why would these 2 be the movie critics? They
could be, but they don't have to be.
2. Here is why option A must be true - What you've concluded isn't wrong. I agree there may be a snob who does not dislike hollywood blockbuster, but that's not what this option is about. The option starts with
if someone is not a snob. Now if someone is not a snob, they definitely do not dislike hollywood busters (the question states - If someone dislikes Hollywood blockbusters, they are a snob). Consequently, if someone does not dislike Hollywood blockbusters, they like large explosions. So whoever is not a snob will definitely like large explosions as we know that the non-snobs cannot be the people who dislike hollywood busters.
Hope this helps you out!