Researchers studying workplace productivity randomly assigned clerical workers to two equal groups.
One group was told that their tasks, though routine, were cognitively demanding and vital to the company's operations.
The other group received no such message.
Over the following month,
the first group showed a significant increase in typing speed and error reduction, despite working the same number of hours under identical conditions.
The researchers hypothesized that
the performance gains were caused by the workers' increased perception of their work as mentally engaging and important.
Which of the following would it be most useful to determine in evaluating the researchers’ hypothesis?
(A) Whether clerical workers who perceive their jobs as important are more likely to remain in their positions long term.
The argument in mainly concerned with reason for the performance gains and not about job retention.
Incorrect
(B) Whether those in the first group changed their time spent on personal distractions after receiving the message
This may be useful to determine in evaluating the researchers’ hypothesis.
If yes, then the performance gains were caused after receiving the message, since they changed their time spent on personal distractions
If no, then the performance gains were not caused after receiving the message, since they did not change their time spent on personal distractions
Correct
(C) Whether both groups were equally likely to have prior experience in clerical tasks
This is an additional information and is concerned with sampling bias but we are concerned with evaluating researchers hypothesized with the given logic.
Incorrect
(D) Whether the workers in the first group reported greater satisfaction with their pay after receiving the message
Irrelevant. The argument is not concerned with greater satisfaction with their pay.
Incorrect
(E) Whether routine clerical tasks are commonly perceived as cognitively undemanding
The statement does not provide any help in evaluating the researcher's hypothesis and is mainly concerned with general perception.
Incorrect
IMO B