Under Napoleon the French were not able to organize an adequate supply

Question

Under Napoleon the French were not able to organize an adequate supply system, and it  was a major cause of the failure of their invasion of Russia.

(A) Under Napoleon the French were not able to organize an adequate supply system, and it
(B) The French being unable to organize an adequate supply system under Napoleon
(C) For the French under Napoleon, to be unable to organize an adequate supply system
(D) The inability of the French under Napoleon to organize an adequate supply system
(E) The French inability under Napoleon of organizing an adequate supply system.

Project SC Butler: Day 35: Sentence Correction (SC1) 
 For SC butler Questions  Click Here

ritu1009 · Answer

(A) Under Napoleon the French were not able to organize an adequate supply system, and it -  it refers to what 
(B) The French being unable to organize an adequate supply system under Napoleon -  two verbs being and was in one sentence 
(C) For the French under Napoleon, to be unable to organize an adequate supply system -  inappropriate construction of the sentence 
(D) The inability of the French under Napoleon to organize an adequate supply system -  correct 
(E) The French inability under Napoleon of organizing an adequate supply system. -  to organise is better that of organising 
In the sentence, the reference of it is unknown.

sachinsavailable · Answer

in C and D the word inability portrays a different meaning and hence I believe D and E should be out immediately.  for B i agree with your 2 verbs comment. Amongst A and C C portrays different meaning and implies that" Only the french under Napoleon" .
Considering above I feel A should still be the right choice

Prateekj05 · Answer

The answer choices are very vague and distort the meaning of the sentence.

In option  A , what does  "it"  refer to?  The inability of the French  or  an adequate supply system ?  -> Eliminated

In  B , the use of  "being"  is incorrect. It says that the  French  was the main cause but actually it is the  ability  that was the main cause  -> Eliminated

In  C ,  "to be unable to"  is awkward and idiomatically incorrect -> Eliminated

In  E ,  "French" in "French inability"  is an ambiguous adjective. Idiomatically, it's  "inability to"  and not  "inability of"  -> Eliminated

has the correct construction as well as meaning.  D  should be the correct answer.

Shobhit7 · Answer

IMO, ANS IS D

(A) Under Napoleon the French were not able to organize an adequate supply system, and it: ‘IT’ IS INCORRECT, WE NEED TO REFER TO A FULL CLAUSE AND NOT ANY NOUN. 
(B) The French being unable to organize an adequate supply system under Napoleon: SUBJECT ‘FRENCH’ + PREDICATE ‘WAS A MAJOR CAUSE’ : MEANING CHANGE
(C) For the French under Napoleon, to be unable to organize an adequate supply system: AWKWARD SUBJECT, COULD BE MUCH MORE CLEARER.
(D) The inability of the French under Napoleon to organize an adequate supply system: CORRECT, CLEAR AND CONCISE 
(E) The French inability under Napoleon of organizing an adequate supply system.: FRENCH SHOULD BE IN POSSESSIVE FORM.

Dinkar1910 · Answer

Under Napoleon the French were not able to organize an adequate supply system, and it  was a major cause of the failure of their invasion of Russia.

(A) Under Napoleon the French were not able to organize an adequate supply system, and   it   - "it" has no referent 
(B)  The French being unable to organize an adequate supply system under Napoleon  - here if we remove the redundant part then we have... The French.......was a major cause
(C)  For the French under Napoleon, to be unable to organize an adequate supply system  - awkward construction
(D)  The inability of the French under Napoleon to organize an adequate supply system  -The inability....was.... - correct structure
(E) The French inability  under Napoleon of organizing  an adequate supply system. - awkward construction

lary301254M7 · Answer

Under Napoleon the French were not able to organize an adequate supply system, and it  was a major cause  of the failure of  their  invasion of Russia.

(A)  Under Napoleon the French were not able to organize an adequate supply system , and  it 
(B)  The French being  unable to organize an adequate supply system under Napoleon
(C) For the French under Napoleon, to be unable to organize an adequate supply system
(D)  The inability  of the French under Napoleon to organize an adequate supply system
(E)  The French inability  under Napoleon of organizing an adequate supply system.

Focus on the part not underlined: "was a major cause" ... "their invasion"
What was a major cause? (D), "The inability of French to organize an adequate supply system" 
In (A), it appears that " it " the pronoun is referring to the whole clause. However " it " can only refer to a noun. Eliminate
(B), being ... is describing " The French " and " The French " was not a major cause. Eliminate
(C), I cannot really make sense of this writing. "to be unable to ... was a cause?"
(E), " The French inability " is wrong. This means there are different types of nation's inability. Also, because " French " is now adjective, " their " has nothing to refer to

Ans: (D)

aragonn · Answer

Official Explanation: 
In choice A, it has no logical noun referent; to make complete sense, a noun phrase such as this inability would have to replace it as the subject of was. B also lacks a noun or construction that can be a subject for was. The infinitive to be unable in C wrongly suggests a permanent or general condition rather than a specific instance of failure. In choice E, French inability ... of organizing is badly worded: inability requires to organize, and the inability itself was not French -it was in this historical circumstance a characteristic of the French. Choice D, the best answer, provides idiomatic phrasing and a proper grammatical subject for was

atulindia · Answer

emcheeks · Answer

Under Napoleon the French were not able to organize an adequate supply system, and it  was a major cause of the failure of their invasion of Russia.

(A) Under Napoleon the French were not able to organize an adequate supply system, and it

that "it" could only refer to the "supply system", but that doesn't make any sense

(B) The French being unable to organize an adequate supply system under Napoleon

being is awkward. In addition, where it places the "under Napoleon" makes it sound like the inability was because of Napoleon's control/reign. Changed the meaning

(C) For the French under Napoleon, to be unable to organize an adequate supply system

"to ... is to ..." should be correct

(D) The inability of the French under Napoleon to organize an adequate supply system

Correct
 
(E) The French inability under Napoleon of organizing an adequate supply system.

correct idiom would be: inability of sb to do sth. In addition, it also makes it sound like the inability was because of Napoleon's control/reign. Changed the meaning

PrashantK0099 · Answer

Also, B and E use: The French inability ....
"inability" is a noun and so, "French" is acting as an "adjective". This is wrong usage, since "French" is not an attribute/characteristic of "inability" (remember Adjectives define attribute/characteristic of nouns). In other words, there is no such thing as "French inability", "Indian inability", "German inability" etc.

RohitSaluja · Answer

Hi  VeritasKarishma   GMATNinja   EducationAisle , can you please validate if my line of reasoning to eliminate option choices were correct on this one. Your help would be much appreciated.

(A) Under Napoleon the French were not able to organize an adequate supply system, and it -   it jumps out from this one, and there is no clear antecedent for it, to me "it" seems to reach back to "not able to organize an adequate system" but given its not a noun/noun phrase we can eliminate this

(B) The French being unable to organize an adequate supply system under Napoleon   Though I have yet not come across any official SC question in which usage of being was correct, I tried to think of other reason to eliminate this one, and I eliminated this because to me this option means

The French  being unable to organize an adequate supply system under Napoleon  was a major cause of the failure of their invasion of Russia. Let me know if this is correct, or the issue is something else

(C) For the French under Napoleon, to be unable to organize an adequate supply system   I eliminated this because the phrase "For the French Under Napolean" seemed to implies that there are two category of French one under Napoleon and another not, but that seemed illogical. Let me know if this is correct, or the issue is something else

(D) The inability of the French under Napoleon to organize an adequate supply system   This seemed fine, there are no issues in this

(E) The French inability under Napoleon of organizing an adequate supply system.   to organize seemed better idiom than of organizing, so I eliminated E. Please let me know if this is correct, or the issue is something else

VerbalBot · Answer

Hello from the GMAT Club VerbalBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.

Under Napoleon the French were not able to organize an adequate supply

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Sentence Correction (SC - EA only) Questions

Under Napoleon the French were not able to organize an adequate supply

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards