Early ornithologists often mistook the calling of the Mockingbird as

Question

Early ornithologists often mistook the  calling of the Mockingbird as the rare Rufous Sided Towhee .

A. calling of the Mockingbird as the rare Rufous Sided Towhee

B. call of the Mockingbird for that of the rare Rufous Sided Towhee

C. call of the Mockingbird as the rare Rufous Sided Towhee

D. calling of the Mockingbird for that of the rare Rufous Sided Towhee

E. Mockingbird calling for the rare Rufous Sided Towhee

matzetx · Answer

Hi!
Well the idiom is: mistake + thing/person + for and eliminates thereby answer choices A,C and E.
When comparing B to D, one must chose between the call of the Mockingbird and the callING of the mockingbird.
The call of the mockingbird seems preferable in this sentence structure.

Early ornithologists often mistook the calling of the Mockingbird as the rare Rufous Sided Towhee

A. calling of the Mockingbird   as   the rare Rufous Sided Towhee
B.  call  of the Mockingbird for that of the rare Rufous Sided Towhee
C. call of the Mockingbird   as   the rare Rufous Sided Towhee
D.   calling   of the Mockingbird for that of the rare Rufous Sided Towhee
E.   Mockingbird calling   for the rare Rufous Sided Towhee

blueseas · Answer

hi,
according to meaning context ornithologist mistook the call of MB with the call of some other RST bird.
secondly we have mistook in non underlined part ....and as per the idiom ..mistook - for is the correct idiom.

on the basis of idiom we can eliminate 
A,C=>MISTOOK AS==wrong idiom.
NOW left with B,D,and E
E==>calling is compared to RST BIRD
D==>MISTOOK THE CALLING FOR .....this one is unidiomatic.

hence option B
KUDOS if it helped.

ankurgupta03 · Answer

Thanks for the explanations, but still they do not cater to my doubt

why is call preferred to calling?

blueseas · Answer

hi ankur ,
see actually its all in meaning.
ornithologist: they study birds
in this sentence the meaning coming out that the ornithologist misunderstood the voice of MB for that of other bird.
call = voice. (as per my opinion)
now if you put calling
mistook the calling of A for calling of B.=== as per my opinion this doesn't makes sense.

hope it helps.
what was your approach?

ankurgupta03 · Answer

To some extent yes ... i agree with you, but still not fully convinced

I felt call was better than calling, calling just did not seem right.

Zarrolou · Answer

calling is the ACT. You don't "mistook   the calling  ", you "mistook the   call  ": the actual thing that you hear.

vishnuns39620 · Answer

There is a subtle difference between "the call" and "the calling" :- The call - These two words are totally independant (the call, the sound, the voice etc) - It it is used casually ( I had a call today. The call was from... etc) The calling - These two words together make a different meaning that each word individually. Its a noun - And to be used for somewhat non-common or higher reasons ( does that make sense?

) - The examples are as follows " I had always wanted to be in the army. The calling grew louder as I became an adult" Hope it helps! ( --> https://dictionary.reference.com/browse/calling )

ankurgupta03 · Answer

Hmmm ... you are right in the usage of calling here, but i feel that the usage that you have mentioned is not the one used here ...
Still more or less convinced as to why callingis wrong.

Thanks Zarrlou and vishnuns39620!!

blueseas · Answer

IDOM TESTED  :  MISTOOK - FOR .

basing this we can eliminate option A/C
 
(A) calling of the Mockingbird as the rare Rufous Sided Towhee
  WRONG.  
==INCORRECT IDIOM USAGE.

(B) call of the Mockingbird for that of the rare Rufous Sided Towhee
  CORRECT.

(C) call of the Mockingbird as the rare Rufous Sided Towhee
  WRONG.  
== SAME AS A

(D) calling of the Mockingbird for that of the rare Rufous Sided Towhee
  WRONG.  
== MISTOOK THE CALLING IS AWKWARD ... correct usage = mistook the call....

(E) Mockingbird calling for the rare Rufous Sided Towhee
  WRONG.  
==incoorect comparison...calling compared to bird
== MISTOOK THE CALLING IS AWKWARD ... correct usage = mistook the call....

Divyadisha · Answer

Idiom is 'mistook for' A, C are out

Ornithologists mistook the call and not the mockingbird. E is out

'Call' is better than 'calling'. B is right option.

patrickyip0520 · Answer

"The calling" is a complex gerund which is not kept in parallel with the relative pronoun "that".

amarsinha · Answer

A. not parallel....mistook calling as...the rare
B. seems parallel. ...call of Mockingbird....for that...that represents call. 
C. not parallel
D. seems parallel but calling of the mocking bird is a bit awkward....it is his calling....call is sound of mocking bird but why calling....
E. not parallel

nickrocks · Answer

I took call over calling: " call of the Mockingbird" as the sound which was made by Mockingbird and which was mistaken to be of Rufous Sided Towhee.

gmat1393 · Answer

Hi  generis

Please underline the highlighted part

Thanks!

Bunuel · Answer

_____________________
Done. Thank you.

sayan640 · Answer

B ..
Mistook for " is better..
" call " is better..
Imo

Posted from my mobile device

AdityaHongunti · Answer

"the call" vs "the calling"

Now as per the intended meaning you are comparing a "sound of a particular bird " to the "sound of another bird"

a quality - beauty , intelligence, smartness - is either an adjective or a noun ... as we are comparing nouns we prefer original powerful noun form

"call" - base form of noun - is basically an entity or a particular quirk of the bird

"the calling" - gerund ( non direct) - same function

so it all comes down to how direct you wanna sound ...

SO B

sanjayparihar16 · Answer

There are a number of equally serious errors in this sentence as written. It contains an incorrect usage of the idiom "mistook X for Y"—the preposition "for" should replace "as" in the original. It also contains an illogical comparison, drawing a parallel between the "calling" of the mockingbird and the "rare rufous-sided towhee." Logically, one birdsong should be compared to another, not the song of the mockingbird to the species of the rufous-sided towhee. 
In addition, the sentence should use the noun form "call," rather than the verb "calling," to describe birdsong. 
Scan and Group the Answer Choices:
(B) and (D) correctly compare the two bird calls. (A), (C), and (E) leave the comparison unchanged from the original. (B) and (C) use "call" instead of "calling." (B) and (D) use the correct idiom "mistook ... for" instead of "mistook ... as." 
Eliminate Wrong Answer Choices:
Only (B) and (D) correctly implement the "mistook X for Y" idiom, and only (B) uses the correct noun form of "call." (B) fits perfectly into the original sentence and is correct. 
TAKEAWAY: Comparisons must be in parallel form and compare logically identical items.

CEdward · Answer

I mean B is as obvious a choice as any. But, I agree with Ankur. Why is this the case from a grammatical point of view? Call and calling are both nouns.

I guess the question can be asked differently. Would it be wrong to compare the calling of one bird with that of the other?

Early ornithologists often mistook the calling of the Mockingbird as

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Sentence Correction (SC - EA only) Questions

Early ornithologists often mistook the calling of the Mockingbird as

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards