Bunuel
Anton, Beatrice, and Carl, each running at a constant rate, competed in a 30-kilometer race. The combined time Anton and Beatrice took to finish the race was exactly 3 hours longer than the time Carl took. Did Carl win the race?
(1) None of the three ran faster than 6 kilometers per hour.
(2) Anton finished before Beatrice.
Anton, Beatrice and Carl are running at the constant rates of a,b,c respectively.
The total length of the race = 30 km.
The combined time of Anton and Beatrice (ta + tb) = 3 hours longer than tc.
(ta + tb) = 3 + tc
Has Carl won the race ?
Statement 1:
(1) None of the three ran faster than 6 kilometers per hour.
If the speeds of a,b,c are not greater than 6 kmph. So speeds have to be like 1,2,3,4,5 kmph.
Time Taken = 30/ 6 = 5 hrs.
Time has to be greater than 5 hrs. So the minimum time = 5 hrs.
Nothing conclusive can be ascertained using the given information.
Hence, Insufficient Statement 2:
(2) Anton finished before Beatrice.
speed of Anton > Beatrice.
Nothing linking Carl s speed is mentioned.
Hence, Insufficient
Combining Statements 1 and Statements 2, we get
the speeds of A,B,C or the Time of A,B,C are not given.
Hence, Insufficient
Option E