Rich - thanks for the response! See m answers below and let me know wha you think.
When you took your CATs:
1) Did you take the ENTIRE CAT each time (including the Essay and IR sections)?
For the most part, yes. There may have been one or two that I only did the V and Q sections. However I always made sure to do at least the V and Q sections in that order because that's how I wanted to test.
At first I tried Q then V, but seeing as how I have been consistently hitting Q47+, I found that changing it up seemed to help me more on the verbal side without risking any degradation to quant.
My results are as follows (all first time at taking it):
6/11/17 Default Pack Test 1: 660 Q43/V38
6/18/17 Default Pack Test 2: 640 W43/V33
7/2/17 EP1 Test 1: 660 Q47/V34
7/15/17 REAL TEST: 650 Q47/V33
7/30/17 EP Test 2: 690 Q49/V35
8/6/17 EP2 Test 1: 730 Q47/V44
8/11/17 EP2 Test 2: 690 Q47/V38
8/28/17 REAL TEST 2: 660 Q47/V34
2) Did you take them at home?
Yes - it is where i have done al of my studying. I know this can be a factor, but I have been very diligent to make it as "test like" as possible - strict break times, no phone, no interruptions, etc.
3) Did you take them in the same order as you took the sections on Test Day?
The last four, yes.
4) Did you take them at the same time of day as when you took your Official GMAT?
Yes - always in the morning
5) Did you ever do ANYTHING during your CATs that you couldn't do on Test Day (pause the CAT, skip sections, take longer breaks, etc.)?
Not that I can remember..
6) Did you ever take a CAT more than once? Had you seen any of the questions BEFORE?
Between the last practice test and my second real test, I retook the old Exam Packs as practice for timing and refresh. I know my scores would be inflated here, but I was consistently getting V40+ on the retakes.
Looking back - I think the gaps between the last practice tests and the real test may have something to do with it... I was feeling really good after I took the EP2 tests (as my scores indicated) but the lag between those and the real test could have affected me? That lag was due to some scheduling conflicts/earliest possible available dates.
Like I said, I KNOW I can hit a V38+, but I just keep falling short on test day. I feel like I'm falling in and out of "peak performance" and I don't know how to stay there, if that makes sense? I have worked so hard on this, and I feel very confident on the quant side. I just feel like I'm so close to being able to break the 700 mark if I could just round out verbal.