mcschan86
Thank you for these tips. I'm struggling to find content for the optional essay.
Should I use this space to justify my relatively weak GMAT and emphasize my value in multiple years of international exposure in an unique industry?
I doubt it would be a disadvantage to leave it blank. On the other hand, it might even be a disadvantage to force something in there, am I correct?
mcschan86 What I do know for sure is that, leaving an optional essay blank will NOT harm you. I left mine blank (despite not exactly covering myself in glory with an incredibly high GMAT score that is "expected" from Indian applicants) and it worked out pretty well.
Honestly, justifying a low GMAT score is unfortunately seen as "justifying" and when you do that you risk the adcom wondering "why not re-take the GMAT if the applicant himself/herself is not convinced that the GMAT score isn't the best reflection of his/her abilities?" If you are trying to use the optional essay to justify your GMAT, remember, its not just about "why you slipped in the previous attempt" but you also need to succinctly find the right tone to subtly justify "why you can't retake the GMAT in the future to substantiate your claim, especially when you are allowed to re-take in a couple of weeks?" (trust me, the sweet spot for the right tone to justify this is incredibly minuscule). In my experience, I have found the latter to be the more difficult point to justify, unless you have a genuinely extenuating circumstance that doesn't allow you to re-take. Keep in mind INSEAD doesn't encourage re-applicants. Therefore, they expect you to apply to INSEAD when you are convinced and confident about putting your best foot forward.
On the upside, INSEAD is one of the very few top business schools that do not overtly obsess about GMAT more than the other data points, such as GPA, work ex - quality and quantity, international exposure, essays, interviews, etc. Infact, it would be safer for you to use the optional essay to justify a relatively low GPA or a gap inbetween professional switchovers (if you have any) because, unlike the GMAT, you can not control the outcomes of any of these data points anymore and justifying them honestly will help you present the complete picture to the adcom. My advice to you would be to take a step back, and assess (don't fret) your GMAT score. If you feel you are within the +/- 20 points of the school average (and if you are convinced you can't/don't want to retake the GMAT), then your time would be better spent in orchestrating an irresistible application with articulate essays and compelling narratives that would offset your GMAT deficit and draw the adcom towards your strengths rather than dishing them out a whole optional essay to justify the low GMAT score. So I implore you to re-think your strategy about your optional essay. The more information you give the adcom, the more scrutiny you invite on your application which in turn creates more doubts about your candidacy.
As Polonius in Shakespeare's Halet once said "Brevity is the soul of wit" - sometimes Less is More. So be Concise Confident and Convincing - in my opinion, that is what the adcom would like to see more than a guy fretting to justify a low GMAT score.
Hope this helps.