bizwiz84 wrote:
slee26 wrote:
Ward2012 wrote:
Oh geez. I think Kellogg really needs to scrap the video essay. Clearly, the technical issues haven't been resolved.
I say that even though I think I did well on my video essay. It's not fair to everyone when it's working for some people and not working for others.
definitely. it's not fair. and i hate feeling nervous about whether it will negatively affect my candidacy or not.
If you truly believe adcom would allow technical issues in a new application component to negatively affect your candidacy, why would you want to go to Kellogg in the first place? Do you want to go to school where the staff is unfair and inconsiderate?
Seriously, application season is stressful and everything, I get it, but sometimes I think people write a post just because they have nothing better to do. I find it hard to believe that an intelligent, accomplished professional who wants to attend one of the best business schools in the world, would TRULY believe that this could be an issue.
Go grab a beer, people, and relax! Remember - there are intelligent people at Adcom, too. The process is not run by machines, you know.
Yes, I believe the AdCom when it says these tech issues will not negatively affect an application, but as others have mentioned, those who were able to successfully complete the video were able to give the AdCom an extra piece of information that those with tech issues could not. That lack of opportunity to give that extra piece of information is the issue.
And, I respectfully think that you're giving Kellogg too much of a pass on this situation. Kellogg instituted major changes to its application, and while yes of course, at the end of the day, we're all human, Kellogg really should have tested its application more thoroughly before releasing it. The video hasn't been the only problem. People have been complaining about fields going blank on the form or other error messages. I experienced these myself up until two days before the deadline, when the Admissions Office finally resolved the problem.
That said, at the end of the day, I don't think the video is going to have any major impact on the AdCom's decisions since there have been so many problems.