dcoolguy
Hello experts,
I got stuck in question 3 primary purpose between A and E
heres how I interpreted paras-
first para- author presents what motivates consumer to try new products
1 study- price effects- PPR (perception)
while another study- price has less or no effect on PPR - challanging previos study
2nd para-
study- source's credibility effects- PPR
but another study - source credibility's effect is complex; its price+credibility effects - PPR (again some how challanging)
therefore I chose A
challenging the implications of previous research into why consumers try new products
however in E
discussing certain findings regarding why consumers try new products
but passage is talking about- what motivation consumers trying new products- is it price or advertisement or source. Why consumer try new product is vague and not related
where I am wrong?
please explain!
Thanks
Forget what the passage says for a moment.
Read answer choice A on its own:
A. [The passage is primarily concerned with] challenging the implications of previous research into why consumers try new products.
Write out, in your own words, without thinking about this actual passage, what a passage would look like if this were its primary concern.
(please do this--it will be better for you to try it yourself before reading on).
Here's what I would expect to see in such a passage:
The passage would lay out research on why consumers try to new products. It would then lay out what some people have determined that research implies--meaning, some people would suggest that the research tells us something more--something we should do, know, consider, or try--then what the research itself showed. (E.g. Imagine research that found out that too much sugar is bad for you, and someone suggested this means the government should severely limit the amount of sugar allowed it foods). This passage would then challenge these implications. It would question whether the research really implies what some people are arguing the research implies.
Compare my summary to yours. Where are they similar? Where are they different? Is there certain word I latched onto in the answer that you paid less attention to?
Determine whose 'idea' for what the passage would be in order to justify choosing 'A' is most correct, or rewrite your own that you think captures the idea best.
Now do a similar thing for E:
E. [The passage is primary concerned with] discussing certain findings regarding why consumers try new products.
My summary is something like:
The passage would lay out several different studies that researched why consumers try new products, and what their findings were.
Now reread the passage.
Does it, in fact, challenge the implications of of previous research?
Or does it, perhaps, simply lay out what the research was?