Review for: Menlo Coaching.
I think I’ve written 1 other review in my life and I’m pretty sure it was to get $10 off for food delivery (college student budget).
Now with that said, out of my own volition I decided to accumulate the required post count solely so I could post in this thread and sing the praises of Alice Van Harten and David White from
Menlo Coaching.
I decided in May 2016 to take a serious run at applying to Business School. Unfortunately, my work / extracurricular are significantly demanding and, even with the research I had done on the application process, I still felt unsure as to how to best position my “story.” I was familiar with admission consultants and figured since they all offered a free initial consult I would receive some insight.
Awful. Perhaps it was my misfortune but a good amount of consultants I spoke with either:
(i) gave a stereotypical used car salesman vibe
(ii) forced me into a bucket without hearing my life experiences.
A few were helpful but I just didn’t get the “I want this person in my corner” feeling.
Enter
Menlo Coaching.
I actually came across Alice and David’s company through the 2016 version of this thread. The reviews seemed so unbelievable that I had to reach out.
To anyone reading this thread, I will save you some time by saying: set up a consult and speak with them. That experience will speak to the quality of
Menlo Coaching far better than I could.
For my initial consult, I spoke with Alice and let me tell you, she is smart. Seriously smart. The kind of intelligence that impresses and draws you in within the first few minutes.
She knows the admission game backwards and forwards. She genuinely cares about your success (not just in getting into a school but also your career) but at the same time, she is upfront and pragmatic about everything. While I was driving my story and the work, I kept getting constructive feedback and soon the application process stopped feeling like a chore.
Moreover, she has a bell personality. All the personalities of her clients are different yet she can resonate with all of them and knows the right way to communicate with them. Beyond the application process, I learned quite a bit on how to be successful in general.
Working with
Menlo Coaching felt like I had all the answers in my back pocket.
I applied to 4 schools and received admissions to Wharton (near full-tuition waiver.. this shocked me) and Booth (high scholarship … also surprising). I’m waiting to hear from HBS in round 2 so we’ll see. I would not have achieved these results with other firms or alone (I can say this with confidence).
Menlo’s approach to strategy is otherworldly.
I *know* for sure because every now and then I reread my essays. They contain my story and do not contain a single fabrication yet I never would have thought about taking that approach or angle. However, when I read them I can’t help but think “wow I would totally want this kid in my class!”
On a tangent note: I’ve worked two different high-finance jobs in my career and consider myself a strong interviewer. I worked with David for less than an hour to prepare for my Booth interview. When I finished my interview, I confidently told David and Alice it was the best interview of my life. I *knew* I would get the Booth offer and this is not from a place of ego but just to speak as to how well David prepared me.
In short, work with
Menlo Coaching.
Do not wait too late though as I know their spots fill up rather quickly. When I spoke with Alice in May, she had mentioned that she expected to be fully booked in a few weeks. I believed her, that is just how strong of a consultant she is.
Moreover, when you look at it from a Quality to Value ratio, the other consultants just are not in the same league.