Author 
Message 
TAGS:

Hide Tags

Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 48037

t and w are distinct integers between 105 and 100, not inclusive. Whic
[#permalink]
Show Tags
20 Jul 2017, 21:52
Question Stats:
37% (01:52) correct 63% (02:16) wrong based on 167 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics




Intern
Joined: 30 May 2013
Posts: 29
GMAT 1: 600 Q50 V21 GMAT 2: 640 Q49 V29

t and w are distinct integers between 105 and 100, not inclusive. Whic
[#permalink]
Show Tags
25 Jul 2017, 13:14
Bunuel wrote: t and w are distinct integers between 105 and 100, not inclusive. Which of the following could be the units digit of positive integer ‘n’, if t > w + 1, where \(n = (t^w  w^t)^w?\)
A. 0 B. 1 C. 2 D. 3 E. 4 Ans (A) Interesting problem. From Qn we can deduce the following values for t & w: t w 103 101 ==> (103^101  101^103)^101  case(1) 104 102 ==> (104^102  102^104)^102  case(2) 104 101 ==> (104^101  101^104)^101  case(3) Now, before proceeding further, we must know two important number theory rules: Rule#1 : Cyclicity for units digits of all natural numbers is 4 i.e. after every four occurrences, units digit must repeat. Based on this rule, above cases will give the following results: Case(1) : 31 = 2 (units digit) Case(2) : 66 = 0 (units digit) Case(3) : 41 = 3 (units digit) Rule#2: For scenario like a^b  b^a, it will give negative result as we increase the value of a and b. Lets check this in a pattern using numbers: 2^1  1^2 = 21 = 1 3^2  2^3 = 98 = 1  For numbers after this, we will get negative values. 4^3  3^4 = 6481 = 17 7^5  5^7 = 1680778125 = Big negative no . . Now, going back to our cases, for case(1) & Case(3) : (103^101  101^103)^101 = A negative no odd no of times will yield a negative no (104^101  101^104)^101 = A negative no odd no of times will yield a negative no But for Case(2) (104^102  102^104)^102 = A negative no even no of times will yield a positive no [ The question statement clear mentioned the positive value of n] Thanks!




Manager
Joined: 18 May 2017
Posts: 54

t and w are distinct integers between 105 and 100, not inclusive. Whic
[#permalink]
Show Tags
21 Jul 2017, 01:02
Bunuel  is there any mistake in the question/answers? i tried to solve it but something doesn't work for me. Here is my analysis. As t and w are between 100 to 105 not inclusive, and as t>w+1, the options for the values of t and w are limited (three options): (1) t=103 and w=101; (2) t=104 and w=101; (3) t=104 and w=102. Now we can check what will be the units digit in each of those cases. In the first scenario we have (103^101  101^103)^101. The units digit of 103^101 is 3 and the units digit of 101^103 is 1, so the units digit of the expression in brackets is 2 (31). While we raise the number in brackets in a power of 101 we get a units digit of 2. In the second case we have (104^101  101^104)^101. The units digit of 104^1 will be 4 and the units digit of 101^104 will be 1, so the units digit of the expression in brackets will be equal to 3 (41). When we raise the number in a power of 101, the units digit suppose to be 3. In the last case the units digit of 104^102 is 6 and the units digit of 102^104 is 6, so the units digit of the expression (104^102102^104) will be zero. We'll get the same units digit after raising the number in power of 102. So it seems to me that there is more than one correct answer. But maybe i got wrong in my solution :/



Senior Manager
Joined: 15 Jan 2017
Posts: 367

Re: t and w are distinct integers between 105 and 100, not inclusive. Whic
[#permalink]
Show Tags
25 Jul 2017, 11:59
I also thought of approximation taking t =104 and w = 102 So I plug in: (104^102  102^104)^102 => going by the last digit rule => (4^2  2^4)^102 = zero However using 103 and 101, answer is 2 in units digit Will wait for the detailed OA



Manager
Joined: 13 Apr 2017
Posts: 86
Location: India
Concentration: General Management, International Business
GPA: 3.4
WE: Engineering (Energy and Utilities)

Re: t and w are distinct integers between 105 and 100, not inclusive. Whic
[#permalink]
Show Tags
28 Jul 2017, 12:07
praveen8047 wrote: Bunuel wrote: t and w are distinct integers between 105 and 100, not inclusive. Which of the following could be the units digit of positive integer ‘n’, if t > w + 1, where \(n = (t^w  w^t)^w?\)
A. 0 B. 1 C. 2 D. 3 E. 4 Ans (A) Interesting problem. From Qn we can deduce the following values for t & w: t w 103 101 ==> (103^101  101^103)^101  case(1) 104 102 ==> (104^102  102^104)^102  case(2) 104 101 ==> (104^101  101^104)^101  case(3) Now, before proceeding further, we must know two important number theory rules: Rule#1 : Cyclicity for units digits of all natural numbers is 4 i.e. after every four occurrences, units digit must repeat. Based on this rule, above cases will give the following results: Case(1) : 31 = 2 (units digit) Case(2) : 66 = 0 (units digit) Case(3) : 41 = 3 (units digit) Rule#2: For scenario like a^b  b^a, it will give negative result as we increase the value of a and b. Lets check this in a pattern using numbers: 2^1  1^2 = 21 = 1 3^2  2^3 = 98 = 1  For numbers after this, we will get negative values. 4^3  3^4 = 6481 = 17 7^5  5^7 = 1680778125 = Big negative no . . Now, going back to our cases, for case(1) & Case(3) : (103^101  101^103)^101 = A negative no odd no of times will yield a negative no (104^101  101^104)^101 = A negative no odd no of times will yield a negative no But for Case(2) (104^102  102^104)^102 = A negative no even no of times will yield a positive no [ The question statement clear mentioned the positive value of n] Thanks! Hi Praveen, Quick question, In the cases 1 and 3, how can we be sure that the units digit it 2 and 3 respectively when as stated by Rule #2 the first number will be smaller than the second? Thanks!



Current Student
Joined: 20 Mar 2014
Posts: 2643
Concentration: Finance, Strategy
GPA: 3.7
WE: Engineering (Aerospace and Defense)

Re: t and w are distinct integers between 105 and 100, not inclusive. Whic
[#permalink]
Show Tags
28 Jul 2017, 12:21
Bunuel wrote: t and w are distinct integers between 105 and 100, not inclusive. Which of the following could be the units digit of positive integer ‘n’, if t > w + 1, where \(n = (t^w  w^t)^w?\)
A. 0 B. 1 C. 2 D. 3 E. 4 Good question to check concepts for cyclicity. This question is a "could be" and not "must be" and thus is tells us that picking 1 set of values for t and w should do the trick. DO note that t>w+1 such that 100< t,w<105. The only possible sets for (t,w) are (104,102), (103,101) and (104,101). I will take (104,102) as I like to play around with even numbers and because I know 2 and 4 have 4 and 2 as cyclicity. Taking that into account, n = \((104^{102}  102^{104})^{102}\) Treating them separately, units digit of 104^102 will be the same as that for 4^2 = 16 = 6 as the unit's digit. Similarly, Units digit for 102^104 will be the same as that for 2^4 (as 104 is divisible by 4, cyclicity of 2). 2^4 = 16 and as such the unit's digit will be =6. Now realize that as both the unit's digits (for 104^102 and 102^104)=6, the difference (t^ww^t) = 0 and 0 ^ (any power) = 0. A is thus the correct answer. Hope this helps.



Intern
Joined: 30 May 2013
Posts: 29
GMAT 1: 600 Q50 V21 GMAT 2: 640 Q49 V29

Re: t and w are distinct integers between 105 and 100, not inclusive. Whic
[#permalink]
Show Tags
28 Jul 2017, 23:02
Dkingdom wrote: praveen8047 wrote: Bunuel wrote: t and w are distinct integers between 105 and 100, not inclusive. Which of the following could be the units digit of positive integer ‘n’, if t > w + 1, where \(n = (t^w  w^t)^w?\)
A. 0 B. 1 C. 2 D. 3 E. 4 Ans (A) Interesting problem. From Qn we can deduce the following values for t & w: t w 103 101 ==> (103^101  101^103)^101  case(1) 104 102 ==> (104^102  102^104)^102  case(2) 104 101 ==> (104^101  101^104)^101  case(3) Now, before proceeding further, we must know two important number theory rules: Rule#1 : Cyclicity for units digits of all natural numbers is 4 i.e. after every four occurrences, units digit must repeat. Based on this rule, above cases will give the following results: Case(1) : 31 = 2 (units digit) Case(2) : 66 = 0 (units digit) Case(3) : 41 = 3 (units digit) Rule#2: For scenario like a^b  b^a, it will give negative result as we increase the value of a and b. Lets check this in a pattern using numbers: 2^1  1^2 = 21 = 1 3^2  2^3 = 98 = 1  For numbers after this, we will get negative values. 4^3  3^4 = 6481 = 17 7^5  5^7 = 1680778125 = Big negative no . . Now, going back to our cases, for case(1) & Case(3) : (103^101  101^103)^101 = A negative no odd no of times will yield a negative no (104^101  101^104)^101 = A negative no odd no of times will yield a negative no But for Case(2) (104^102  102^104)^102 = A negative no even no of times will yield a positive no [ The question statement clear mentioned the positive value of n] Thanks! Hi Praveen, Quick question, In the cases 1 and 3, how can we be sure that the units digit it 2 and 3 respectively when as stated by Rule #2 the first number will be smaller than the second? Thanks! Hi DKingdom, Cyclicity for numbers is calculated as described below, but before that we should know that the cyclicity of all natural numbers is 4. That means after every 4th occurrence, pattern will repeat. For ex: 3^1 = 3 (Units Digit=3) 3^2 = 9 (U D=9) 3^3 = 27 (U D=7) 3^4 = 81 (U D=1) 3^5 = 243 (U D=3) 3^6 = 729 (U D=9)...... So on. Here the pattern is 3,9,7,1,3,9,...... Hence we can see that Units Digit repeat after every 4th occurrence. This is true for all the natural numbers Now, to calculate 3^101 = 3^(100+1) = 3^(4*25 + 1) = 3^1 = 1. Here 101 is broken into 100 + 1 as 100 is closest multiple of 4. Hence, 103^101 = 3^101 = 3(Units Digit) 101^103 = 1^103 = 1(Units Digit) Hence, 103^101  101^103 = 31 =2. Similarly, we can get the vales for other cases also. Using above method, we can calculate the Units Digit for all the cases. But the question is asking for positive result. Now, we can use the Rule#2, to discard negative numbers. I hope, this was helpful. Thanks!



Manager
Joined: 19 Aug 2016
Posts: 87

Re: t and w are distinct integers between 105 and 100, not inclusive. Whic
[#permalink]
Show Tags
19 Oct 2017, 19:52
Engr2012 wrote: Bunuel wrote: t and w are distinct integers between 105 and 100, not inclusive. Which of the following could be the units digit of positive integer ‘n’, if t > w + 1, where \(n = (t^w  w^t)^w?\)
A. 0 B. 1 C. 2 D. 3 E. 4 Good question to check concepts for cyclicity. This question is a "could be" and not "must be" and thus is tells us that picking 1 set of values for t and w should do the trick. DO note that t>w+1 such that 100< t,w<105. The only possible sets for (t,w) are (104,102), (103,101) and (104,101). I will take (104,102) as I like to play around with even numbers and because I know 2 and 4 have 4 and 2 as cyclicity. Taking that into account, n = \((104^{102}  102^{104})^{102}\) Treating them separately, units digit of 104^102 will be the same as that for 4^2 = 16 = 6 as the unit's digit. Similarly, Units digit for 102^104 will be the same as that for 2^4 (as 104 is divisible by 4, cyclicity of 2). 2^4 = 16 and as such the unit's digit will be =6. Now realize that as both the unit's digits (for 104^102 and 102^104)=6, the difference (t^ww^t) = 0 and 0 ^ (any power) = 0. A is thus the correct answer. Hope this helps. Excellent explanation!!



Senior Manager
Joined: 15 Jan 2017
Posts: 367

Re: t and w are distinct integers between 105 and 100, not inclusive. Whic
[#permalink]
Show Tags
05 Dec 2017, 14:39
Was revisiting this question  I am still now sure why the 101,103 pair is being rejected. Cyclicity wise, 104,102 makes sense, but a different and positive answer is given by [103^101  101^103] ^101
Would be glad to know any explanation on this




Re: t and w are distinct integers between 105 and 100, not inclusive. Whic &nbs
[#permalink]
05 Dec 2017, 14:39






