Tourism Commission (A) Meaning (reducing the guests)
(B) Modifier / Meaning (ultimately); Idiom (goal to reduce)
(C) Modifier (with the hotel service); Idiom (goal to reduce)
(D) Modifier / Meaning (ultimate); Subject-Verb (guests that ends up)
(E) CORRECT
First glanceMost of the choices begin with prepositions (with, in); in the case of choice (C), just one word (
ultimately) precedes a preposition (with). The problem is testing something related to
Modifiers.
Issues(1) Meaning: reducing the guests
Modifier / Meaning: ultimately; ultimate
The original sentence says that the commission conducted surveys in order to
reduce the guests. Literally, this means to reduce the
size of the guests. Perhaps they’ve invented an
incredible shrinking ray gun?
Probably not—this meaning is illogical. Presumably, the goal was to reduce the
number of guests or the
number of complaints. Eliminate choice (A) for faulty meaning.
While examining the first issue, you might spot another one. The original sentence describes the ultimate goal of the surveys. Other choices move this word around or change the form to
ultimate. Check them for proper placement and meaning.
(A) with the
ultimate goal
(B) with the goal to
ultimately reduce
(C)
ultimately with the goal
(D) in an
ultimate attempt
(E) with the
ultimate goal
An
ultimate goal is a decisive or final goal; this meaning makes logical sense for the sentence. Nothing indicates, however, that this is the
final attempt to achieve the goal; why wouldn't the commission be able to keep trying? Eliminate (D) for an
unlikely meaning.Choice (B) changes the form to
ultimately (an adverb) and places it with the verb
to reduce. The goal is not to
finally reduce the number of guests. Rather, the surveys have a final or ultimate goal. Eliminate choice (B).
(2) Idiom: goal to reduceTwo choices say with the goal of reducing, while two others say with the goal to reduce. (The fifth removes this structure entirely.) Eliminate choices (B) and (C).
The correct idiom is with the goal of (doing something).
(3) Modifier: with the hotel serviceFour of the choices talk about dissatisfaction with the hotels’ service (or with the service in hotels). In choice (C), though, the modifier moves:
(c)...... overall dissatisfaction
by the guests with the hotel servicePrepositional phrases can modify
nouns or
verbs. If a prepositional phrase begins just after a noun, the general expectation is that it is modifying that noun. In this case, then,
with the hotel service would be modifying
guests—but the point of the sentence is not to discuss
the guests with the hotel service. All of the relevant guests stayed in hotels. The point is to call out those guests who are dissatisfied with the hotel service. Eliminate answer (C) for faulty modifier placement leading to illogical meaning.
(4) Subject-Verb: guests that ends upChoice (D) uses the construction
reduce the number of guests that ends up expressing … dissatisfaction.. The plural
guests express dissatisfaction, so they end up expressing dissatisfaction. The singular verb
ends does not match with the plural subject
guests. Eliminate choice (D).
The Correct Answer
Correct answer (E) conveys a logical meaning throughout: the surveys have an ultimate, or final, goal; the goal is to reduce the number of guests; those guests express … dissatisfaction with the hotels’ service.