Official Solution: If a price was increased by \(x\%\) and then decreased by \(y\%\), where x and y are both non-zero, is the new price higher than the original? Let \(P\) represent the original price.
(1) \(x > y\).
If \(x\) is significantly larger than \(y\), the new price is higher than the original. However, if \(x\) is only slightly larger, the new price is lower. For example, if \(x = 20\) and \(y = 19\), the new price is \(P*1.20*0.81 < P\).
(2) \(x = 1.2y\)
Similar reasoning applies here. If \(y\) is large, the new price is smaller (if \(y = 100\), the new price is 0). If \(y\) is small, the new price is higher than the original (if \(y = 10\), the new price is \(P*1.12*0.9 = P*1.008 > P\)).
(1)+(2) Combining Statement 1 with Statement 2 provides no additional information. For example, if \(P = 100\), \(x = 120\), and \(y = 100\), the new price becomes 0, which is lower than the original price of 100. However, if \(P = 100\), \(x = 12\), and \(y = 10\), the new price becomes \(100 * 1.12 * 0.9 = 100 * 1.008\), which is higher than the original price of 100. Therefore, the given information is not sufficient to determine whether the new price is higher or lower than the original price.
Answer: E