The deep sea typically has a sparse fauna dominated by tiny worms and

Question

New Project RC Butler 2019  -  Practice 2 RC Passages Everyday   
Passage # 218, Date : 20-Jul-2019
 This post is a part of New Project RC Butler 2019 .  Click here for Details

The deep sea typically has a sparse fauna dominated by tiny worms and crustaceans, with an even sparser distribution of larger animals. However, near hydrothermal vents, areas of the ocean where warm water emerges from subterranean sources, live remarkable densities of huge clams, blind crabs, and fish.

Most deep-sea faunas rely for food on particulate matter ultimately derived from photosynthesis, falling from above. The food supplies necessary to sustain the large vent communities, however, must be many times the ordinary fallout. The first reports describing vent faunas proposed two possible sources of nutrition: bacterial chemosynthesis, production of food by bacteria using energy derived from chemical changes, and advection, the drifting of food materials from surrounding regions. Later, evidence in support of the idea of intense local chemosynthesis was accumulated: hydrogen sulfide was found in vent water; many vent-site bacteria were found to be capable of chemosynthesis; and extremely large concentrations of bacteria were found in samples of vent water thought to be pure. This final observation seemed decisive. If such astonishing concentrations of bacteria were typical of vent outflow, then food within the vent would dwarf any contribution from advection. Hence, the widely quoted conclusion was reached that bacterial chemosynthesis provides the foundation ,for hydrothermal-vent food chains - an exciting prospect because no other communities on Earth are independent of photosynthesis.

There are, however, certain difficulties with this interpretation. For example, some of the large sedentary organisms associated with vents are also found at ordinary deep-sea temperatures many meters from the nearest hydrothermal sources. This suggests that bacterial chemosynthesis is not a sufficient source of nutrition for these creatures. Another difficulty is that similarly dense populations of large deep-sea animals have been found in the proximity of " smokers " -vents where water emerges at temperatures up to 350° C. No bacteria can survive such heat, and no bacteria were found there Unless smokers are consistently located near more hospitable warm-water vents, chemosynthesis can account for only a fraction of the vent faunas. It is conceivable, however, that these large, sedentary organisms do in fact feed on bacteria that grow in warm-water vents, rise in the vent water, and then rain in peripheral areas to nourish animals living some distance from the warm-water vents.

Nonetheless, advection is a more likely alternative food source. Research has demonstrated that advective flow, which originates near the surface of the ocean where suspended particulate matter accumulates, transports some of that matter and water to the vents. Estimates suggest that for every cubic meter of vent discharge, 350 milligrams of particulate organic material would be advected into the vent area. Thus, for an average-sized vent, advection could provide more than 30 kilograms of potential food per day. In addition, it is likely that small live animals in the advected water might be killed or stunned by thermal and/or chemical shock thereby contributing to the food supply of vents.   1 
 C 
 1. The passage provides information for answering Which of the following questions?

(A) What causes warm-water vents to form? 
(B) Do vent faunas consume more than do deep-sea faunas of similar size? 
(C) Do bacteria live in the vent water of smokers? 
(D) What role does hydrogen sulfide play in chemosynthesis? 
(E) What accounts for the locations of deep-sea smokers?

2 
 B 
 2. The information in the passage suggests that the majority of deep-sea faunas that live in nonvent habitats have which of the following characteristics?

(A) They do not normally feed on particles of food in the water. 
(B) They are smaller than many vent faunas. 
(C) They are predators. 
(D) They derive nutrition from a chemosynthetic food source. 
(E) They congregate around a single main food source.

3 
 D 
 3. The primary purpose of the passage is to

(A) describe a previously unknown natural phenomenon 
(B) reconstruct the evolution of a natural phenomenon 
(C) establish unequivocally the accuracy of a hypothesis 
(D) survey explanations for a natural phenomenon and determine which is best supported by evidence 
(E) entertain criticism of the author's research and provide an effective response

4 
 A 
 4. Which of the following does the author cite as a weakness in the argument that bacterial chemosynthesis provides the foundation for the food chains at deep-sea vents?

(A) Vents are colonized by some of the same animals found in other areas of the ocean floor. 
(B) Vent water does not contain sufficient quantities of hydrogen sulfide. 
(C) Bacteria cannot produce large quantities of food quickly enough. 
(D) Large concentrations of minerals are found in vent water. 
(E) Some bacteria found in the vents are incapable of chemosynthesis.

5 
 B 
 5. Which of the following is information supplied in the passage that would support the statement that the food supplies necessary to sustain vent communities must be many times that of ordinary fallout?

I.  Large vent faunas move from vent to vent in search of food. 
 II.  Vent faunas are not able to consume food produced by photosynthesis. 
 III.  Vents are more densely populated than are other deep-sea areas.

(A) I only 
(B) III only 
(C) I and II only 
(D) II and III only 
(E) I, II, and III

6 
 E 
 6. The author refers to "smokers" most probably in order to

(A) show how thermal shock can provide food for some vent faunas by stunning small animals 
(B) prove that the habitat of most deep-sea animals is limited to warm-water vents 
(C) explain how bacteria carry out chemosynthesis 
(D) demonstrate how advection compensates for the lack of food sources on the seafloor 
(E) present evidence that bacterial chemosynthesis may be an inadequate source of food for some vent faunas

7 
 B 
 7. Which of the following can be inferred from the passage about the particulate matter that is carried down from the surface of the ocean?

(A) It is the basis of bacterial chemosynthesis in the vents. 
(B) It may provide an important source of nutrition for vent faunas. 
(C) It may cause the internal temperature of the vents to change significantly. 
(D) It is transported as large aggregates of particles. 
(E) It contains hydrogen sulfide

Source:   GRE Official Material  
Difficulty Level:   650

Skywalker18 · Accepted Answer

All correct (except Q4) in 10 mins 45 seconds, including 4 mins 40 seconds to read
Para 1- hydrothermal vents- high fauna density
Para 2- two possible sources- bacterial chemosynthesis and advection
Para 3- difficulties with 'bacterial chemosynthesis' explanation
Para 4- advection

1. The passage provides information for answering Which of the following questions?  
(C) Do bacteria live in the vent water of smokers? 
the proximity of "smokers" -vents where water emerges at temperatures up to 350° C. No bacteria can survive such heat, and no bacteria were found there

2. The information in the passage suggests that the majority of deep-sea faunas that live in nonvent habitats have which of the following characteristics?  
(B) They are smaller than many vent faunas. 
The deep sea typically has a sparse fauna dominated by tiny worms and crustaceans, with an even sparser distribution of larger animals.

3. The primary purpose of the passage is to  
(A) describe a previously unknown natural phenomenon- incorrect, no unknown natural phenomenon is described
(B) reconstruct the evolution of a natural phenomenon - incorrect, no evolution is described here
(C) establish unequivocally the accuracy of a hypothesis - incorrect, no hypothesis was unequivocally established
(D) survey explanations for a natural phenomenon and determine which is best supported by evidence- Correct - two explanation are discussed and are evaluated in terms of evidence
(E) entertain criticism of the author's research and provide an effective response- incorrect

4. Which of the following does the author cite as a weakness in the argument that bacterial chemosynthesis provides the foundation for the food chains at deep-sea vents?

(A) Vents are colonized by some of the same animals found in other areas of the ocean floor. 
some of the large sedentary organisms associated with vents are also found at ordinary deep-sea temperatures many meters from the nearest hydrothermal sources.

5. Which of the following is information supplied in the passage that would support the statement that the food supplies necessary to sustain vent communities must be many times that of ordinary fallout?  
 Vents are more densely populated than are other deep-sea areas. - Thus the amount of food from ordinary fallout would not suffice the requirements

6. The author refers to "smokers" most probably in order to  
(E) present evidence that bacterial chemosynthesis may be an inadequate source of food for some vent faunas - Correct
Smokers--> No bacteria can survive such heat--> thus we need an alternate source of food

7. Which of the following can be inferred from the passage about the particulate matter that is carried down from the surface of the ocean?

(B) It may provide an important source of nutrition for vent faunas. - Correct
advection is a more likely alternative food source. 
Thus, for an average-sized vent, advection could provide more than 30 kilograms of potential food per day. In addition, it is likely that small live animals in the advected water might be killed or stunned by thermal and/or chemical shock thereby contributing to the food supply of vents.

as6 · Answer

Can Some one please explain how the answer is B and why not E for last question ? The passage does not say anything about the importance of food.

Carcass · Answer

bacterial chemosynthesis, production of food by bacteria using energy derived from chemical changes

Which of the following can be inferred from the passage about the particulate matter that is carried down from the surface of the ocean?

(A) It is the basis of bacterial chemosynthesis in the vents.

Not totally true. later in the passage is said that it is partial

(B) It   may  provide  an important source of nutrition for vent faunas.

Most deep-sea faunas rely for food on particulate matter ultimately derived from photosynthesis, falling from above.  The food supplies  necessary to sustain  the large vent communities ,  however ,  must be many times the ordinary fallout.

which means there are other factors that sustain the fauna.

(C) It may cause the internal temperature of the vents to change significantly.

Partially true.

(D) It is transported as large aggregates of particles.

Not stated directly in the passage or inferred.

(E) It contains hydrogen sulfide.

Not true. Hydrogen sulfide is a by-product of a process. The result. Per se the water does not contain it.

Hope this helps.

Regards.

PS: this is a very daunting passage yet it is 100% reliable.

AdityaHongunti · Answer

as6  welcome to the club

Which of the following can be inferred from the passage about the  particulate matter that is carried down from the surface of the ocean?

first find where we have the "particuate matter" in the entire para !!
"Most deep-sea faunas rely for food on  particulate matter  ultimately derived from photosynthesis, falling from above."

"Research has demonstrated that advective flow, which originates near the surface of the ocean where suspended  particulate matter  accumulates, transports some of that matter and water to the vents. Estimates suggest that for every cubic meter of vent discharge, 350 milligrams of  particulate organic material  would be advected into the vent area. Thus, for an average-sized vent, advection could provide more than 30 kilograms of potential food per day."

in the second para the author intoroduces 2 possible explanations for nutrition : chemo and advectio
in the same para we get the positives toads chemo
in the third para we get the limitations of chemo explanation : by stating the chemo is not an adquate explanayion and thus an adequate source of food
in the 4th para the author states : "advection is a more likely  alternative food source.  "
and what does advectio involve ?? usage of particulate matter !!! so isnt this indirectly suggesting us that "oarticaulate matter" may be an alternative souce of food !!

(A) It is the basis of bacterial chemosynthesis in the vents.
NO MENTION
 
(B) It may provide an important source of nutrition for vent faunas. 
- CORRECT
(C) It may cause the internal temperature of the vents to change significantly. 
- NO MENTION

(D) It is transported as large aggregates of particles. 
- This was the second closest answer. As the 4th para states ": for every cubic meter of vent discharge, 350 milligrams of particulate organic material would be advected into the vent area. Thus, for an average-sized vent, advection could provide more than 30 kilograms of potential food per day. "
But the "large" aggregate was a throw in this !!! second best answer

(E) It contains hydrogen sulfide
- The huydro sulphide was a possibe explanation for " chemo" ...but we have no link between chemo and "particulate matter"

Raj30 · Answer

The information in the passage suggests that the majority of deep-sea faunas that live in nonvent habitats have which of the following characteristics?

(A) They do not normally feed on particles of food in the water. 
(B) They are smaller than many vent faunas. 
(C) They are predators. 
(D) They derive nutrition from a chemosynthetic food source. 
(E) They congregate around a single main food source.

Why ain't the answer c?
it's mentioned that animals feed on bacteria

Wonderwoman31 · Answer

The information regarding deep-sea faunas is mentioned in first passage. And it is nowhere mentioned that they are the predators.

Timebomb · Answer

Why is C the ans for question 1?

(C) Do bacteria live in the vent water of smokers? - "Another difficulty is that similarly dense populations of large deep-sea animals have been found in the proximity of "smokers" -vents where water emerges at temperatures up to 350° C. No bacteria can survive such heat, and no bacteria were found there Unless smokers are consistently located near more"

Posted from my mobile device

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Here is the relevant portion:  "There are, however, certain difficulties with this interpretation. For example, some of the large sedentary organisms associated with vents are also found at ordinary deep-sea temperatures many meters from the nearest hydrothermal sources."

Choice A , then, is the answer: some animals found near the vents are also found elsewhere. If chemosynthesis near the vents supposedly provides all the food, then how do these other animals not near the vents find food?

nqp18 · Answer

can someone expalain question no 5 ?

The deep sea typically has a sparse fauna dominated by tiny worms and

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Reading Comprehension (RC) Questions

The deep sea typically has a sparse fauna dominated by tiny worms and

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards