sid0791
vv65Exactly that's what I wanna know, how we can define what the author wants to say in this question. Because if we go with meaning, we refer to exactly what the author says in the original sentence. Now A option is just wrong because of pronoun error. Choosing option E would change its meaning.
Re "how we can define what the author wants to say in this question"
It's a judgement call
We need to apply some outside knowledge/logic in many GMAT questions
For example, see this sentence:
While watching TV, the dogs disturbed me.
The literal meaning is that the dogs were watching TV, and the dogs disturbed me.
Most of us would agree that is illogical, not what the writer meant.
Even though some dogs do watch TV (as some of my students have informed me
In the case of the question we are discussing, it makes less sense to speak of a language's mercantile heritage.
It makes more sense to speak of the mercantile heritage of the Portuguse nation or people.
(Having said all the above, let me point out that this is not an official question.
It's better to keep such detailed discussions for official questions made by the GMAC)
Posted from my mobile device