There are 2 circular cylinders X and Y, and both cylinders contain wat

Question

There are 2 circular cylinders X and Y, and both cylinders contain water inside. Cylinder X has 5π square inches as the base area and 6 inches as the height of the water inside, and cylinder Y has 10π square inches as the base area and 2 inches as the height of the water inside. If the height of the water becomes the same when the water drawn from cylinder X is poured into cylinder Y, what is the height of water in these cylinders, in inches?

A. 2.5
B. 3
C. \(\frac{10}{3}\)
D. 4
E. 4.5

Weekly Quant Quiz #3 Question No 1

Show Answer

Official Answer

C

A. 2.5 
B. 3 
C.  \frac{10}{3}  
D. 4 
E. 4.5

Weekly Quant Quiz #3 Question No 1

GMATBusters · Answer

Official Explanation 1.jpg Volume of water = Area of Base * Height /level of water filled As shown in the figure above, since the heights of both cylinders become the same, Initial total volume = final volume. We get 6(5π) + 2(10π) = 5πk + 10πk or 50π = 15πk. Therefore, k= \frac{10}{3} . The answer is C .

Gladiator59 · Answer

PFA solution in the image.

Answer should be C.
BEst,
G

pk123 · Answer

Cylinder 1 total vol= 5 pie *6 = 30 pie
Cylinder 2 total vol = 10 pie*2= 20 pie

so total vol = 50 pie

Height becomes same in both so 5pie *h + 10 pie *h = 50 pie
15 pie *h = 50 pie
so h = 50/15 = 10/3

Option C fits

aeon86 · Answer

cylinder A contains 5Pi x 6 inches water, or 30Pi cubic inches water
cylinder B contains 10Pi x 2 inches water, or 20Pi cubic inches of water

total sum is 50Pi cubic inches.
in order to be the same the ratio of the volume between the cylinders needs to be the same after being divided by 5PI and 10Pi respectively

if we keep 15pi cubic inches in A, and 35 in B that results in 3 and 3,5
if we keep 20pi cubic inches in A, and 30 in B that results in 4 and 3
if we keep 25pi cubic inches in A, and 30 in B that results in 4 and 3

15-35 is the closest result we get with whole numbers
so the value has to be between 3 and 3,5

--> C

Anisha2793 · Answer

C, as it gives the same volume , as to when individual volumes are added with the respective heights

Posted from my mobile device

rever08 · Answer

Step 1: 
Calculating the volume of water in each of the two cylinders before water from one is poured into the other. 
Volume of cylinder = πr^2h
h is the height and r is the radius of the circular base.

Water in cylinder X: Volume = 5π x 6 = 30 π inches^3

Water in cylinder Y: Volume = 10π x 2 = 20π inches^3

Now we can let “A" be the amount of water that should be poured from cylinder X to cylinder Y so that the water in both cylinders will be the same height.

So

(30π - A)/5π = (20π + A)/10π
 
15Aπ = 200π^2

A = 40 π/3

Since A = 40π/3, the height of water in each cylinder is:

(30 π - 40 π/3)/5π = 10/3

Anisha2793 · Answer

C, as it gives the same volume , as to when individual volumes are added with the respective heights

Posted from my mobile device

MsInvBanker · Answer

Total volume of water available is 50 π square inches.

With a height of 3, the total is less than 50 and with a height of 4, the total is more than 50. So, somewhere in between. The only option is C.

u1983 · Answer

1 unit reduction in x = 0.5 unit increase in Y
2 unit decrease in X= 1 increase in y

6-2a = 2+ a

3a=4
a=4/3

resultant height = 2+4/3 =10/3...... ans C

yenbh · Answer

Pls see my answer as below:

Vx = 5π x 6 = 30π
Vy = 10π x 2 = 20π

Let a is the volume of water drawn from X to Y

--> (30π - a)/5π = (20π + a)/10π --> a = 40π/3

--> New volume in Y = 40π/3 + 20π = 100π/3

--> New Height in cylinder Y = New volume Y/ Base area Y = (100π/3) /10π = 10/3 = Height in cylinder X

binsnitin11 · Answer

As the base of Cylinder X is = 5pie and Cylinder Y is = 10pie, assuming that if the Cylinder X would have base area of 10 pie than the water surface area of water inside it would become half thus after Cylinder X has base area of 10 pie the height would be 3. Once we balance the water inside both the cylinder the resultant height would be 2.5

Hope this make sense.
ANy comments much appreciated.

Hope this make sense. 
ANy comments much appreciated.

lostboy · Answer

E:

its a ratio from 1:2 and so if you take away approximately greater than 1 from the first cylinder and put in a bit more than 2 into the second, they would even out to 4.5 each.

hargun3045 · Answer

For first cylinder

V = 10pi*6

Second cylinder

V = 20pi*2

We need to find the transfer so that both have the same height

Thing to note is that V of second cylinder has twice as much surface are as first

Using smart numbers we see that we will need first cylinder to lose a height of 2 inches for every increase of 1 inch on second cylinder

Keeping that in mind, imagine this a problem of average weights

Y(2)----------(AV)--------------------X(6)

let height be t weight on Y side is 2 and on X is 6
Thus, (t-2)/(t-6) = 1/2
Solve, t = 10/3

HAPPYatHARVARD · Answer

gmatbusters  
do you mean the total initial volume of the water in the cylinders is the same as the final volume of water?

GMATBusters · Answer

As per the question, initially the level of water in the 2 cylinders are different ( 6 inches & 2 inches)
the liquid are transferred to make the liquid level same.

If it is still not clear, feel free to tag me again...

sekipap · Answer

If you take two liters from X and put it into Y, is gonna be 4 vs 3... so you need to put more water so that 4 decreases and 3 increases... until they converge somewhere between 3 and 4. Where exactly? you don't care, because the only result included between 3 and 4 is 10/3

Fdambro294 · Answer

Thinking Conceptually about the Problem:

Cylinder X has a radius = sqrt(5)

Cylinder Y has a radius = sqrt(10)

This means cylinder Y is twice as wide/thick as Cylinder X.

If we start with Cylinder X with a height of 6 inches and we Doubled the width of the Cylinder’s Base, the Water in the Cylinder would now have TWICE as much room to “spread out” in the Cylinder and the Height would drop by 1/2 to 3 inches.

Thus, since Cylinder Y is TWICE as Wide as Cylinder X, in order for the water to be at the same Height in both Cylinders we would need to give Twice as much of the Total Volume of Water we have to Cylinder Y (whose base “spreads out” twice as much) than to Cylinder X.

Vol Water in X : Vol Water in Y : Total Amount of water in both cylinders

Need to be in the Ratio of:

1m : 2m : 3m

Therefore, 2/3rd of All the Water needs to go in Y and 1/3rd of All the Water needs to go in X. Only then will we have an equal Height of the Water in each cylinder.

Vol of water in X = 5(pi) * 6 = 30(pi)

Vol of water in Y = 10(pi) * 2 = 20(pi)

Total Amount of water = 50(pi)

(1/3) * 50(pi) = Volume of Water in X, which has a radius = sqrt(5)

(2/3) * 50(pi) = Volume of Water in Y, which has a radius = sqrt(10)

Setting each equation equal to the Volume Formula with the corresponding radius:

50(pi)/3 = (pi) * ( sqrt(5) )^2 * (Height of X)

100(pi)/3 = (pi) * ( sqrt(10) )^2 * (Height of Y)

Solving for the Height in each equation:

Height of X = Height of Y = 10/3

C

Posted from my mobile device

bumpbot · Answer

Hello from the GMAT Club BumpBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.

There are 2 circular cylinders X and Y, and both cylinders contain wat

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Problem Solving (PS) Questions

There are 2 circular cylinders X and Y, and both cylinders contain wat

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards