Bunuel
A moving service charges p dollars for the first 5 miles of any trip plus 0.1*p dollars for each additional mile or fraction of a mile. If p > 30, was a particular trip more than 30 miles long?
(1) The moving service charged a total of 3.3p dollars for the trip.
(2) The moving service charged a total of $132 for the trip.
Given:
p dollars for 1st 5 miles
0.1p dollars for each additional mile or a fraction of a mile.
If p>30, trip >30 miles long?
Statement 1
Total: 3.3p dollars for the trip
Let p=31
Total = 3.3*31= 102.3
Cost for the rest apart from first 5 miles: 102.3-31=71.3
Number of miles apart from the first 5: 71.3/3.1
= 23 miles.
Total trip length= 23+5=28miles
Let p=35
Total= 3.3*35= 115.5
Cost for the rest apart from first 5 miles : 115.5-35=80.5
Number of miles apart from the first 5: 80.5/3.5= 23 miles
Total trip length = 23+5= 28 miles
This means that for any value of p>30, this statement will hold true as the values will stay in proportion and the total length will remain the same.
The length of the trip <30 miles. A definite answer : NO
Sufficient. Statement 2:
Total: $132
Let p=32
Remaining= 132-32= 100
Number of miles apart from the first 5 = 31.25 miles.
Let p=42
Remaining = 132-42 =90
Number of miles apart from the first five = 90/4.2= 21.42 miles
We aren't getting a definite YES/NO Answer.
Not Sufficient. Answer: A