Bunuel
There are 10 trees in a garden, and a gardener randomly selects 3 different trees to prune. Is the probability that all 3 selected trees are oaks greater than 1/20?
(1) The probability that two randomly selected trees are both oaks is 2/15.
(2) There are 6 maple trees in the garden.
There are 10 trees in a garden
T = 10
and a gardener randomly selects 3 different trees to prune
Selection of 3 trees = 10C3
Is the probability that all 3 selected trees are oaks greater than 1/20?
Let say oak trees = x
Non-oak trees = 10 - x
Is \(\frac{{xC3}}{{10C3}}\) > 1/20?
Calculating \(\frac{{xC3}}{{10C3}}\) we get
=> \(\frac{x!}{{3!(x-3)!}}\) / \(\frac{10!}{3!7!}\)
=> \(\frac{x(x-1) (x-2) }{6}\) / \(\frac{10.9.8}{6}\)
=> \(\frac{x(x-1) (x-2) }{6}\) * \(\frac{6}{10.9.8}\)
=> \(\frac{x(x-1) (x-2)}{10.9.8}\)
Now
\(\frac{x(x-1) (x-2)}{10.9.8}\) > 1/20
=> \(x(x-1)(x-2)\) > \(\frac{10.9.8}{20}\)
=> \(x(x-1)(x-2)\) > \(36\)
=> x >= 5
So, we have to check if x >= 5?
(1) The probability that two randomly selected trees are both oaks is 2/15.
=> \(\frac{{xC2}}{{10C2}}\) = 2/15
=> \(\frac{x!}{{2!(x-2)!}}\) / \(\frac{10!}{2!8!}\) = 2/15
=> \(\frac{x(x-1) }{2}\) / \(\frac{10.9}{2}\) = 2/15
=> \(\frac{x(x-1)}{2}\) * \(\frac{2}{10.9}\) = 2/15
=> \(\frac{x(x-1)}{10.9}\) = 2/15
=> \(x(x-1)\) = 10.9.2/15
=> \(x(x-1)\) = 12
=> x = 4
Sufficient
(2) There are 6 maple trees in the garden.
The number of oak trees can be a maximum of 4
=> x <= 4
This is also sufficient
Option D