Author 
Message 
TAGS:

Hide Tags

Manager
Joined: 05 Jul 2011
Posts: 63

Hollywood starlets Ashlee and Britnee each has an entourage [#permalink]
Show Tags
22 Jul 2011, 11:40
3
This post received KUDOS
8
This post was BOOKMARKED
Question Stats:
40% (01:24) correct 60% (01:17) wrong based on 394 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics
Hollywood starlets Ashlee and Britnee each has an entourage consisting of a number of wannabes. If each starlet has a list of 10 wannabes from which to choose entourage members, which starlet can form the most different entourages? (1) Britnee’s entourage consists of more wannabes than Ashlee’s entourage does. (2) Ashlee’s entourage consists of exactly four wannabes.
Official Answer and Stats are available only to registered users. Register/ Login.
_________________
Winners do it differently



Manager
Joined: 04 Apr 2010
Posts: 143

Re: Odd DS Question [#permalink]
Show Tags
23 Jul 2011, 19:22
Don't you think this problem is little bit difficult to understand especially for nonnative English speaker?
_________________
Consider me giving KUDOS, if you find my post helpful. If at first you don't succeed, you're running about average. ~Anonymous



Manager
Joined: 05 Jul 2011
Posts: 63

Re: Odd DS Question [#permalink]
Show Tags
24 Jul 2011, 11:10
Yeah it is.. I just assumed entourage for a selected group (word web:The group following and attending to some important person) and wannabes as candidates (word web: An ambitious and aspiring young person). So basically, the no. of people to be selected is different for both the singers. Out of 10 candidates, britnee selects x no. to form her group and ashlee selects y people out of her list of 10 candidates. Now, statement 2 says ashlee needs to select 4 out of 10 which means there are 10C4 or 210 ways to form ashlee's group. No info about britnee yet. 1st statement says Britnee needs to select more people out of 10 than does ashlee. It gives us no clue about the possible no. of groups she can form in comparison to ashlee. Combining 1st and 2nd Britnee needs to select more than 4 people out of 10 to form her group in which case No. of ways for britnee ranges from  10C4 to 10C10 i.e, 252 ways to 1 way. =>No conclusive answer. Hence, E. In the process of explaining it to you, I got my doubt cleared :D Thanks...
_________________
Winners do it differently



Manhattan Prep Instructor
Joined: 22 Mar 2011
Posts: 1225

Re: Hollywood starlets Ashlee and Britnee each has an entourage [#permalink]
Show Tags
28 Jun 2014, 01:35
3
This post received KUDOS
Expert's post
6
This post was BOOKMARKED
Very clever. This plays on the fact that mathematics is blind to which group is in and which is out. In other words, putting 4 people "in" and 6 "out" is the same as putting 6 "in" and 4 "out." Our intuition is to say that the more members, the more possibilities, but that's not true. In fact, the highest number of possibilities comes at 5 in/5 out, and the number tapers off equally in both directions. There are 252 ways to select a group of 5, 210 ways to select a group of four (or six), etc., all the way down to 1 way to select a group of 10. (1) INSUFFICIENT: B could have 5 and A could have 4. B (252) >A (210) B could have 6 and A could have 5. A (252) >B (210) (2) INSUFFICIENT: A's total is 210, but this is useless without info about B. (1&2) INSUFFICIENT: A's total is 210. B could have 5, for a total of 252. B>A B could have 6, for a total of 210. B=A B could have 10, for a total of 1. B<A T he correct answer is E.On a Sentence Correction note, the sentence should read "A&B each have," not "has." The subject is A&B (plural), not each (singular). If this is a real Princeton Review problem, I hope this was a transcription error.
_________________
Dmitry Farber  Manhattan GMAT Instructor  New York
Manhattan GMAT Discount  Manhattan GMAT Course Reviews  View Instructor Profile  Manhattan GMAT Reviews



Manager
Joined: 27 Oct 2014
Posts: 156
Location: India
GPA: 4
WE: Consulting (Consulting)

Re: Hollywood starlets Ashlee and Britnee each has an entourage [#permalink]
Show Tags
10 Jun 2017, 15:16
Here's my take: Quote: (1) Britnee’s entourage consists of more wannabes than Ashlee’s entourage does. (2) Ashlee’s entourage consists of exactly four wannabes.
From 2, If Ashlee has to make entourages of 4 wannabes each and she has 10 to pick from, she could pick 8 people and therefore 2 entourages. But this is not sufficient. 1 seems insufficient on it's own. But if B's entourage is bigger, let's assume 2 numbers: 5 & >5. At 5, she could make two entourages from the 10 people but only 1 entourage at >5. Therefore we don't have a certain number for B. Therefore, E?
_________________
If you found this post useful, hit Kudos! :D



Current Student
Joined: 22 Sep 2016
Posts: 200
Location: India
GPA: 4

Re: Hollywood starlets Ashlee and Britnee each has an entourage [#permalink]
Show Tags
19 Jul 2017, 21:04
RohitKalla wrote: Yeah it is.. I just assumed entourage for a selected group (word web:The group following and attending to some important person) and wannabes as candidates (word web: An ambitious and aspiring young person). So basically, the no. of people to be selected is different for both the singers. Out of 10 candidates, britnee selects x no. to form her group and ashlee selects y people out of her list of 10 candidates. Now, statement 2 says ashlee needs to select 4 out of 10 which means there are 10C4 or 210 ways to form ashlee's group. No info about britnee yet. 1st statement says Britnee needs to select more people out of 10 than does ashlee. It gives us no clue about the possible no. of groups she can form in comparison to ashlee. Combining 1st and 2nd Britnee needs to select more than 4 people out of 10 to form her group in which case No. of ways for britnee ranges from  10C4 to 10C10 i.e, 252 ways to 1 way. =>No conclusive answer. Hence, E. In the process of explaining it to you, I got my doubt cleared :D Thanks... The question states that "which starlet can form the most different groups". In that way, the answer should be C. Because, only 10C1 has the issue of not being greater than 10C(1+n) where n is an integer greater than zero and less than 10. In all other cases, Britnee's group will have fewer different member teams.
_________________
Desperately need 'KUDOS' !!



Manager
Joined: 01 Feb 2017
Posts: 105

Hollywood starlets Ashlee and Britnee each has an entourage [#permalink]
Show Tags
01 Nov 2017, 08:24
nCk value is maximized when k=n/2. If n is odd, then value of n/2+0.5 is same. Eg. 25C12=25C13.
Similarly, max 10Ck is when k=5.
St.1 is Insufficient because we cannot conclude the higher value of 10Ck even if value of k1 is different from k2.
St.2 is Insufficient as k1= 4. So, if k2=5, then k2>k1. But, if k2=10, then k2<k1.
Even after combining two statements, we cannot decide which k is leading to higher value of 10Ck.
Hence, Ans E
Posted from my mobile device



Senior Manager
Joined: 02 Apr 2014
Posts: 471

Re: Hollywood starlets Ashlee and Britnee each has an entourage [#permalink]
Show Tags
23 Nov 2017, 12:00
Before we solve this problem, we must note that
10C1 = 10C9, 10C2 = 10C8, 10C3 = 10C7, 10C4 = 10C6
So,
10C1 < 10C2 < 10C3 < 10C4 < 10C5 10C9 < 10C8 < 10C7 < 10C6 < 10C5
Let us attack the statements:
Statement 1: Britnee’s entourage consists of more wannabes than Ashlee’s entourage does. Say Britnee has 4 wannabes out of 10, and Ashlee has 3 wannabes out of 10 => 10C4 > 10C3, so Britnee has more combinations than Ashless has
Say Britnee has 6 wannabes out of 10, and Ashlee has 5 wannabes out of 10 => 10C6 < 10C4 (from above), so Britnee has less number of combinations than Ashless has
InSuff
Statement2: Ashlee’s entourage consists of exactly four wannabes.  Clearly insufficient, as we don't know about Britnee's
From 1 + 2, A has 4, but if B has 5 wannabes, then B has more combinations than A has but if B has 7 wannabes, then effectively 10C7 = 10C3 (<10C4), B has less combinations than A has
Still Insuff > (E)




Re: Hollywood starlets Ashlee and Britnee each has an entourage
[#permalink]
23 Nov 2017, 12:00






