May 24 10:00 PM PDT  11:00 PM PDT Join a FREE 1day workshop and learn how to ace the GMAT while keeping your fulltime job. Limited for the first 99 registrants. May 25 07:00 AM PDT  09:00 AM PDT Attend this webinar and master GMAT SC in 10 days by learning how meaning and logic can help you tackle 700+ level SC questions with ease. May 27 01:00 AM PDT  11:59 PM PDT All GMAT Club Tests are free and open on May 27th for Memorial Day! May 27 10:00 PM PDT  11:00 PM PDT Special savings are here for Magoosh GMAT Prep! Even better  save 20% on the plan of your choice, now through midnight on Tuesday, 5/27 May 30 10:00 PM PDT  11:00 PM PDT Application deadlines are just around the corner, so now’s the time to start studying for the GMAT! Start today and save 25% on your GMAT prep. Valid until May 30th.
Author 
Message 
TAGS:

Hide Tags

Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 55271

Question Stats:
46% (01:23) correct 54% (01:14) wrong based on 228 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics
Is the product of \(a\) and \(b\) equal to 1? (1) \(a*b*a=a\) (2) \(b*a*b=b\)
Official Answer and Stats are available only to registered users. Register/ Login.
_________________



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 55271

Re M0136
[#permalink]
Show Tags
16 Sep 2014, 00:16
Official Solution: Question: is \(ab=1\)? (1) \(a^2b=a\) \(a^2ba=0\); \(a(ab1)=0\): either \(a=0\) (and \(b=\text{any value}\), including zero) so in this case \(ab=0\neq 1\) OR \(ab=1\). Two different answers, not sufficient. (2) \(ab^2=b\) \(ab^2b=0\); \(b(ab1)=0\): either \(b=0\) (and \(a=\text{any value}\), including zero) so in this case \(ab=0 \neq 1\) OR \(ab=1\). Two different answers, not sufficient. (1)+(2) either \(a=b=0\), so in this case \(ab=0 \neq 1\) and the answer to the question is NO, OR \(ab=1\) and the answer to the question is YES. Two different answers, not sufficient. Answer: E
_________________



Board of Directors
Joined: 17 Jul 2014
Posts: 2551
Location: United States (IL)
Concentration: Finance, Economics
GPA: 3.92
WE: General Management (Transportation)

Re: M0136
[#permalink]
Show Tags
20 Nov 2014, 20:46
why can't we conclude that: a^2*b=a=>b=1/a in this case a*1/a = 1 and statement 1 and 2 are both sufficient hm..



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 55271

Re: M0136
[#permalink]
Show Tags
21 Nov 2014, 04:56
mvictor wrote: why can't we conclude that: a^2*b=a=>b=1/a in this case a*1/a = 1 and statement 1 and 2 are both sufficient hm.. Please reread the solution above. Does not a = 0 satisfy the equation? You cannot write b=1/a from a^2*b=a because a could be 0, and we cannot reduce or divide by 0.
_________________



Manager
Joined: 06 Jun 2013
Posts: 106
Concentration: Technology, General Management
GPA: 3.47

Re: M0136
[#permalink]
Show Tags
19 Jun 2015, 07:45
Hi Bunuel, I have a question based on the solution that you have mentioned below: Let's say a question in DS is as follows? If x is a positive integer, is x=4? Stmt 1) X is a root of the quadratic equation  x^2  12x+12=0 Stmt 2) X is a root of the quadratic equation  x^2  9x+20=0 Now solving each statement alone, Stmt 1 > Allows x value to be either x= 3,4 Stmt 2 > Allows x value to be either x= 4,5 Now for such a Data sufficiency question, don't we find that x=4 is a common solution in both statements together and hence mark the answer as Answer choice (C)  Both statements together are sufficient but neither alone. Now based on this understanding, for the current question, Both statement (1) and statement (2) when taken together show that ab = 1. Can we not select option choice (c), based on this? Please correct me if my understanding is wrong some where? Vijay Bunuel wrote: Official Solution:
Question: is \(ab=1\)? (1) \(a^2b=a\) \(a^2ba=0\); \(a(ab1)=0\): either \(a=0\) (and \(b=\text{any value}\), including zero) so in this case \(ab=0\neq 1\) OR \(ab=1\). Two different answers, not sufficient. (2) \(ab^2=b\) \(ab^2b=0\); \(b(ab1)=0\): either \(b=0\) (and \(a=\text{any value}\), including zero) so in this case \(ab=0 \neq 1\) OR \(ab=1\). Two different answers, not sufficient. (1)+(2) either \(a=b=0\), so in this case \(ab=0 \neq 1\) and the answer to the question is NO, OR \(ab=1\) and the answer to the question is YES. Two different answers, not sufficient.
Answer: E



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 55271

Re: M0136
[#permalink]
Show Tags
19 Jun 2015, 07:55
svijayaug12 wrote: Hi Bunuel, I have a question based on the solution that you have mentioned below: Let's say a question in DS is as follows? If x is a positive integer, is x=4? Stmt 1) X is a root of the quadratic equation  x^2  12x+12=0 Stmt 2) X is a root of the quadratic equation  x^2  9x+20=0 Now solving each statement alone, Stmt 1 > Allows x value to be either x= 3,4 Stmt 2 > Allows x value to be either x= 4,5 Now for such a Data sufficiency question, don't we find that x=4 is a common solution in both statements together and hence mark the answer as Answer choice (C)  Both statements together are sufficient but neither alone. Now based on this understanding, for the current question, Both statement (1) and statement (2) when taken together show that ab = 1. Can we not select option choice (c), based on this? Please correct me if my understanding is wrong some where? Vijay Bunuel wrote: Official Solution:
Question: is \(ab=1\)? (1) \(a^2b=a\) \(a^2ba=0\); \(a(ab1)=0\): either \(a=0\) (and \(b=\text{any value}\), including zero) so in this case \(ab=0\neq 1\) OR \(ab=1\). Two different answers, not sufficient. (2) \(ab^2=b\) \(ab^2b=0\); \(b(ab1)=0\): either \(b=0\) (and \(a=\text{any value}\), including zero) so in this case \(ab=0 \neq 1\) OR \(ab=1\). Two different answers, not sufficient. (1)+(2) either \(a=b=0\), so in this case \(ab=0 \neq 1\) and the answer to the question is NO, OR \(ab=1\) and the answer to the question is YES. Two different answers, not sufficient.
Answer: E When we consider two statements together we should take the values which satisfy both statements. For this question \(ab=1\) satisfies both statement, but \(a=b=0\) also satisfies both statements. So what you call "common solution" for this question is: \(ab=1\) OR \(ab=0\neq{1}\).
_________________



Intern
Joined: 23 Jan 2014
Posts: 27

Re: M0136
[#permalink]
Show Tags
15 Aug 2016, 21:45
Sorry Bunuel, but if b=0, it will not satisfy the statement 1, will it? Bunuel wrote: svijayaug12 wrote: Hi Bunuel, I have a question based on the solution that you have mentioned below: Let's say a question in DS is as follows? If x is a positive integer, is x=4? Stmt 1) X is a root of the quadratic equation  x^2  12x+12=0 Stmt 2) X is a root of the quadratic equation  x^2  9x+20=0 Now solving each statement alone, Stmt 1 > Allows x value to be either x= 3,4 Stmt 2 > Allows x value to be either x= 4,5 Now for such a Data sufficiency question, don't we find that x=4 is a common solution in both statements together and hence mark the answer as Answer choice (C)  Both statements together are sufficient but neither alone. Now based on this understanding, for the current question, Both statement (1) and statement (2) when taken together show that ab = 1. Can we not select option choice (c), based on this? Please correct me if my understanding is wrong some where? Vijay Bunuel wrote: Official Solution:
Question: is \(ab=1\)? (1) \(a^2b=a\) \(a^2ba=0\); \(a(ab1)=0\): either \(a=0\) (and \(b=\text{any value}\), including zero) so in this case \(ab=0\neq 1\) OR \(ab=1\). Two different answers, not sufficient. (2) \(ab^2=b\) \(ab^2b=0\); \(b(ab1)=0\): either \(b=0\) (and \(a=\text{any value}\), including zero) so in this case \(ab=0 \neq 1\) OR \(ab=1\). Two different answers, not sufficient. (1)+(2) either \(a=b=0\), so in this case \(ab=0 \neq 1\) and the answer to the question is NO, OR \(ab=1\) and the answer to the question is YES. Two different answers, not sufficient.
Answer: E When we consider two statements together we should take the values which satisfy both statements. For this question \(ab=1\) satisfies both statement, but \(a=b=0\) also satisfies both statements. So what you call "common solution" for this question is: \(ab=1\) OR \(ab=0\neq{1}\).



Current Student
Joined: 03 Aug 2016
Posts: 353
Location: Canada
GMAT 1: 660 Q44 V38 GMAT 2: 690 Q46 V40
GPA: 3.9
WE: Information Technology (Consumer Products)

Re: M0136
[#permalink]
Show Tags
05 Sep 2017, 19:42
I am confused, Why cant we say a*b*a = a a*b = a/a a*b = 1 What am i missing Bunuel
_________________
My MBA Journey  https://smalldoubledouble.com



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 55271

Re: M0136
[#permalink]
Show Tags
05 Sep 2017, 20:40
mbsingh wrote: I am confused, Why cant we say a*b*a = a a*b = a/a a*b = 1 What am i missing BunuelYou cannot reduce a*b*a = a by a, because a can be 0, and we cannot divide by 0. By doing so you are loosing a root, namely a = 0. Never reduce equation by variable (or expression with variable), if you are not certain that variable (or expression with variable) doesn't equal to zero. We cannot divide by zero.
_________________



Current Student
Joined: 03 Aug 2016
Posts: 353
Location: Canada
GMAT 1: 660 Q44 V38 GMAT 2: 690 Q46 V40
GPA: 3.9
WE: Information Technology (Consumer Products)

Re: M0136
[#permalink]
Show Tags
05 Sep 2017, 20:42
Bunuel wrote: mbsingh wrote: I am confused, Why cant we say a*b*a = a a*b = a/a a*b = 1 What am i missing BunuelYou cannot reduce a*b*a = a by a, because a can be 0, and we cannot divide by 0. By doing so you are loosing a root, namely a = 0. Never reduce equation by variable (or expression with variable), if you are not certain that variable (or expression with variable) doesn't equal to zero. We cannot divide by zero. Interesting , didnt think of that. Thanks Bunuel
_________________
My MBA Journey  https://smalldoubledouble.com



Director
Joined: 12 Feb 2015
Posts: 840

Re: M0136
[#permalink]
Show Tags
06 Jul 2018, 10:18
We have seen numerous DS questions where statement (1) gives two values of x and statement (2) gives another two values but when only one of the values is common in the solutions from both the statements then we conclude with option "C" that is "both statements taken together are sufficient to answer the question, but neither statement alone is sufficient" because we get one definite value (which is common) of x from both the statements. Say for example if we have a question like: What is the value of x? 1) x^2 = x (we find that x could be 0 or 1 therefore not sufficient) 2) (x1)(x2) = 0 ( we find that x could be 1 or 2) Now answer me what would be the answer of this question, will it be "option C" that x = 1, i.e. common solution; or "Option E" that x could either be 0 or 2 and x could be 1. Clearly when x will be 0 or 2 then it cannot be 1 and vice versa because x can assume only one value at a given point of time. Applying the same logic for this question I am unable to understand the logic why "E" is the right answer? ab = 1 is common to both the statements. Peripheral issue is:  by definition if a & b can assume only one value, i.e. that is "zero" then no matter what you do, you cannot have a solution of ab = 1 which is a contradiction in the question & statements itself?
_________________



Manager
Joined: 20 Apr 2018
Posts: 173
Concentration: Technology, Nonprofit
WE: Analyst (NonProfit and Government)

Bunuel or chetan2u, I was able to establish the equations from statements 1 and 2. 1) a = 0 or ab = 1 (not suff.) 2) b = 0 or ab = 1 (not suff.) I couldn't understand how to synthesize these equations together. I guess this is a very fundamental doubt. That is when we move to combine these equations, how exactly do we do it? I combined these equations and thought ab = 1 is the only COMMON solution, hence C is the answer. Can you help me with this?



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Aug 2009
Posts: 7686

Re: M0136
[#permalink]
Show Tags
21 Jul 2018, 08:54
sandman13 wrote: Bunuel or chetan2u, I was able to establish the equations from statements 1 and 2. 1) a = 0 or ab = 1 (not suff.) 2) b = 0 or ab = 1 (not suff.) I couldn't understand how to synthesize these equations together. I guess this is a very fundamental doubt. That is when we move to combine these equations, how exactly do we do it? I combined these equations and thought ab = 1 is the only COMMON solution, hence C is the answer. Can you help me with this? Hi... If the two statements had given two different values of a, I) say a=0 or ab=1 2) say a=2 or ab=1 Them a cannot be both values and hence only possibility is ab=1 But here we have two solutions.. 1) ab=1 Or 2) a=b=0 Both the above will satisfy the equation.. So ab=0 or ab=1
_________________



Manager
Joined: 20 Apr 2018
Posts: 173
Concentration: Technology, Nonprofit
WE: Analyst (NonProfit and Government)

chetan2u wrote: Hi... If the two statements had given two different values of a, I) say a=0 or ab=1 2) say a=2 or ab=1 Them a cannot be both values and hence only possibility is ab=1
But here we have two solutions.. 1) ab=1 Or 2) a=b=0
Both the above will satisfy the equation.. So ab=0 or ab=1 Hi chetan2u, thanks for the prompt reply. Just a clarification: why did you pick that COMBINATION of possible solutions? Let me make this a bit abstract. Say, S1: X or Y (where X and Y are some sets of solution(s)) S2: Z or Y Now, combining the two: (X or Y) and (Z or Y) ... is what? I think I studied this back in school, but I have no clear recollection of how those compliments and unions work. I was able to DRAW the event (X or Y) and (Z or Y) on a Venn diagram and get the result Y or (X and Z)In our problem, this would basically translate as follows: S1: a = 0 OR ab = 1 S2: b = 0 OR ab = 1 Combining, we get EITHER 1. ab = 1 OR 2. a = 0 AND b = 0 But this seems like a REALLY long way to solve the problem. What am I missing?
>> !!!
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.



Intern
Joined: 16 Apr 2014
Posts: 16

Re: M0136
[#permalink]
Show Tags
16 Dec 2018, 03:53
Bunuel"Never reduce equation by variable (or expression with variable), if you are not certain that variable (or expression with variable) doesn't equal to zero. We cannot divide by zero." If its given in problem a & b are not zero, then answer will be D. Right? Pl. clarify!



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 55271

Re: M0136
[#permalink]
Show Tags
16 Dec 2018, 07:42
16SK16 wrote: Bunuel"Never reduce equation by variable (or expression with variable), if you are not certain that variable (or expression with variable) doesn't equal to zero. We cannot divide by zero." If its given in problem a & b are not zero, then answer will be D. Right? Pl. clarify! Right. In this case we could reduce (1) by a and get ab = 1 and reduce (2) by b and get ab = 1.
_________________



Manager
Joined: 22 Jun 2017
Posts: 178
Location: Argentina

Re M0136
[#permalink]
Show Tags
18 Feb 2019, 13:23
I think this is a highquality question and I agree with explanation.
_________________
The HARDER you work, the LUCKIER you get.



Intern
Joined: 19 Feb 2019
Posts: 5

Re: M0136
[#permalink]
Show Tags
21 Mar 2019, 20:04
sandman13 wrote: I was able to establish the equations from statements 1 and 2. 1) a = 0 or ab = 1 (not suff.) 2) b = 0 or ab = 1 (not suff.)
I couldn't understand how to synthesize these equations together. I guess this is a very fundamental doubt. That is when we move to combine these equations, how exactly do we do it? I combined these equations and thought ab = 1 is the only COMMON solution, hence C is the answer. Can you help me with this? Very interesting question. I had the same problem but I guess this is how the solution was arrived at; 1) a = 0 or ab = 1 (not suff.) => the fact that a = 0 also implies that ab = 0 2) b = 0 or ab = 1 (not suff.) => the fact that b = 0 also implies that ab = 0 so combining (1) and (2), we still have ab = 0 or ab = 1. Not Sufficient










