samarpan.g28
3. Which of the following most accurately describes Morris’ opinion of the Abu Gharib crimes? I believed that in the last paragraph, the line saying "...soldiers leering over an Iraqi corpse helped camouflage the crimes’ higher-ranking perpetrators, is an argument that warrants retelling – and national soul-searching." would yield (B) as right option. However, I read other comments here and found (A) is correct since "At its core, though, “Believing is Seeing” is an elegantly conceived and ingeniously constructed work..." is mentioned in paragraph 6. I am a little confused with the logic. If someone helps me to understand it will be kind.
Answer option
(A) suggests that the photograph could have dual functions - exposing the wrongdoing and simultaneously covering it up. In the passage, it's mentioned that Morris asserts the repellent photos of soldiers leering over an Iraqi corpse helped camouflage the crimes' higher-ranking perpetrators. This implies that while the photographs did expose the wrongdoing, they also served to mask the responsibility of higher-ranking individuals involved in the crimes. Therefore, the photograph indeed could serve as both an expose, by revealing the actual acts of abuse, and as a cover-up, by diverting attention away from the more significant perpetrators higher up in the chain of command.
On the other hand
(B) suggests that the photograph exposes the wrongdoing all the way up the chain of command. While the photographs did expose the wrongdoing committed by the soldiers depicted in the images, Morris' assertion is more focused on how the photographs helped to camouflage the involvement of higher-ranking perpetrators. Therefore, this option doesn't fully capture Morris' opinion, which suggests that the exposure doesn't extend fully up the chain of command but rather implicates higher-ranking individuals while also serving to conceal their involvement.