Neither the late 18th century composers, such as Mozart or Haydn, nor

OE

Split #1: This subject is a neither P nor Q structure. Whether the first term, P, is singular or plural does not matter at all. All that matter is the second term, Q, which here is “Beethoven, as well as Schubert in the early 19th century.” Of course, the “as well as” is an additive phrase, so does not count as part of the subject. The only relevant subject is “Beethoven,” and of course Mr. Beethoven is singular. We need the singular verb. Choices (A) & (B) & (C) are all incorrect.

Split #2: to describe a single activity, the correct idioms is “known to compose”: these people did not do this one thing, composing suites, but that is not what made them famous overall. The idiom “known for composing” is a correct idiom, but here it illogically implies that not composing suites is precisely what made these men famous: that’s ridiculous! The construction “known by composing” even more illogically suggests that someone else, unnamed, does the composing, or the “not composing”, and this is how we know these men. The construction “known in composing” is not a correct idiom at all. Only (A) and (D) use the correct idiom for this context.

Choice (D) is the only possible answer.
_________________

A,B,C are out. 'Beethoven' is a singular noun so we need 'was'.
E - Out. Was known by composing - Weird meaning.
D - Correct answer. SV agreement + 'known to compose' is correct.
_________________

Mahmud6
At 4.12 PM, you gave the problem and then at 4.13 PM, you gave the OA and OE also. What is the hurry? Where is the opportunity for a discussion?
My humble suggestion to you is to wait for a few postings before you reveal the OA or OE.
_________________

OK Sir, Thank you for your suggestion.
_________________

Neither the late 18th century composers, such as Mozart or Haydn, nor Beethoven, as well as Schubert in the early 19th century, were known to compose in the suite format, so popular in the Baroque period.

(A) were known to compose
(B) were known in composing
(C) were known for composing
(D) was known to compose
(E) was known by composing

Straight D

This is a neither X or nor y structure- this question is testing subjective-verb agreement within the context of the usage of this idiom- so actually the verb will be contingent on the person (second or first) of the noun next proceeding nor. Beethoven is singular so it should be D.

The idiom here is "neither x nor y" and the simple rule of thumb is that the person ( singular or plural) of the verb that comes after y is determined by the person of y. So if "y" is a singular noun or pronoun then a singular verb must follow and if "Y" is a plural noun or pronoun then a plural verb must follow.

D

Neither X nor Y ___

Rule#1: verb must agree with the subject closest to the verb (the Y component)
Rule#2(not applicable here): if Neither or Either is used in isolation (without the nor/ or, respectively) then SV = singular

In this case all subjects are singular.

Eliminate (A) to (C)

Correct idiom: Known for composing
Correct idiom: Known tocompose

Incorrect: Known as composing
Incorrect: Known by composing
suggests someone is named "composing" and they knew the people mentioned.

A real good question with good trap doors. The idiom "Neither....nor..." will always have a subject verb agreement as per the singularity or plurality of the word that follows "nor".
Here Beethoven is that word which is singular (mind the "as well as" s-v rule). Hence we can eliminate A, B & C.
Between D and E, "by composing" has a lot of issues. "To compose" is prefered.

Hence Option D.

Hello from the GMAT Club VerbalBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.
_________________