Author 
Message 
TAGS:

Hide Tags

Intern
Joined: 09 Sep 2016
Posts: 35
Location: Georgia
Concentration: Finance, International Business
GPA: 3.75
WE: Analyst (Investment Banking)

The three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
22 Mar 2017, 10:02
Question Stats:
34% (02:19) correct 66% (02:06) wrong based on 461 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics
The three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer. Is this triangle right triangle? (1) The perimeter of the triangle is an odd integer. (2) If the triangle's area is doubled, the result is not an integer. Please hit kudos if you liked the question
Official Answer and Stats are available only to registered users. Register/ Login.




Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 58464

Re: The three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
20 May 2017, 10:56
poojamathur21 wrote: Hi Bunuel,
Could you please share the solution for this? I'm very confused! The three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer. Is this triangle right triangle?(1) The perimeter of the triangle is an odd integer. Given p + q + r = odd. This implies that either all three p, q and r are odd OR two of them are even and the third one is odd. If all three p, q and r are odd, then \((side_1)^2 + (side_2)^2 = odd+odd=even\) and \((side_3)^2=odd\). Thus \((side_1)^2 + (side_2)^2 \neq (side_3)^2\). The triangle cannot be right angled. If two of them are even and the third one is odd, then \((side_1)^2 + (side_2)^2 = even+even=even\) and \((side_3)^2=odd\) OR \((side_1)^2 + (side_2)^2 = even+odd=odd\) and \((side_3)^2=even\). In any case \((side_1)^2 + (side_2)^2 \neq (side_3)^2\). The triangle cannot be right angled. So, we have a definite answer to the question: the triangle is NOT right angled. Sufficient. From above we can derive that if the lengths of all three sides of a right triangle are integers (so if a right triangle is Pythagorean Triple triangle), then the perimeter of the triangle must be even.(2) If the triangle's area is doubled, the result is not an integer. If the triangle were right angled, the area would be \(\frac{(leg_1)*(leg_2)}{2}\) and double that would be \(2*\frac{(leg_1)*(leg_2)}{2}=(leg_1)*(leg_2)=integer*integer=integer\). Since we are told that double the area of the triangle is NOT an integer, then the triangle is NOT right angled. Sufficient. Answer: D. Hope it's clear.
_________________




Senior Manager
Joined: 24 Apr 2016
Posts: 321

Re: The three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
22 Mar 2017, 12:45
The Three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer. Is this triangle right triangle?
Two points to be known about a Right Angled Triangle
The height and the hypotenuse of Right Angled Triangle will always be Odd Integers The Base of the Right Angled Triangle will always be an Even Integer
Statement 1) the perimeter of the triangle is an odd integer. Based on the above, the perimeter of a Right Angled Triangle will always be Even. Hence the Triangle in question is not a right Angled Triangle. This statement is sufficient.
Statement 2) if the triangle's area is doubled, the result is not an integer.
The Area of a Right Angled Triangle is 1/2 * b*h. On doubling this it becomes b*h. Since all sides of a Right Angles Triangle are integers, b*h will also be an integer. So in this case, the Triangle in question is not a right Angled Triangle. This statement is sufficient.
Answer is D




Retired Thread Master
Joined: 10 Nov 2016
Posts: 42
Location: India

Re: The three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
22 Apr 2017, 09:13
quantumliner wrote: The Three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer. Is this triangle right triangle?
Two points to be known about a Right Angled Triangle
The height and the hypotenuse of Right Angled Triangle will always be Odd Integers The Base of the Right Angled Triangle will always be an Even Integer
Statement 1) the perimeter of the triangle is an odd integer. Based on the above, the perimeter of a Right Angled Triangle will always be Even. Hence the Triangle in question is not a right Angled Triangle. This statement is sufficient.
Statement 2) if the triangle's area is doubled, the result is not an integer.
The Area of a Right Angled Triangle is 1/2 * b*h. On doubling this it becomes b*h. Since all sides of a Right Angles Triangle are integers, b*h will also be an integer. So in this case, the Triangle in question is not a right Angled Triangle. This statement is sufficient.
Answer is D Consider : 6,8,10... These also form right angled triangle. So,I think reasoning for St 1 may not be correct...



Current Student
Joined: 07 Jan 2015
Posts: 64
Location: United States
GPA: 3.4
WE: Engineering (Manufacturing)

Re: The three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
01 May 2017, 04:42
nainy05 wrote: quantumliner wrote: The Three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer. Is this triangle right triangle?
Two points to be known about a Right Angled Triangle
The height and the hypotenuse of Right Angled Triangle will always be Odd Integers The Base of the Right Angled Triangle will always be an Even Integer
Statement 1) the perimeter of the triangle is an odd integer. Based on the above, the perimeter of a Right Angled Triangle will always be Even. Hence the Triangle in question is not a right Angled Triangle. This statement is sufficient.
Statement 2) if the triangle's area is doubled, the result is not an integer.
The Area of a Right Angled Triangle is 1/2 * b*h. On doubling this it becomes b*h. Since all sides of a Right Angles Triangle are integers, b*h will also be an integer. So in this case, the Triangle in question is not a right Angled Triangle. This statement is sufficient.
Answer is D Consider : 6,8,10... These also form right angled triangle. So,I think reasoning for St 1 may not be correct... Is it safe to say that the perimeter of a right triangle is always even?



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 58464

Re: The three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
01 May 2017, 05:56
satsurfs wrote: nainy05 wrote: quantumliner wrote: The Three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer. Is this triangle right triangle?
Two points to be known about a Right Angled Triangle
The height and the hypotenuse of Right Angled Triangle will always be Odd Integers The Base of the Right Angled Triangle will always be an Even Integer
Statement 1) the perimeter of the triangle is an odd integer. Based on the above, the perimeter of a Right Angled Triangle will always be Even. Hence the Triangle in question is not a right Angled Triangle. This statement is sufficient.
Statement 2) if the triangle's area is doubled, the result is not an integer.
The Area of a Right Angled Triangle is 1/2 * b*h. On doubling this it becomes b*h. Since all sides of a Right Angles Triangle are integers, b*h will also be an integer. So in this case, the Triangle in question is not a right Angled Triangle. This statement is sufficient.
Answer is D Consider : 6,8,10... These also form right angled triangle. So,I think reasoning for St 1 may not be correct... Is it safe to say that the perimeter of a right triangle is always even? If the lengths of all three sides are integers (so if a right triangle is Pythagorean Triple triangle), then yes the perimeter will always be even.
_________________



Intern
Joined: 25 Apr 2017
Posts: 13

Re: The three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
20 May 2017, 10:24
Hi Bunuel,
Could you please share the solution for this? I'm very confused!



Director
Joined: 12 Nov 2016
Posts: 699
Location: United States
GPA: 2.66

Re: The three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
28 May 2017, 14:40
Bunuel wrote: poojamathur21 wrote: Hi Bunuel,
Could you please share the solution for this? I'm very confused! The three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer. Is this triangle right triangle?(1) The perimeter of the triangle is an odd integer. Given p + q + r = odd. This implies that either all three p, q and r are odd OR two of them are even and the third one is odd. If all three p, q and r are odd, then \((side_1)^2 + (side_2)^2 = odd+odd=even\) and \((side_3)^2=odd\). Thus \((side_1)^2 + (side_2)^2 \neq (side_3)^2\). The triangle cannot be right angled. If two of them are even and the third one is odd, then \((side_1)^2 + (side_2)^2 = even+even=even\) and \((side_3)^2=odd\) OR \((side_1)^2 + (side_2)^2 = even+odd=odd\) and \((side_3)^2=even\). In any case \((side_1)^2 + (side_2)^2 \neq (side_3)^2\). The triangle cannot be right angled. So, we have a definite answer to the question: the triangle is NOT right angled. Sufficient. From above we can derive that if the lengths of all three sides of a right triangle are integers (so if a right triangle is Pythagorean Triple triangle), then the perimeter of the triangle must be even.(2) If the triangle's area is doubled, the result is not an integer. If the triangle were right angled, the area would be \(\frac{(leg_1)*(leg_2)}{2}\) and double that would be \(2*\frac{(leg_1)*(leg_2)}{2}=(leg_1)*(leg_2)=integer*integer=integer\). Since we are told that double the area of the triangle is NOT an integer, then the triangle is NOT right angled. Sufficient. Answer: D. Hope it's clear. Bunuel my interpretation of your explanation is that if the pythagorean theorem cannot be validated then the triangle cannot be a right triangle because the Pythagorean Theorem only applies to right triangles?



Manager
Joined: 17 Apr 2016
Posts: 79

Re: The three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
28 May 2017, 18:21
Bunuel wrote: poojamathur21 wrote: Hi Bunuel,
Could you please share the solution for this? I'm very confused! The three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer. Is this triangle right triangle?(1) The perimeter of the triangle is an odd integer. Given p + q + r = odd. This implies that either all three p, q and r are odd OR two of them are even and the third one is odd. If all three p, q and r are odd, then \((side_1)^2 + (side_2)^2 = odd+odd=even\) and \((side_3)^2=odd\). Thus \((side_1)^2 + (side_2)^2 \neq (side_3)^2\). The triangle cannot be right angled. If two of them are even and the third one is odd, then \((side_1)^2 + (side_2)^2 = even+even=even\) and \((side_3)^2=odd\) OR \((side_1)^2 + (side_2)^2 = even+odd=odd\) and \((side_3)^2=even\). In any case \((side_1)^2 + (side_2)^2 \neq (side_3)^2\). The triangle cannot be right angled. So, we have a definite answer to the question: the triangle is NOT right angled. Sufficient. From above we can derive that if the lengths of all three sides of a right triangle are integers (so if a right triangle is Pythagorean Triple triangle), then the perimeter of the triangle must be even.(2) If the triangle's area is doubled, the result is not an integer. If the triangle were right angled, the area would be \(\frac{(leg_1)*(leg_2)}{2}\) and double that would be \(2*\frac{(leg_1)*(leg_2)}{2}=(leg_1)*(leg_2)=integer*integer=integer\). Since we are told that double the area of the triangle is NOT an integer, then the triangle is NOT right angled. Sufficient. Answer: D. Hope it's clear. Hi Bunuel, Can you please explain why the triangle is NOT right angled, if the area of the triangle is not an integer?



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 58464

Re: The three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
28 May 2017, 20:59
Nunuboy1994 wrote: Bunuel wrote: poojamathur21 wrote: Hi Bunuel,
Could you please share the solution for this? I'm very confused! The three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer. Is this triangle right triangle?(1) The perimeter of the triangle is an odd integer. Given p + q + r = odd. This implies that either all three p, q and r are odd OR two of them are even and the third one is odd. If all three p, q and r are odd, then \((side_1)^2 + (side_2)^2 = odd+odd=even\) and \((side_3)^2=odd\). Thus \((side_1)^2 + (side_2)^2 \neq (side_3)^2\). The triangle cannot be right angled. If two of them are even and the third one is odd, then \((side_1)^2 + (side_2)^2 = even+even=even\) and \((side_3)^2=odd\) OR \((side_1)^2 + (side_2)^2 = even+odd=odd\) and \((side_3)^2=even\). In any case \((side_1)^2 + (side_2)^2 \neq (side_3)^2\). The triangle cannot be right angled. So, we have a definite answer to the question: the triangle is NOT right angled. Sufficient. From above we can derive that if the lengths of all three sides of a right triangle are integers (so if a right triangle is Pythagorean Triple triangle), then the perimeter of the triangle must be even.(2) If the triangle's area is doubled, the result is not an integer. If the triangle were right angled, the area would be \(\frac{(leg_1)*(leg_2)}{2}\) and double that would be \(2*\frac{(leg_1)*(leg_2)}{2}=(leg_1)*(leg_2)=integer*integer=integer\). Since we are told that double the area of the triangle is NOT an integer, then the triangle is NOT right angled. Sufficient. Answer: D. Hope it's clear. Bunuel my interpretation of your explanation is that if the pythagorean theorem cannot be validated then the triangle cannot be a right triangle because the Pythagorean Theorem only applies to right triangles? Yes. If a triangle is right angled , then \((side_1)^2 + (side_2)^2 = (side_3)^2\). The reverse is also true, if \((side_1)^2 + (side_2)^2 = (side_3)^2\), then a triangle is right angled.
_________________



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 58464

Re: The three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
28 May 2017, 21:01
adityapareshshah wrote: Bunuel wrote: poojamathur21 wrote: Hi Bunuel,
Could you please share the solution for this? I'm very confused! The three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer. Is this triangle right triangle?(1) The perimeter of the triangle is an odd integer. Given p + q + r = odd. This implies that either all three p, q and r are odd OR two of them are even and the third one is odd. If all three p, q and r are odd, then \((side_1)^2 + (side_2)^2 = odd+odd=even\) and \((side_3)^2=odd\). Thus \((side_1)^2 + (side_2)^2 \neq (side_3)^2\). The triangle cannot be right angled. If two of them are even and the third one is odd, then \((side_1)^2 + (side_2)^2 = even+even=even\) and \((side_3)^2=odd\) OR \((side_1)^2 + (side_2)^2 = even+odd=odd\) and \((side_3)^2=even\). In any case \((side_1)^2 + (side_2)^2 \neq (side_3)^2\). The triangle cannot be right angled. So, we have a definite answer to the question: the triangle is NOT right angled. Sufficient. From above we can derive that if the lengths of all three sides of a right triangle are integers (so if a right triangle is Pythagorean Triple triangle), then the perimeter of the triangle must be even.(2) If the triangle's area is doubled, the result is not an integer. If the triangle were right angled, the area would be \(\frac{(leg_1)*(leg_2)}{2}\) and double that would be \(2*\frac{(leg_1)*(leg_2)}{2}=(leg_1)*(leg_2)=integer*integer=integer\). Since we are told that double the area of the triangle is NOT an integer, then the triangle is NOT right angled. Sufficient. Answer: D. Hope it's clear. Hi Bunuel, Can you please explain why the triangle is NOT right angled, if the area of the triangle is not an integer? I think this is explained. We know that the lengths of the sides of the triangle are integers. If the triangle were right angled, the area would be \(\frac{(leg_1)*(leg_2)}{2}\) and double that would be \(2*\frac{(leg_1)*(leg_2)}{2}=(leg_1)*(leg_2)=integer*integer=integer\). Since we are told that double the area of the triangle is NOT an integer, then the triangle is NOT right angled. Sufficient.
_________________



Veritas Prep GMAT Instructor
Joined: 16 Oct 2010
Posts: 9705
Location: Pune, India

Re: The three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
29 May 2017, 23:37
giobas wrote: The three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer. Is this triangle right triangle? (1) The perimeter of the triangle is an odd integer. (2) If the triangle's area is doubled, the result is not an integer. Please hit kudos if you liked the question Responding to a pm: A few things about primitive pythagorean triplets (not multiples of other pythagorean triplets) a, b, c where c is the hypotenuse. 1. One of a and b is odd and the other is even. 2. c is odd. (3, 4, 5), (5, 12, 13), (8, 15, 17) etc The nonprimitive triplets are made by multiplying each member of the primitive triplet by an integer n greater than 1. Depending on whether n is odd or even, the three sides will be (Odd, Even, Odd) or (Even, Even, Even). Given: p, q and r are all integers. (1) The perimeter of the triangle is an odd integer. The perimeter of a right triangle can never be odd. Odd + Even + Odd = Even Even + Even + Even = Even Hence, the perimeter will be even in all cases. (2) If the triangle's area is doubled, the result is not an integer. If p, q and r are the sides of a right triangle such that r is the hypotenuse (could be any of p, q, r), Area of this triangle = (1/2)*p*q Double of area of this triangle = p*q This has to be an integer. But we know that this is not an integer. In that case, this triangle cannot be a right triangle. If it is not a right triangle, double the area will be base*altitude. The altitude would not be an integer in this case. Answer (D)
_________________
Karishma Veritas Prep GMAT Instructor
Learn more about how Veritas Prep can help you achieve a great GMAT score by checking out their GMAT Prep Options >



Intern
Joined: 13 Apr 2017
Posts: 15
Location: India
Concentration: Finance, Marketing
WE: Analyst (Computer Software)

Re: The three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
08 Jul 2017, 07:37
nainy05 wrote: quantumliner wrote: The Three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer. Is this triangle right triangle?
Two points to be known about a Right Angled Triangle
The height and the hypotenuse of Right Angled Triangle will always be Odd Integers The Base of the Right Angled Triangle will always be an Even Integer
Statement 1) the perimeter of the triangle is an odd integer. Based on the above, the perimeter of a Right Angled Triangle will always be Even. Hence the Triangle in question is not a right Angled Triangle. This statement is sufficient.
Statement 2) if the triangle's area is doubled, the result is not an integer.
The Area of a Right Angled Triangle is 1/2 * b*h. On doubling this it becomes b*h. Since all sides of a Right Angles Triangle are integers, b*h will also be an integer. So in this case, the Triangle in question is not a right Angled Triangle. This statement is sufficient.
Answer is D Consider : 6,8,10... These also form right angled triangle. So,I think reasoning for St 1 may not be correct... 6,8,10 in its simplest form will be 3,4,5.
_________________
princeton1: 470 princeton2: 590 princeton3: 460 princeton4: 610 gmat club cat: 620 manhatten1: 680 veritas: 650 princeton5: 700 princeton6: 610 manhatten2: 740 kaplan: 750 princeton7: 700 manhatten3: 780 gmat prep 1: 770 princeton8: 680 manhatten4: 780 princeton9: 710 gmat prep 2: 740 manhatten5: 780 princeton10: 710



Senior Manager
Joined: 15 Jan 2017
Posts: 340

Re: The three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
22 Jul 2018, 01:07
The three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer. Is this triangle right triangle?
(1) The perimeter of the triangle is an odd integer. (2) If the triangle's area is doubled, the result is not an integer.
Thought of pythagorean triplets first > 3,4,5/ 12,13,5/ 8/10/6, 8/15/17 > each of these have an even integer divisible by two, and each's perimeter is even cz in each case o + o + e is e (I did this by adding)
So Qx is asking us if triangle pqr is actually right angled or not.
St 1: triangle perimeter is odd. Based on quite a few pairs, perimeter is even. Which means, this triangle isn't a right triangle with integers. Sufficient.
St 2: If the triangle's area is doubled, the result is not an integer. > if the double of something isn't divisible by 2 (I'm using formula 1/2 bh for area) so halfing it will also not be divisible by 2. Each pythagorean triplet right triangle has an even integer as its height, so this triangle in question isn't a right triangle. Sufficient
So answer is D.



Manager
Joined: 10 Aug 2009
Posts: 62

Re: The three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
13 Jan 2019, 02:42
giobas wrote: The three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer. Is this triangle right triangle? (1) The perimeter of the triangle is an odd integer. (2) If the triangle's area is doubled, the result is not an integer. Please hit kudos if you liked the question Since statement 1 can be easily evaluated using pythagorean triplets. Here is another way to evaluate statement 2: Area of triangle is \(= 1/2*p*q*sin\alpha\), where \(\alpha\) is the angle between p & q. Now if we double this area, it will become \(p*q*sin\alpha\). The only thing you need to know is that \(sin 90 = 1\) and for any other angle the value of \(sin\) is noninteger. Since doubling the area makes it non integer and p and q are already integers => \(sin \alpha\) is non integer => Hence we know that the angle between p and q is not 90. So statement 2 is sufficient.
_________________
Retaking gmat for second time, any retakers please feel free to connect.




Re: The three sides of triangle have length p, q and r, each an integer.
[#permalink]
13 Jan 2019, 02:42






