John bought 2 shares and sold them for $96 each. If he had a profit of

Question

John bought 2 shares and sold them for $96 each. If he had a profit of 20% on the sale of one of the shares but a loss of 20% on the sale of the other share, then on the sale of both shares John had

(A) a profit of $10
(B) a profit of $8
(C) a loss of $8
(D) a loss of $10
(E) neither a profit nor a loss

SavageBrother · Accepted Answer

John bought 2 shares and sold them for $96 each. If he had a profit of 20% on the sale of one of the shares but a loss of 20% on the sale of the other share, then on the sale of both shares John had

(A) a profit of $10
(B) a profit of $8
(C) a loss of $8
(D) a loss of $10
(E) neither a profit nor a loss

Sold both shares for $96 each, 1 20% profit, 1 20% loss.

96% for 20% profit: 
96 = 1.2x
x = 80
96 - 80 = 16 profit

96% for 20% loss:
96 = 0.8x
x = 120
120 - 96 = 24 loss

24 loss - 16 profit = 8 loss.

C.

AmoyV · Answer

$ Profit of the share sold at 20% profit = 
120-96
20-?
$16 profit on the sale of 1 share.

$ Loss of the share sold at 20% loss= 
80-96
20-?
$24 loss on the sale of 1 share.

16-24=Loss of $8

Answer: C

IceMaur · Answer

Sold both shares (A+B) for?

96 + 96 = 192

Bought both shares for?

A: 96 / (6/5) = 16 * 5 = 80

B: 96 / (4/5) = 24 * 5 = 120

A + B = 200

Profit: 192 - 200 = -8

Answer: C

adityadon · Answer

for 2 products ,Whenever selling price is same and there is x% profit on one and x% loss on other then there is loss on whole transaction. 
Here ,
for first prodcut 
96 = 1.2x
x = 80
First Cost price = 80

For second product 
96 = 0.8x
x = 120
second cost price=120

total cost price =120+80=200
total selling price = 96+96 =192
Hence , loss of 8$

rachitsinha · Answer

For the share in profit,

1.2x=96
x=80

for the share in loss,

0.8y=96
y=120

Total C.P = x+y = 120+20=200

Total S.P = 96 *2 = 192

Loss = 200 - 192= $8

Answer C

KS15 · Answer

Cost price of each share=x
Sale price of share A=0.8x
Therefore, 0.8x=96
x=120
Loss=$24
Sale price of share B=1.2X=96
X=80
Profit=16
Net loss=$8
Answer C

Bunuel · Answer

VERITAS PREP OFFICIAL SOLUTION

Note that the question would have been straight forward had the COST price been the same, say $100. A 20% profit would mean a gain of $20 and a 20% loss would mean a loss of $20. Overall, there would have been no profit no loss.

Here the two shares are sold at the same SALE price. One at a profit of 20% on cost price which must be lower than the sale price (to get a profit) and the other at a loss of 20% on cost price which must be higher than the sale price (to get a loss). 20% of a lower amount will be less in dollar terms and hence overall, there will be a loss.

The loss % = (20)^2/100 % = 4%.

But we need the amount of loss, not the percentage of loss.

Total Sale price of the two shares = 2*96 = $192

Since there is a loss of 4%, the 96% of the total cost price must be the total sale price

(96/100)*Cost Price = Sale Price

Cost Price = $200

Loss = $200 – $192 = $8

Answer (C)

chetan2u · Answer

total CP = 9600/120 + 9600/80 = 80 + 120=200
SP=96*2=192
loss= Rs 8/-
C

GMATinsight · Answer

For EQUAL SELLING PRICE and EQUAL %age PROFIT AND LOSS ON ARTICLES the resultant loss or profit is calculated as follows

The situations always lead to loss

Loss% = (%age Profit or loss / 10)^2 = (20/10)^2 = 4% loss

Total Selling Price = 96*2 = $192
Total Cost Price = 192/(0.96) = $200

Loss = 200-192 = $8

Answer: Option C

ALTERNATIVE

Cost price of first share = 96 / 1.2 
Cost price of first share = 96 / 0.8

Total Cost price of both shares = (96 / 1.2 )+(96 / 0.8) = $200

Total Loss = 200-192 = $8

Answer: Option C

JeffTargetTestPrep · Answer

For the one share earning a 20% profit, we can set up the following equation in which c = cost:

Profit = 0.2c

96 - c = 0.2c

96 = 1.2c

80 = c

Thus, John made 96 - 80 = 16 dollars on the sale.

For the share with a 20% loss, we can set up the following equation in which c = cost:

Profit = -0.2c

96 - c = -0.2c

96 = 0.8c

120 = c

Thus, John lost 120 - 96 = 24 dollars on the sale.

So, overall he lost 8 dollars.

Answer: C

GMATinsight · Answer

Harikamini

Please find answer to your question posted as PM

Since the loss incurred is 4% therefore we can deduce that revenue is only 96% of the cost

i.e. (96/100)*Total Cost = 192

i.e. Total Cost = 192/0/96 = 200

I hope this clears your doubt.

Saiganesh999 · Answer

Hi Chetan,
Your approach is short and sweet and I like it.
Can you solve this problem, just by using conceptual approach? (without using the math I mean) 
If it is possible, can you give a try?

Thanks in advance!

bumpbot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club BumpBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

John bought 2 shares and sold them for $96 each. If he had a profit of

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Problem Solving (PS) Questions

John bought 2 shares and sold them for $96 each. If he had a profit of

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards