A standard problem for computer security is that passwords that have

Question

A standard problem for computer security is that passwords that have to be typed on a computer keyboard are comparatively easy for unauthorized users to steal or guess. A new system that relies on recognizing the voices of authorized users apparently avoids this problem. In a small initial trial, the system never incorrectly accepted someone seeking access to the computer's data. Clearly, if this result can be repeated in an operational setting, then there will be a way of giving access to those people who are entitled to access and to no one else.

The reasoning above is flawed because it

(A) makes a faulty comparison, in that a security system based on voice recognition would not be expected to suffer from the same problems as one that relied on passwords entered from a keyboard 
(B) bases a general conclusion on a small amount of data 
(C) fails to recognize that a security system based on voice recognition could easily have applications other than computer security 
(D) ignores the possibility that the system sometimes denies access to people who are entitled to access 
(E) states its conclusion in a heavily qualified way

blowice27 · Answer

B says it bases conclusion on small data. But the argument clearly states that only if the results can be replicated in operational setting.

Argument states that conclusion will be true under some condition. Argument is not basing its conclusion on small data, but on future condition that could or could not be true

D on the other states what the argument missed, i.e. it might deny access when it should have allowed a person to access the system

Posted from my mobile device

bidskamikaze · Answer

The OA seems confusing, as it doesn't address the core problem with keyboard passwords: That they are easy to steal or guess. Choice A seems to be a better choice. 
Experts please help with this one!

sthahvi · Answer

I agree with this A does seem like a better option as well as applicable

anshulasthana · Answer

Someone, please explain why A is wrong.
And how D is not vaguely assumed.

Is it talking about the scenario when an authorized person is suffering from a Cold?

AnirudhaS · Answer

D is correct. Think in terms of Venn diagrams.

In the text this is mentioned 
 ", the system never incorrectly accepted someone seeking access to the computer's data"

But this can mean two things - 
(1) It stopped BAD guys (SUCCESS)
(2) It stopped GOOD guys (FAIL)

**here BAD = not a match, people not matching the password/description
**GOOD = a match, and has right of entry to the system

Situation (2) is exactly what D is - 
(D) ignores the possibility that the system sometimes denies access to people who are entitled to access

Hope this helps.

HoneyLemon · Answer

I got confused between B and D .

But realized that key to read the highlighted portion ..

the system never incorrectly accepted someone seeking access to the computer's data. Clearly, if this result can be repeated in an operational setting
 => then there will be a way of giving access to those  people who are entitled to access and to no one else .

To achieve the highlighted conclusion the assumption is the people who are entitled to get access are not stopped as well .

A standard problem for computer security is that passwords that have to be typed on a computer keyboard are comparatively easy for unauthorized users to steal or guess. A new system that relies on recognizing the voices of authorized users apparently avoids this problem. In a small initial trial,   the system never incorrectly accepted someone seeking access to the computer's data. Clearly, if this result can be repeated in an operational setting  , then there will be a way of giving access to those people who are entitled to access and to no one else.

The reasoning above is flawed because it

(A) makes a faulty comparison, in that a security system based on voice recognition would not be expected to suffer from the same problems as one that relied on passwords entered from a keyboard 
(B) bases a general conclusion on a small amount of data 
(C) fails to recognize that a security system based on voice recognition could easily have applications other than computer security 
(D) ignores the possibility that the system sometimes denies access to people who are entitled to access 
(E) states its conclusion in a heavily qualified way

8Harshitsharma · Answer

No proper explanation for answer choice A is provided, so I'll take a stab at it.

Choice A

A is incorrect because the comparison is a totally valid comparison, keeping in context the given problem with keyboard system. It is NOT expected that the voice recognition system overcomes ALL the vulnerabilities in the world for password systems, especially since it is stated in the argument - "A new system that relies on recognizing the voices of authorized users apparently avoids  this problem" -  the problem being keyboard passwords are comparatively easy to steal or guess for unauthorized users. So the voice recognition system needs to avoid only this problem for the conclusion to hold - we don't care about any "other" problems the voice recognition system may have. Hence, this choice is an invalid claim.

Choice D

Clearly, it addresses the possibility of going against the conclusion by contradicting the bolded part - "...there will be  a way of giving access to those people who are entitled  to access and to no one else."

Hope this helps somebody.

AbhishekP220108 · Answer

Can we have a official explanation for this one

A standard problem for computer security is that passwords that have

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Critical Reasoning (CR) Questions

A standard problem for computer security is that passwords that have

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards