SonofPegasus
I picked up a view on my optional essay over the weekend, whatever that means. Probably going through wait-list candidates...
I believe they review someone's entire app (essays, stats, recs, linkedin page, etc.) all at once within like 15 minutes, score it, and then push it down the pipe or reject. I highly doubt they decide waitlist candidates before reviewing someone's optional essay and even if they did, I assume they would wait to view the essay until after round 1 interviews - they seem pretty busy at the moment. Pure conjecture but trying to stay positive!
I agree they would push it down the pipe or flat-out reject. I would think they are now going through the very borderline candidates and deciding whether or not to sneak them into an interview, waitlist, or reject. Fingers crossed!