guenthermat
Is it never, never, never possible to combine present tense and present perfect in two connected clauses?
Hi guenthermat, on the contrary, it is perfectly
fine to combine
present tense and
present perfect. For example, following is a valid sentence:
I do not have any money because I have lost my wallet. I do not have any money is simple present, while
I have lost my wallet is present perfect. In fact, I cannot think of a better way to articulate this sentence.
The sentence that you've posted here however, is not strictly
present tense; it uses
present participle (in option D). This is what's creating bit of a problem here, because present participles of this type (that appear towards the end of a clause and are preceded by a comma) are supposed to depict a
continuum and not
discreteness.
For example, following would not be correct:
Michael has prepared hard for the exam, now planning to appear in the exam.
Again, the issue is that preparation has already been
done (one discrete event) and his act of planning to appear in the exam is
another discrete event. So, continuum is again
missing and we
cannot use present perfect here.
A better sentence would be:
Michael, having prepared hard for the exam, is now planning to appear in the exam.
p.s. Our book
EducationAisle Sentence Correction Nirvana discusses
participles, their application and examples in significant detail. If someone is interested, PM me your email-id; I can mail the corresponding section. In fact, this very sentence has been cited in our book.