OFFICIAL EXPLANATIONgeneris
Project SC Butler: Sentence Correction (SC1)
Scholars have little doubt
whether the latter years of Egypt's Old Kingdom were marked by economic decline and a breakdown in the centralized system of government, disasters likely brought about by changes in the flow of the Nile.
A)
whether the latter years of Egypt's Old Kingdom were marked
B)
as to whether the latter years of Egypt's Old Kingdom were marked
C) that the latter years of Egypt's Old Kingdom were marked
D)
about the latter years of Egypt's Old Kingdom
having been markedE)
about whether the latter years of Egypt's Old Kingdom
was marked
SolutionIn general, use
doubt that.
Always avoid
doubt if.As long as the statement is affirmative,
doubt whether is usually okay.
If the statement is negative or you are asking a question, use
doubt that.-- If a statement / main clause is negative, use doubt
that: I do not doubt that you are telling the truth. = I am certain that you are telling the truth.
I have no doubt that foreigners interfered with U.S. elections in 2016. = I am certain that foreigners interfered with elections.
I have little doubt that foreigners interfered with U.S. elections in 2016. = I am certain that foreigners interfered with elections.
I have no doubt = I am certain
When we use the verb
to doubt in the negative, we are
not expressing doubt.
In fact, we are expressing certainty. We are confident about our belief.
I do not doubt = I am
not uncertain = I am certain
Use doubt
that.-- When asking a question, use doubt
that:Do you doubt that foreigners interfered with U.S. elections in 2016?Does she doubt that you fought in Afghanistan?If a statement / main clause is positive and expresses skepticism, use
doubt that or
doubt whether.Do not use
doubt if. I doubt that he will be on time. = I am pessimistic; I think he will be late.
I doubt whether he will be on time. = I am pessimistic; I think he will be late.
But if the statement is in the negative then the following is true:
I have little doubt that ≈
I have no doubt thatWe have a statement in the negative.
The sentence means that
scholars are almost completely certain that changes in the flow of the Nile River brought about economic and governmental "disasters" that plagued the last years of Egypt's old kingdom.• Split #1: subject-verb agreement→ In option E because the plural noun
years does not agree with the singular verb
was.Eliminate E
• Split #2: negative doubt statements cannot take whetherOptions A, B, and E incorrectly use
doubt whether, doubt as to whether, and
doubt about whether.
The scholars are confident that changes in the flow of the Nile caused disasters in the last years of Egypt's Old Kingdom and led to the demise of that Old Kingdom.
The scholars do
not doubt
that changes in the flow of the Nile caused disasters in the last years of Egypt's Old Kingdom.
Options A, B, and E incorrectly use some form of
whether.In negative sentences, use
doubt that.
ELIMINATE A and B (option E is already eliminated.)
• Split #3 - Use that for negative statements; avoid awkward phrasingOption D uses
having been marked, phrasing that makes an already passive sentence more passive.
Because option D does not use
whether, it may not seem as incorrect as the other three options.
But SC is often a comparison between the better option and the worse option.
Option C is better than option D: (C) is straightforward and does not use awkward phrasing.
(If you disagree, argue your case: why is D better than C?)
Eliminate D
The best answer is C.COMMENTSvipulshahi , welcome to SC Butler.
This question is hard.
GMAC has tested this rule on a couple of occasions (and probably on occasions I have not yet seen.)
One reason I posted this question stems from non-native speakers' tendency to say, "I have a doubt."
That sentence usually goes further to: "I have a doubt
about . . ."
I have a doubt about is
not wrong—I hope that people continue to ask questions.
(The only dumb question is the one that goes unasked.)
Just know that if you express doubt in a negative statement—use
that. vipulshahi , you were brave. And your answer is very good. Well done.