OFFICIAL EXPLANATIONProject SC Butler: Sentence Correction (SC1)
• HIGHLIGHTSThis sentence is a conditional.
We know so because we see the word
unless, which can mean
if not or
only if.See Notes, below.
We are committed to the fact that the
if/unless clause is in the present tense.
Every option uses
is or
are in the if/unless clause.
Only two types of conditionals use present tense in the condition (if/unless) clause: Type 1 and Zero Conditional.
This sentence not a general truth or scientific fact and thus not a zero conditional.
The results clause should be in simple future tense.
That is, Type 1 conditionals use
IF/UNLESS
simple present, THEN
simple future Unless THIS thing happens, THAT thing will happen.
See Notes, below, for more on Zero and Type 1 conditionals.
THE PROMPTQuote:
Post-capitalists have vehemently claimed that unless the unabated consumption patterns common
in the era since the end of World War II are somehow curbed, the world would face increasing economic disasters that will violently force humankind to settle for less.
Strip the sentence:
Post-capitalists have vehemently claimed that unless the unabated consumption patterns common in the era since the end of World War II are somehow curbed, the world would face increasing economic disasters
that will violently force humankind to settle for less.
The sentence, stripped:
Unless the unabated consumption patterns common in the era since the end of World War II are somehow curbed, the world would face increasing economic disasters.THE OPTIONS (in shortened sentences)
Quote:
A) Unless the unabated consumption patterns common in the era
since the end of World War II are somehow curbed, the world would face increasing economic disasters.
• the verb
would face in the result clause is incorrect.
-- we do not use
would face (the future past) in the result clause when the if/unless clause is in simple present tense.
-- as I explained above, with an
unless clause in simple present, the results clause can be only in simple present (zero conditional) or simple future (Type 1)
• this sentence is not a zero conditional—it's not a general truth.
The post-capitalists' claim is not a general truth.
The post-capitalists are predicting. Almost always, predictions are Type 1 conditionals.
• as I mentioned, Type 1 conditionals use simple future in the result clause, this way:
IF/UNLESS simple present, THEN simple
future.-- the verb
would face is not simple future.
(
would face could be used to express uncertainty about the future or to report the future from the past)
• This Type 1 conditional requires the simple future tense
will face. ELIMINATE (A)
Quote:
B) Unless the unabated consumption patterns common since
since the end of World War II are somehow curbed, the world would face increasing economic disasters.
• Same problem as that in (A).
-- the results clause uses
would face and should be
will faceELIMINATE (B)
Quote:
C) Unless the unabated consumption
patterns common
in the era since the end of World War II is somehow curbed, the world will face increasing economic disasters • the plural subject
patterns does not agree with the singular verb
isELIMINATE (C)
Quote:
D) Unless the unabated consumption patterns common
in the era since the end of World War II are somehow curbed, the world had faced increasing economic disasters.
• illogical:
had faced is in past perfect tense, the "past of the past."
We cannot use past perfect without at least one event in simple past tense or a time marker.
This event is in
present tense ("are curbed"): the world will face—not had faced—increasing economic disasters.
ELIMINATE (D)
Quote:
E) Unless the unabated consumption patterns common in the era
since the end of World War II are somehow curbed, the world will face increasing economic disasters.
[/quote]
• Bingo. UNLESS simple present (are curbed), THEN simple future *will face").
Unless/if unabated consumption patterns are not curbed, then the world will face increasing economic disasters.The correct answer is E• NOTESConditionals and verb tensesEvery option contains a present tense in the
unless/if clause.
Only two types of conditionals use present tense in the condition clause: Zero Conditional and Type 1 Conditional.
-- A Zero Conditional expresses scientific facts or general truths.
If you freeze water, it expands.Unless you possess a medical license, you cannot practice medicine in this state.→
IF you do NOT possess a medical license, you cannot practice medicine in this state.→
ONLY IF you possess a medical license can you practice medicine in this state.The time in a Zero Conditional is now and always.
The circumstances are real and possible
We use simple present for the condition (if/unless) clause and simple present for the main (result/then) clause.
-- A Type 1 conditional speculates about a possible condition and its probable result.
Unless you reject tribalism and xenophobia, I will have little respect for you.The time in a Type 1 conditional is the present or the future
UNLESS simple present, [THEN] simple future.
If you look at the bottom of
this post, here, you will find a
short overview of the five types of conditionals.
ExplainCOMMENTSsanjayparihar16 ,
poojakhanduja3017 ,
FauleKatze ,
Shahalikhan welcome to SC Butler.
I am glad to see you all.
I typically post an explanatory note saying that only
good explanations get kudos.
I forgot to do so.
Still -- everyone should strive to be comprehensible in posts.
Our job is to eliminate the four worst answers, not to find the one best answer.
People who follow must be able to understand what the heck you are talking about.
Using jargon and assertion is not explanation.
I will give kudos to correct answers with decent-to-good explanations -- smiley faces go to those that I think are incomplete, half-hearted, or underwhelming, but only because I did not have the "warning" up.
A few of you did a very good job.
I am pleased that you all seem familiar with what is happening here.
Be safe.