Author 
Message 
TAGS:

Hide Tags

Intern
Joined: 07 Jun 2010
Posts: 14
Location: mumbai
Schools: isb

Committee X and Committee Y , which have no common members
[#permalink]
Show Tags
Updated on: 16 Mar 2012, 00:00
Question Stats:
73% (01:13) correct 27% (01:14) wrong based on 445 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics
Committee X and Committee Y , which have no common members, will combine to form Committee Z . Does Committee X have more members than Committee Y ? (1) The average (arithmetic mean) age of the members of Committee X is 25.7 years and the average age of the members of Committee Y is 29.3 years. (2) The average (arithmetic mean) age of the members of Committee Z will be 26.6 years.
Official Answer and Stats are available only to registered users. Register/ Login.
Originally posted by sunland on 01 Jul 2010, 04:57.
Last edited by Bunuel on 16 Mar 2012, 00:00, edited 1 time in total.
Edited the question




Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 64322

Re: Committee X and Committee Y , which have no common members
[#permalink]
Show Tags
16 Mar 2012, 00:23
There is actually no need for variables and formulas here. Committee X and Committee Y , which have no common members, will combine to form Committee Z . Does Committee X have more members than Committee Y ? (1) The average (arithmetic mean) age of the members of Committee X is 25.7 years and the average age of the members of Committee Y is 29.3 years. Insufficient on its own. (2) The average (arithmetic mean) age of the members of Committee Z will be 26.6 years. Insufficient on its own. (1)+(2) The difference between the averages of Z and X is 26.625.7=0.9 and the difference between the averages of Z and Y is 29.326.6=2.7. Since the average of Z is closer to the average of X then X must have more members than Y (to draw the overall average closer to its own average). Sufficient. Notice that we cannot find # of members in X or Y, though based on the difference in averages (0.9 and 2.7) we can deduce that the ratio of members in X and Y is 3:1. Answer: C.
_________________




Manager
Joined: 05 Jul 2008
Posts: 104

Re: DS quest from paperbased test31
[#permalink]
Show Tags
01 Jul 2010, 08:39
OK, i replied to this topic 3 times but failed all, this is the last time! Kudo me if I'm right Let X be sums of ages of mem of Com X, n be the number of mems of Com X Let Y be sums of ages of mem of com Y, m be the number of mems of Com Y X/n=25.7 so X=25.7*n Y/m=29.3 so Y=29.3*m (X+Y)/(m+n)= (25.7*n+29.3*m)/(m+n)=26.6 So 25.7*n+29.3*m=26.6*m+26.6*n => 2.7m=0.9n =>3m=n =>n>m C suff
Attachments
maths.jpg [ 7.91 KiB  Viewed 10189 times ]



Intern
Joined: 21 Apr 2010
Posts: 21

Re: DS quest from paperbased test31
[#permalink]
Show Tags
01 Jul 2010, 13:16
sunland wrote: 19. Committee X and Committee Y , which have no common members, will combine to form Committee Z . Does Committee X have more members than Committee Y ?
(1) The average (arithmetic mean) age of the members of Committee X is 25.7 years and the average age of the members of Committee Y is 29.3 years.
(2) The average (arithmetic mean) age of the members of Committee Z will be 26.6 years. 1 Statement 1 is insufficient. Knowing the average of the groups gives us no idea about how many members there are 2. Statement 2 is insufficient because knowing the average of the group does not tell you anything about the number in the group Together they are suff because the info together can tell you the relative portion of the two groups. A(25.7) + B(29.3) / A+B = 26.6 is a weighted average problem. It can tell you the relative size of one group to the other. You can also think of the problem another way. Since the avg age of the groups is closer to community X. You know there must be more people in X.



Intern
Joined: 21 Aug 2011
Posts: 23
Concentration: Leadership, Finance
GMAT Date: 04022012
GPA: 3.79
WE: Corporate Finance (Investment Banking)

Re: Committee X and Committee Y , which have no common members,
[#permalink]
Show Tags
15 Mar 2012, 12:48
Question: Couldn't both committees have the same number of members but one committee just have older members?



Intern
Joined: 21 Apr 2010
Posts: 21

Re: Committee X and Committee Y , which have no common members,
[#permalink]
Show Tags
15 Mar 2012, 13:08
If that were true u would expect mean age of z to b the arithmatic mean, which would be directly betw een x and y . The weighs would be equal for each group in that case Posted from my mobile device [img] http://gmatclub.com/static/mobile.png[/img]



Manager
Joined: 22 Feb 2012
Posts: 80
GMAT 1: 740 Q49 V42 GMAT 2: 670 Q42 V40
GPA: 3.47
WE: Corporate Finance (Aerospace and Defense)

Re: Committee X and Committee Y , which have no common members,
[#permalink]
Show Tags
15 Mar 2012, 14:08
I had to think about this a few times I forgot to rephrase the question and thats what got me in the end.. Basically the question is asking what is # of X members/# of Y Members 1) Ins 2) Ins 1 + 2 ) Ins to solve for X and Y but based on X as number of comm x members and Y as number of comm y members... you can say: (25.7 * x + 29.3 (y)) / (x + y) = 26.6 then you can say that 25.7 x + 29.3 y = 26.6x + 26.6y thus .9x = 2.7y or x/y = 1/3 I kept banging my head against a wall thinking i cant solve for x or y with one equation..



Intern
Joined: 25 Sep 2012
Posts: 7
Concentration: General Management

Re: Committee X and Committee Y , which have no common members
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Nov 2012, 00:05
Bunuel wrote: There is actually no need for some variables and formulas here.
Committee X and Committee Y , which have no common members, will combine to form Committee Z . Does Committee X have more members than Committee Y ?
(1) The average (arithmetic mean) age of the members of Committee X is 25.7 years and the average age of the members of Committee Y is 29.3 years. Insufficient on its own.
(2) The average (arithmetic mean) age of the members of Committee Z will be 26.6 years. Insufficient on its own.
(1)+(2) The difference between the averages of Z and X is 26.625.7=0.9 and the difference between the averages of Z and Y is 29.326.6=2.7. Since the average of Z is closer to the average of X then X must have more members than Y (to draw the overall average closer to its own average). Sufficient.
Notice that we cannot find # of members in X or Y, though based on the difference in averages (0.9 and 2.7) we can deduce that the ration of members in X and Y is 3:1.
Answer: C. I agree with this explanation Bunuel, however I have one doubt while solving questions using this approach. What if one committee has say 3 members with age 200(avg 200) and other has say 10 members with age 10 (avg=10) . In this case the average age of group (266) is closer to the committee with fewer members. guess there is a problem in my basics...if u could please throw some light on weighted avg
_________________
 Never Say Die die die die die die die die die 



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 64322

Re: Committee X and Committee Y , which have no common members
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Nov 2012, 04:02
Maverick04308 wrote: Bunuel wrote: There is actually no need for some variables and formulas here.
Committee X and Committee Y , which have no common members, will combine to form Committee Z . Does Committee X have more members than Committee Y ?
(1) The average (arithmetic mean) age of the members of Committee X is 25.7 years and the average age of the members of Committee Y is 29.3 years. Insufficient on its own.
(2) The average (arithmetic mean) age of the members of Committee Z will be 26.6 years. Insufficient on its own.
(1)+(2) The difference between the averages of Z and X is 26.625.7=0.9 and the difference between the averages of Z and Y is 29.326.6=2.7. Since the average of Z is closer to the average of X then X must have more members than Y (to draw the overall average closer to its own average). Sufficient.
Notice that we cannot find # of members in X or Y, though based on the difference in averages (0.9 and 2.7) we can deduce that the ration of members in X and Y is 3:1.
Answer: C. I agree with this explanation Bunuel, however I have one doubt while solving questions using this approach. What if one committee has say 3 members with age 200(avg 200) and other has say 10 members with age 10 (avg=10) . In this case the average age of group (266) is closer to the committee with fewer members. guess there is a problem in my basics...if u could please throw some light on weighted avg The average age of the of the whole group cannot be more than individual averages of the smaller groups, so 266 just cannot be the average age since it's more than both 200 and 10. Generally the weighted average of 2 individual averages (200 and 10) must lie between these individual averages.In this case the average age of the whole group of 13 members is (3*200+10*10)/13=~54, which is closer to 10 than to 200. Hope it's clear.
_________________



Manager
Joined: 03 Mar 2013
Posts: 61
Location: India
Concentration: General Management, Marketing
GPA: 3.49
WE: Web Development (Computer Software)

Re: Committee X and Committee Y , which have no common members
[#permalink]
Show Tags
17 Jun 2013, 23:01
sunland wrote: Committee X and Committee Y , which have no common members, will combine to form Committee Z . Does Committee X have more members than Committee Y ?
(1) The average (arithmetic mean) age of the members of Committee X is 25.7 years and the average age of the members of Committee Y is 29.3 years.
(2) The average (arithmetic mean) age of the members of Committee Z will be 26.6 years. here is my take of the question: s1: gives u two variable terms which can't be equated to any so its insufficent s2: gives a single variable term : not sufficient s1 and s2 together then we get a two viable equation which can be used ot find out the relation between x and y so c is our picK



VP
Joined: 06 Sep 2013
Posts: 1494
Concentration: Finance

Committee X and Committee Y , which have no common members
[#permalink]
Show Tags
16 Jan 2014, 05:31
They totally got me on this one, I thought too the following. "Can't X just have older members?" But it is actually the ratio that matters. Even if X has older member the ratio, that is the weight of each of the components will determine the quantity of members in each of both groups, very tricky question indeed totally fell for it Cheers! J



Intern
Joined: 01 Jan 2013
Posts: 47
Location: India

Re: Committee X and Committee Y , which have no common members
[#permalink]
Show Tags
02 Apr 2014, 08:20
sunland wrote: Committee X and Committee Y , which have no common members, will combine to form Committee Z . Does Committee X have more members than Committee Y ?
(1) The average (arithmetic mean) age of the members of Committee X is 25.7 years and the average age of the members of Committee Y is 29.3 years.
(2) The average (arithmetic mean) age of the members of Committee Z will be 26.6 years. Using Scale Method 25.726.629.3 XZ Y 0.3: 2.7 3:27 1: 9 Therefore W1/W2 = 9:1 Therefore members in X > Y



SVP
Joined: 23 Feb 2015
Posts: 1900

Committee X and Committee Y , which have no common members
[#permalink]
Show Tags
02 Apr 2020, 11:06
Bunuel wrote: There is actually no need for variables and formulas here.
Committee X and Committee Y , which have no common members, will combine to form Committee Z . Does Committee X have more members than Committee Y ?
(1) The average (arithmetic mean) age of the members of Committee X is 25.7 years and the average age of the members of Committee Y is 29.3 years. Insufficient on its own.
(2) The average (arithmetic mean) age of the members of Committee Z will be 26.6 years. Insufficient on its own.
(1)+(2) The difference between the averages of Z and X is 26.625.7=0.9 and the difference between the averages of Z and Y is 29.326.6=2.7. Since the average of Z is closer to the average of X then X must have more members than Y (to draw the overall average closer to its own average). Sufficient.
Notice that we cannot find # of members in X or Y, though based on the difference in averages (0.9 and 2.7) we can deduce that the ratio of members in X and Y is 3:1.
Answer: C. BunuelBut, the average of x and y is 27.5 {(25.7+29.3)/2}. May I know why did you deduct 25.7 from the average of z (26.6)? Thanks__
_________________
Do you need fresh question to exercise? Here you go>
https://gmatclub.com/forum/ofthe120childreninacertainschool75arecurrentlystudyingspe326102.html?fl=notifications#p2538179 https://gmatclub.com/forum/50animalscompetedforprizesatacertainfairhowmanyoftheanim325553.html?fl=notifications#p2533491 https://gmatclub.com/forum/50animalscompetedforprizesatacertainfairhowmanyoftheanim325411.html https://gmatclub.com/forum/crossschedulingsoftwarewillallowthecompanybothtoallocatesale324154.html?fl=notifications#p2521256 https://gmatclub.com/forum/theratioofapplestobananasinabasketis3to5iftheratioof325108.html https://gmatclub.com/forum/thelimitingsumoftheinfiniteseries324845.html https://gmatclub.com/forum/theratioofboystogirlsinaclassis3to5if2boysareaddedt323583.html#p2516618 https://gmatclub.com/forum/atypicalassertionofpoliticianswhoareupforreelectionparticul324449.html#p2523288 https://gmatclub.com/forum/ausedbooksellerpurchased50copiesofabookforatotalof323839.html#p2519046




Committee X and Committee Y , which have no common members
[#permalink]
02 Apr 2020, 11:06




