Bunuel
Dr. Philip, along with his four distinguished colleagues, are presenting their dynamic theory of neuron regeneration at symposiums in Athens.
(A) Dr. Philip, along with his four distinguished colleagues, are
(B) Dr. Philip, along with his four distinguished colleagues, is
(C) Dr. Philip, in addition to his four distinguished colleagues, are
(D) Dr. Philip, as well as his four distinguished colleagues, are
(E) Dr. Philip and his four distinguished colleagues is
According to official answer the correct sentence is B.
(B) Dr. Philip, along with his four distinguished colleagues, is presenting their dynamic theory of neuron regeneration at symposiums in Athens.Here, we have background like:
Let's say that Dr. Philip is presenting dynamic theory neuron of regeneration at symposiums in Athens, and Dr. Philip and four distinguished colleagues are standing on a dais.
Here is the sentence for this background:On the dais are four distinguished colleagues and Dr. Philip, who is presenting his dynamic theory of neuron regeneration at symposiums in Athens.---> this sentence is not OK, because "who" indicates both Dr. Philip and four distinguished colleagues ( "Dr. Philip and four distinguished colleagues" treated as ONE word), but the ONLY 'doer' in this sentence is Dr. Philip.
So we can have some possible fixes on this issue
who (Original issue):
On the dais are four distinguished colleagues and Dr. Philip, who is presenting his dynamic theory of neuron regeneration at symposiums in Athens.1/
On the dais with four distinguished colleagues is Dr. Philip, who is presenting his dynamic theory of neuron regeneration at symposiums in Athens.
2/
On the dais are Dr. Philip, who is presenting his dynamic theory of neuron regeneration at symposiums in Athens, and four distinguished colleagues.
--> Here the subject is
Dr. Philip and four distinguished colleagues.
3/On the dais is four distinguished colleagues, along with Dr. Philip, who is presenting his dynamic theory of neuron regeneration at symposiums in Athens.
--> Here the subject is
four distinguished colleagues.
4/
On the dais are four distinguished colleagues and Dr. Philip, the latter of whom is presenting his dynamic theory of neuron regeneration at symposiums in Athens.
We can make the number 3/ as creative as follows:
3/Dr. Philip, along with four distinguished colleagues, is presenting his dynamic theory of neuron regeneration at symposiums in Athens.--> Here the subject is
Dr. Philip. along with four distinguished colleagues is just a modifier
So, the use of
their in non-underlined part does not make sense to me at all.
I think, expert can explain it very well.
I'm tagging some of my favorite experts here.
RonPurewal,
MartyTargetTestPrep,
jennpt,
AjiteshArun,
ccooley,
DmitryFarber,
VeritasKarishma,
GMATNinja,
egmat,
generis.
BunuelI've a curiosity to know the source of this question. Could you reveal the source, please?