Bunuel
Paleontologist: Fossil evidence suggests that the crest of the dinosaur
Parasaurolophus contained hollow tubes connected to its nasal passages. One researcher has proposed that the dinosaur used this crest to produce loud, resonant calls for long-distance communication. However, this hypothesis is implausible, since any such call would have had to exceed 100 decibels to travel the distances proposed, and the structure of the crest does not appear capable of producing such high-volume sound.
Which of the following, if true, would most effectively rebut the paleontologist’s objection?
(A)
Parasaurolophus likely traveled in herds, where long-distance calls may have had limited usefulness.
(B) Similar hollow-crest structures are found in many other herbivorous dinosaur species.
(C) Fossil reconstructions of the
Parasaurolophus crest suggest it was reinforced with cartilage, making it slightly more rigid than bone alone.
(D) The crest may have served multiple functions, including both sound production and thermoregulation.
(E) Soft-tissue structures that do not fossilize could have been involved in vocalization in
Parasaurolophus.
We need to weaken the objection raised :
Objection : Researcher's proposal that the dinosaur used this crest to produce loud is not possible.
He has mentioned the reasoning as below :
Since any such call would have had to exceed 100 decibels to travel the distances proposed, and the structure of the crest does not appear capable of producing such high-volume sound.
Prethingking : If we share some info that the above reasning might be weakened will help. So alt explanation.
Lets do the POE::
A)
Parasaurolophus likely traveled in herds, where long-distance calls may have had limited usefulness.
So what, Irrelevant. (B) Similar hollow-crest structures are found in many other herbivorous dinosaur species.
So what, Irrelevant. (C) Fossil reconstructions of the
Parasaurolophus crest suggest it was reinforced with cartilage, making it slightly more rigid than bone alone.
So what, Irrelevant. (D) The crest may have served multiple functions, including both sound production and thermoregulation.
So what, Irrelevant. (E) Soft-tissue structures that do not fossilize could have been involved in vocalization in
Parasaurolophus.
Hmm this provides alternale explanition for the objection. Making his claim to be rebutted.
Hence
IMO E