New fall shows added to the television network’s upcoming we

Question

New fall shows added to the television network’s upcoming weeknight schedule have increased overall viewership, critical acclaim,  popularity among all age groups, and have decreased  ratings on the network’s shows online

A) popularity among all age groups, and have decreased

B) popularity among all age groups, and decreased

C) and popularity among all age groups, while decreasing

D) increased popularity among all age groups, but decreased

E) and popularity among all age groups were increased, while decreasing

virinchiwiwo · Answer

I think there is a typo in the question. Should it be 'ratings  OF  the network’s shows online', instead of 'ratings on the network’s shows online'? (The official question says 'ON').

I picked D. I was of the opinion that 'increased' in the question is parallel to 'decreased' and should not be changed to 'decreasing'. Please let me know if I was wrong in thinking so. Thank you

neha24 · Answer

first of all u need "and" before the last item of the identical list to make the parallelism complete--->  have increased overall viewership, critical acclaim and popularity among all age groups !! 
always remember that parallelism is not random ,that means that u put things in parallel only when they are suppose to be in parallel !! 
so by that rule we can virtually rule out A, B and D 
E is wrong again for wrong parallelism .
 so C is definitely the answer here

crashVcrush · Answer

New fall shows  added to the television network’s upcoming weeknight schedule  have increased overall  viewership ,  critical acclaim , popularity among all age groups, and  have decreased ratings on the network’s shows online

1. New fall shows have increased

-------------overall viewership, 
-------------critical acclaim,
-------------( something has to be put in the blank )………………………which is parallel to the above two : ( Guess, nothing but POPULARITY find a place ) : D, which is  INCREASED POPULARITY  goes into elimination zone

2. The first half says about INCREASE………………The second half says about DECREASE ( so there’s a contrast, we cannot use AND ) : A/B into elimination zone

3. A/B/D are out..............Between C & E :

a. C : Shows have increase popularity………………………
b. E : Shows have increased popularity…….......were increased

E goes into the elimination zone.

Thus left with C, the OA……………..my understanding

VarunBhardwaj · Answer

Parallelism is the key.three items should be in parallel:: overall viewership, critical acclaim, popularity among all age groups.
There should be a and before last item.

lolivaresfer · Answer

Why not parallel structure between (A):

New fall shows added to the television network’s upcoming  weeknight schedule have increased  overall viewership, critical acclaim, popularity among all age groups,  and have decreased  ratings on the network’s shows online.

dinesh86 · Answer

New fall shows added to the television network’s upcoming weeknight schedule have increased overall viewership, critical acclaim,  popularity among all age groups, and have decreased  ratings on the network’s shows online.

New fall shows
Have increased A, B, and C
And Have decreased D

A) popularity among all age groups, and have decreased - And is missing before third item in sub-list.
B) popularity among all age groups, and decreased -Same as A
C) and popularity among all age groups, while decreasing - Correct.
D) increased popularity among all age groups, but decreased - Shows have increased ''Increased popularity''...seems wrong and redundant. And is required to separate items.
E) and popularity among all age groups were increased, while decreasing - Noun are made parallel with clause. Wrong.

Kudos please....

McQueen · Answer

Why do we expected "have decreased - have increased" but accepted " have increased - decreasing" in D?
Please clarify, thank you.

DmitryFarber · Answer

McQueen , the simple answer is that "while" is not a parallel marker. It indicates a modifier that builds on the earlier action. The fall shows have increased 3 things, and they have done all this while decreasing something else. Using a parallel verb linked with "and" or "but" would work as well, but there's nothing wrong with the modifier form in C. (I'm assuming you meant C, not D.)

iamanorwhal · Answer

New fall shows added to the television network’s upcoming weeknight schedule have increased overall viewership, critical acclaim, popularity among all age groups, and have decreased ratings on the network’s shows online

A)     popularity among all age groups, and have decreased –  require “and” before final element that was increased

B)     popularity among all age groups, and decreased –  require “and” before final element that was increased

C)  and  popularity among all age groups,   while decreasing

D)      increased  popularity among all age groups, but decreased –  require “and” before final element that was increased. second "increase" is redundant

E) and popularity among all age groups  were increased , while decreasing –  second "increase" is redundant

Divyadisha · Answer

Two parallel elements are mentioned in the sentence- 
1) 'have increased viewership' and ' have decreased ratings' 
2) viewership, critical acclaim and popularity among all age groups

popularity among all age groups, and have decreased  and is missing to have 2nd parallel elements 
 popularity among all age groups, and decreased  and is missing to have 2nd parallel elements 
 and popularity among all age groups, while decreasing  correct choice.  
 increased popularity among all age groups, but decreased  'increased' is not required 
 and popularity among all age groups were increased, while decreasing  'increased' is not required

daboo343 · Answer

Here in the above question, parallelism is at issue.
Viewership, acclaim, and popularity have to parallel and without any conjunction before the third itme parallelism cannot be established.
C offers us the same
Hence C is correct

BillyZ · Answer

OFFICIAL EXPLANATION

The correct response is (C). Adding new fall shows have increased overall viewership, acclaim, and popularity. However, they have also decreased online viewership for that network . For sentence clarity, the list of three elements that have been increased require “and” before the final element. Also, contrast is needed between these three positive effects and the one negative outcome for the overall meaning of the sentence to make sense.

deucebigalow · Answer

Hi,

I am confused about this question,
I was expecting to see an option which has " have increased - while ....have decreased" 
So isn't there any problems with the usage "have increased- while decreasing" in the OA, don't these need to be parallel?

I will appreciate any clarification.

NeverGiveUp- Arpit · Answer

Below response from Manhattan instructor  DmitryFarber  may clarify your doubt.

McQueen, the simple answer is that "while" is not a parallel marker. It indicates a modifier that builds on the earlier action. The fall shows have increased 3 things, and they have done all this while decreasing something else. Using a parallel verb linked with "and" or "but" would work as well, but there's nothing wrong with the modifier form in C. (I'm assuming you meant C, not D.)

deucebigalow · Answer

Thanks!

Raksat · Answer

In strict sense "while" is a conjunction and hence a subject and verb should follow. But here "while"+ "participle" is also acceptable. Here it acts as an adverbial modifier and gives us additional information about another effect.
More on the usage of "while"
https://gmatclub.com/forum/usage-of-whi ... fl=similar

GittinGud · Answer

New fall shows have A, B and C and have X.---Parallelism is correct.
New fall shows have A, B and C (while) decreasing X---How is this parallel?

VerbalBot · Answer

Hello from the GMAT Club VerbalBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.

New fall shows added to the television network’s upcoming we

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Sentence Correction (SC - EA only) Questions

New fall shows added to the television network’s upcoming we

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards