Oh, great accomplishments. Only high school activities matter. You should be very proud of what you've done. Hopefully, you've achieved these things because you wanted to beyond padding your resume for college applications.
It's all about being uniquely different from other applicants. There's no one thing the admissions offices look for. They are trying to fill out an entire class which requires lots of different talents. What you have may be in hot demand one year and not the other, so luck is part of it.
The first criteria is whether you are academically qualified. The GPA and class rank are compelling but depend on the quality of the school and if the school commonly sends kids to these colleges. If so, the admissions office may know what those points and classes mean.
The number of AP classes is excessive. The scores on those tests would be important to review. Your SAT score is frankly a bit low in comparison, but if you have a bunch of 5's on your AP tests, that can be ignored.
Your extra curricular activities show you are a leader and involved in your school with personal activities and group leadership recognition. That's great. Class president is a big deal. A critical question is whether you've achieved at the state or national level. Most of the competitive schools' freshman classes are smaller than the number of American high schools, so successful candidates need more than being the best in their high school.
If you're involved in sports that also exist at the colleges, are you at the level to play on those teams? Getting tapped by a coach is extremely helpful. If you're not strong enough to represent the college at a competitive level, then you fall in the club category which is fine, but there are probably many others who are applying with similar qualifications.
A huge impact on applications is the teacher recommendations. Do you have teachers who can say you're among the best they've ever taught in their career? Without that check box, you're chances drop. Being in the top 5% is nice, but these colleges aren't going to accept 5% of your teacher's students.
Finally, your essay and explanation of what you're seeking and personal experiences may be decisive.
Remember that you can be successful regardless of where you go to college. It's what you do with your opportunities that matter. Plenty of kids in good schools who end up with a bad experience. Plus there's always grad school. Good luck with your applications.