Bunuel
What is the remainder when a positive integer ‘P’ is divided by 6?
(1) When P is divided by 12, the remainder is 4.
(2) When P is divided by 3, the remainder is 1.
Solution
Step 1: Analyse Question Stem
• P is a positive integer.
• We need to find the remainder when P is divided by 6 or \((\frac{P}{6})_{remainder}\)
Step 2: Analyse Statements Independently (And eliminate options) – AD/BCE
Statement 1: When P is divided by 12, the remainder is 4.
• According to this statement: \(P = 12n + 4\), where n is a positive integer
o So, \((\frac{P}{6}) = 2n + \frac{4}{6}\)
• Hence, \((\frac{P}{6})_{remainder} = (\frac{4}{6})_{remainder} = 4\)
Hence, statement 1 is sufficient and we can eliminate answer Options B, C and E.
Statement 2: When P is divided by 3, the remainder is 1.
• According to this statement: \(P = 3m + 1\), where m is a positive integer. Here m can be an even integer or odd integer, so there will be two cases as given below:
o Case 1: m is an even integer i.e. \(m = 2k\) where k is any integer.
\(P = 3*2k + 1\)
\((\frac{P}{6}) = k + \frac{1}{6}\)
Hence, \((\frac{P}{6})_{remainder} = (\frac{1}{6})_{remainder} = 1\)
o Case 2: m is an odd integer. Let say \(m = 2k +1\), where k is a positive integer.
\(P = 3*(2k+1) + 1 = 6k +4\)
\((\frac{P}{6}) = k + \frac{4}{6}\)
Hence, \((\frac{P}{6})_{remainder} = (\frac{4}{6})_{remainder} = 4\)
We can see that result of the above two cases are different.
Hence, statement 2 is NOT sufficient.
Thus, the correct answer is
Option A.