I picked D)5 and arrived at the answer by creating a matrix.
Column 1: Group 1 Dominant, Group 1 Sub (or not dominant), Total
Row 1: Group 2 Dominant, Group 2 Sub (or not dominant), Total
The cell that will answer the question/what we are solving for is
Group 1 Dominant + Group 2 DominantSince the stimulus says there were 8 pairs/session and one animal in each pair was dominant and the other submissive, there is an even split of 8 and 8 for the totals:
Group 1 Dominant + Total: 8
Group 1 Sub + Total: 8
Group 2 Dominant + Total: 8
Group 2 Sub + Total: 8
Total + Total: 16
The stimulus also states that of subordinate animals in the first session (Group 1 Sub), 5 were also subordinate in the second session (Group 2 Sub). This Then fills in the cells:
Group 1 Subordinate + Group 2 Dominant: 3
Group 1 Subordinate + Group 2 Subordinate: 5
Since we now have only one cell missing for Group 1 Dominant and Group 2 Dominant (Group 1 Dominant + Group 2 Dominant), we can solve:
(Group 1 Dominant + Group 2 Dominant) + 3 = 8
Therefore, Group 1 Dominant + Group 2 Dominant = 8 - 3 = 5In case this helps anyone else just getting their footing with overlapping sets and matrices, the mistake I made that slowed me down at first was choosing incorrect variables:
Column 1: Group 1, Group 2, Total
Row 1: Dominant, Subordinate, Total
This doesn't help because it doesn't create the overlap in session sets needed to solve (i.e., you need a cell where Group 1 and Group 2 overlap, which this matrix didn't provide; and you need a specific cell where Group 1 Dominant and Group 2 Dominant overlap to account for the 5 animals presented in the stimulus).