Sep 19 12:00 PM PDT  10:00 PM PDT On Demand $79, For a score of 4951 (from current actual score of 40+) AllInOne Standard & 700+ Level Questions (150 questions) Sep 19 08:00 PM EDT  09:00 PM EDT Strategies and techniques for approaching featured GMAT topics. One hour of live, online instruction. Sep 19 10:00 PM PDT  11:00 PM PDT Join a FREE 1day Data Sufficiency & Critical Reasoning workshop and learn the best strategies to tackle the two trickiest question types in the GMAT! Sep 21 07:00 AM PDT  09:00 AM PDT Learn reading strategies that can help even nonvoracious reader to master GMAT RC Sep 22 08:00 PM PDT  09:00 PM PDT Exclusive offer! Get 400+ Practice Questions, 25 Video lessons and 6+ Webinars for FREE Sep 23 08:00 AM PDT  09:00 AM PDT Join a free 1hour webinar and learn how to create the ultimate study plan, and be accepted to the upcoming Round 2 deadlines. Save your spot today! Monday, September 23rd at 8 AM PST
Author 
Message 
TAGS:

Hide Tags

GMAT Tutor
Joined: 24 Jun 2008
Posts: 1843

Re: Data Sufficiency: different answers but both correct
[#permalink]
Show Tags
02 Mar 2019, 10:09
As I mentioned above, the question doesn't make any sense. So it is pointless to debate what the "right" answer should be, because it's like debating "what colour is the number 5?" For the question I posted, you could argue "I cannot find a unique value of x, therefore the answer is E". That is a good argument. I think most mathematicians would instead argue "no value of x exists, therefore I have answered the question using both statements, and the answer is C". That is also a good argument. That is why you can simply never see a DS question like this on the GMAT.
_________________
GMAT Tutor in Toronto
If you are looking for online GMAT math tutoring, or if you are interested in buying my advanced Quant books and problem sets, please contact me at ianstewartgmat at gmail.com



VP
Joined: 23 Feb 2015
Posts: 1211

Re: Data Sufficiency: different answers but both correct
[#permalink]
Show Tags
02 Mar 2019, 11:23
IanStewart wrote: As I mentioned above, the question doesn't make any sense. So it is pointless to debate what the "right" answer should be, because it's like debating "what colour is the number 5?" For the question I posted, you could argue "I cannot find a unique value of x, therefore the answer is E". That is a good argument.I think most mathematicians would instead argue "no value of x exists, therefore I have answered the question using both statements, and the answer is C".That is also a good argument. That is why you can simply never see a DS question like this on the GMAT. But the highlighted part can't be happen in DS because of my above explanation. We all know that there are 2 types of DS. They are: 1/ value types question (what is the value of x?) 2/ yes/no question (Is x positive?) You example is value types question. So, our goal is to find the specific value. But, you are going to say no value , which implies "value types question". So, should I correlate the yes/no question with value types question? It seems that i am going to argue with you, but i am very excited/curious to know this types of problem. Thanks___
_________________
“The heights by great men reached and kept were not attained in sudden flight but, they while their companions slept, they were toiling upwards in the night.”― Henry Wadsworth LongfellowDo you need official questions for Quant?3700 Unique Official GMAT Quant Questions SEARCH FOR ALL TAGSGMAT Club Tests



GMAT Tutor
Joined: 24 Jun 2008
Posts: 1843

Re: Data Sufficiency: different answers but both correct
[#permalink]
Show Tags
02 Mar 2019, 11:42
AsadAbu wrote: But the highlighted part can't be happen in DS Yes, that is my point. This kind of question cannot show up on the GMAT, because it is not clear what the right answer to such a question should be. And there isn't any reason for either of us to spend time discussing what the right answer is to a question that has no right answer, nor is there any reason to spend time discussing the right answer to a question that can never appear on the GMAT.
_________________
GMAT Tutor in Toronto
If you are looking for online GMAT math tutoring, or if you are interested in buying my advanced Quant books and problem sets, please contact me at ianstewartgmat at gmail.com



VP
Joined: 23 Feb 2015
Posts: 1211

Data Sufficiency: different answers but both correct
[#permalink]
Show Tags
02 Mar 2019, 12:11
IanStewart wrote: AsadAbu wrote: But the highlighted part can't be happen in DS Yes, that is my point. This kind of question cannot show up on the GMAT, because it is not clear what the right answer to such a question should be. And there isn't any reason for either of us to spend time discussing what the right answer is to a question that has no right answer, nor is there any reason to spend time discussing the right answer to a question that can never appear on the GMAT. Thank you so much for your feedback in the debatable question! I'm really sorry to bother you! I'm writing here because it seems that the correct choice is E. But, someone may establish the most prominent mathematicians' thinking in this types of question. What I've written in this link is what the GMAC actually says. I should not care about what the prominent mathematicians say, should I?
_________________
“The heights by great men reached and kept were not attained in sudden flight but, they while their companions slept, they were toiling upwards in the night.”― Henry Wadsworth LongfellowDo you need official questions for Quant?3700 Unique Official GMAT Quant Questions SEARCH FOR ALL TAGSGMAT Club Tests



CEO
Joined: 12 Sep 2015
Posts: 3961
Location: Canada

Re: Data Sufficiency: different answers but both correct
[#permalink]
Show Tags
02 Mar 2019, 14:49
IanStewart wrote: ...because it's like debating "what colour is the number 5?" If you ask me, that 5 looks black QED *drops microphone, and then smartly inserts folder bologna into tuxedo breast pocket. Nice to see you back on the forums, Ian!! You always provide valuable insights. Cheers, Brent
_________________
Test confidently with gmatprepnow.com



CEO
Status: GMATINSIGHT Tutor
Joined: 08 Jul 2010
Posts: 2972
Location: India
GMAT: INSIGHT
WE: Education (Education)

Re: Data Sufficiency: different answers but both correct
[#permalink]
Show Tags
02 Mar 2019, 23:21
jk11 wrote: Can a data sufficiency question have different answers from statement 1 and statement 2? Example (hypothetical question): Find x? (1) x  9 = 10 (2) x  9 = 15
As you can see, each statement is sufficient but we get different answers from each. Is this a possible GMAT question?
Posted from my mobile device It is IMPOSSIBLE to have contradictory information between the two statements OR between the question stem and statements. Hence this question does NOT qualify to be a GMAT Like question Question : Find x?Statement 1: x  9 = 10i.e. x = 10+9 = 19 SUFFICIENT Statement 1: x  9 = 15i.e. x = 15+9 = 24 SUFFICIENT As per the logic of DS questions the answer to this question should Be Option D But since this question has different values of x obtained from the two statements therefore it is a BAD question to practice.AsadAbu I hope this helps!!!
_________________
Prosper!!!GMATinsightBhoopendra Singh and Dr.Sushma Jha email: info@GMATinsight.com I Call us : +919999687183 / 9891333772 Online OneonOne Skype based classes and Classroom Coaching in South and West Delhihttp://www.GMATinsight.com/testimonials.htmlACCESS FREE GMAT TESTS HERE:22 ONLINE FREE (FULL LENGTH) GMAT CAT (PRACTICE TESTS) LINK COLLECTION



Veritas Prep GMAT Instructor
Joined: 16 Oct 2010
Posts: 9637
Location: Pune, India

Data Sufficiency: different answers but both correct
[#permalink]
Show Tags
05 Mar 2019, 02:30
AsadAbu wrote: Here is my logic again: Statement 2 can't give ONLY NO in this case, because, then, both statement will contradict each other. So, if we are 100% sure that there is no NO value in statement 2 (specifically in this example), then we must not try for finding YES value in statement 2 !!! It'll be just waste of time finding YES value in statement 2. Without finding YES, I can definitely say: it is D (Correct option). Am I right? Thanks_
Edited.......... Responding to a PM: Yes, I agree that if one statement gives me a definite YES, I will ONLY look for a NO from the other to get a may be. The other statement cannot give me a definite NO. I do understand that GMAC reps don't necessarily take a definitive stand on this but what I think is that they might be playing the "don't say anything that you could be proven wrong on" game. Since some experimental questions that do not make the cut go into the OG, GMAC reps seems to be ensuring that something like that doesn't catch them unaware. If contradictory information were possible on two statements, option (C) would make no sense (say the two stmnts are n = 1 and n = 0) and options (A), (B) and (D) would be questionable too (so what if n = 1, apparently it could be something else too such as 0 or for that matter 100 too so stmnt 1 is not sufficient). Hence, there is no way a valid, scored GMAT question would offer contradictory data, in my opinion. If option (C) exists, I should be able to consider it  whether I need to or not is beside the point. For me, every question has to be a complete logical whole. Seeing that GMAT spends a lot of time and money on every question, I am sure that that is what they want too. Also, since GMAT's scoring and itemvalidating algorithms are extremely data driven, I would be surprised if they let unexplainable data go through (since options (A), (B) and (D) may be chosen randomly)
_________________
Karishma Veritas Prep GMAT Instructor
Learn more about how Veritas Prep can help you achieve a great GMAT score by checking out their GMAT Prep Options >



VP
Joined: 23 Feb 2015
Posts: 1211

Re: Data Sufficiency: different answers but both correct
[#permalink]
Show Tags
05 Mar 2019, 02:50
VeritasKarishma wrote: AsadAbu wrote: Here is my logic again: Statement 2 can't give ONLY NO in this case, because, then, both statement will contradict each other. So, if we are 100% sure that there is no NO value in statement 2 (specifically in this example), then we must not try for finding YES value in statement 2 !!! It'll be just waste of time finding YES value in statement 2. Without finding YES, I can definitely say: it is D (Correct option). Am I right? Thanks_
Edited.......... If contradictory information were possible on two statements, option (C) would make no sense (say the two stmnts are n = 1 and n = 0) and options (A), (B) and (D) would be questionable too (so what if n = 1, apparently it could be something else too such as 0 or for that matter 100 too so stmnt 1 is not sufficient). Hence, there is no way a valid, scored GMAT question would offer contradictory data, in my opinion.Could you explain me the above by giving an authentic example, please? Thnaks__
_________________
“The heights by great men reached and kept were not attained in sudden flight but, they while their companions slept, they were toiling upwards in the night.”― Henry Wadsworth LongfellowDo you need official questions for Quant?3700 Unique Official GMAT Quant Questions SEARCH FOR ALL TAGSGMAT Club Tests



Veritas Prep GMAT Instructor
Joined: 16 Oct 2010
Posts: 9637
Location: Pune, India

Data Sufficiency: different answers but both correct
[#permalink]
Show Tags
05 Mar 2019, 06:11
AsadAbu wrote: VeritasKarishma wrote: AsadAbu wrote: Here is my logic again: Statement 2 can't give ONLY NO in this case, because, then, both statement will contradict each other. So, if we are 100% sure that there is no NO value in statement 2 (specifically in this example), then we must not try for finding YES value in statement 2 !!! It'll be just waste of time finding YES value in statement 2. Without finding YES, I can definitely say: it is D (Correct option). Am I right? Thanks_
Edited.......... If contradictory information were possible on two statements, option (C) would make no sense (say the two stmnts are n = 1 and n = 0) and options (A), (B) and (D) would be questionable too (so what if n = 1, apparently it could be something else too such as 0 or for that matter 100 too so stmnt 1 is not sufficient). Hence, there is no way a valid, scored GMAT question would offer contradictory data, in my opinion.Could you explain me the above by giving an authentic example, please? Thnaks__ That is the whole point. We can't have an "authentic" example of this kind. It is hypothetical only. What is n? Stmnt 1: n = 1 Stmnt 2: n = 0 If stmnt 1 gives n is 1, and we take it at face value and say that stmnt 1 is sufficient to give the answer, then suddenly, how can stmnt 2 say that n = 0? If another value of n were possible (n = 0), how did we conclude that n is indeed 1 using stmnt 1? This just means we don't have sufficient data and hence neither statement should be enough to answer. What then stops n from being 100 or 345? We probably don't have information about that too. When we say that the value of a variable is 1, it has to be just that. Hence, with contradictory data, options (A), (B) and (D) all become questionable.
_________________
Karishma Veritas Prep GMAT Instructor
Learn more about how Veritas Prep can help you achieve a great GMAT score by checking out their GMAT Prep Options >



Director
Joined: 17 Dec 2012
Posts: 629
Location: India

Data Sufficiency: different answers but both correct
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Mar 2019, 01:14
A DS question is answered in such a way that everybody should logically agree on the same answer. But the instructions for DS does not be exactly interpreted in this way. It only asks whether the statements are independently or together sufficient to answer the question or are insufficient independently or together. Consider this: stmt 1: n=4, stmt 2: n=4 Some may dismiss this as contradictory. They do not contradict if n is a square root of 16. So "D" is an "authentic" answer. . In addition to "authentically" saying that D is the right answer we can also "authentically" say that E is the answer as some others may say that information is not sufficient. Some may say that C is the answer assuming common sense for the missing info. Some may be able to reason that A alone is sufficient or B alone is sufficient. I wonder what is the position of GMAC on this.
_________________
Srinivasan Vaidyaraman Sravna Test Prep http://www.sravnatestprep.comHolistic and Systematic Approach



GMAT Tutor
Joined: 24 Jun 2008
Posts: 1843

Re: Data Sufficiency: different answers but both correct
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Mar 2019, 03:43
SravnaTestPrep wrote: Consider this:
stmt 1: n=4, stmt 2: n=4
Some may dismiss this as contradictory.
They do not contradict if n is a square root of 16. Those statements do contradict each other no matter what you know about n. n cannot be equal to two different numbers simultaneously; if n is a square root of 16, then n is equal either to 4 or to 4, not to both at the same time.
_________________
GMAT Tutor in Toronto
If you are looking for online GMAT math tutoring, or if you are interested in buying my advanced Quant books and problem sets, please contact me at ianstewartgmat at gmail.com



Director
Joined: 17 Dec 2012
Posts: 629
Location: India

Re: Data Sufficiency: different answers but both correct
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Mar 2019, 04:34
IanStewart wrote: SravnaTestPrep wrote: Consider this:
stmt 1: n=4, stmt 2: n=4
Some may dismiss this as contradictory.
They do not contradict if n is a square root of 16. Those statements do contradict each other no matter what you know about n. n cannot be equal to two different numbers simultaneously; if n is a square root of 16, then n is equal either to 4 or to 4, not to both at the same time. Two equally objective persons may deduce logically the value of the same variable in a different way. It may later be resolved. In this sense, there is no precise value for a variable even simultaneously. So you may take the value of n arrived by 2 independent persons which an be resolved and both be used in a consistent way using a single formulation. In other words they produce exactly the same effects.
_________________
Srinivasan Vaidyaraman Sravna Test Prep http://www.sravnatestprep.comHolistic and Systematic Approach



VP
Joined: 23 Feb 2015
Posts: 1211

Re: Data Sufficiency: different answers but both correct
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Mar 2019, 09:28
SravnaTestPrep wrote: IanStewart wrote: SravnaTestPrep wrote: Consider this:
stmt 1: n=4, stmt 2: n=4
Some may dismiss this as contradictory.
They do not contradict if n is a square root of 16. Those statements do contradict each other no matter what you know about n. n cannot be equal to two different numbers simultaneously; if n is a square root of 16, then n is equal either to 4 or to 4, not to both at the same time. Two equally objective persons may deduce logically the value of the same variable in a different way. It may later be resolved. In this sense, there is no precise value for a variable even simultaneously. So you may take the value of n arrived by 2 independent persons which an be resolved and both be used in a consistent way using a single formulation. In other words they produce exactly the same effects. But, how do you come up with 2 different values simultaneously?Are you talking about the following example? What is the value of n?1) \(n=4\) 2) \(n^2=16\) Here statement 2 gives 2 values (e.g., 4,4). Statement 1 directly says n=4. So, Why different people takes the value of n=4 in statement 2? Thanks__
_________________
“The heights by great men reached and kept were not attained in sudden flight but, they while their companions slept, they were toiling upwards in the night.”― Henry Wadsworth LongfellowDo you need official questions for Quant?3700 Unique Official GMAT Quant Questions SEARCH FOR ALL TAGSGMAT Club Tests



GMAT Tutor
Joined: 24 Jun 2008
Posts: 1843

Re: Data Sufficiency: different answers but both correct
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Mar 2019, 10:14
SravnaTestPrep wrote: Two equally objective persons may deduce logically the value of the same variable in a different way. It may later be resolved. In this sense, there is no precise value for a variable even simultaneously. So you may take the value of n arrived by 2 independent persons which an be resolved and both be used in a consistent way using a single formulation. In other words they produce exactly the same effects. I don't understand your post, but letters in GMAT DS questions are not 'variables' (except on rare occasions when they define a function f(x), or similar situations). Letters in GMAT DS questions stand for single unknown values. If you see an equation like n^2 = 16 in a GMAT DS question, then we can be certain that the value of n is either 4 or to 4, we just don't know which. But it's not equal to both values simultaneously; n can only have one value. I'll agree that two objective people can arrive at two different solutions to an equation. But if that happens, at least one of them is wrong. We aren't talking about literary criticism or philosophy where there can be many 'right' answers. In math there are right answers and wrong answers. And I'll reiterate what I said earlier: you can never see a real GMAT DS question where one statement leads you to conclude that n = 4, and the other leads you to conclude that n = 4, because those two things cannot both be true, and it is always possible in GMAT DS for both statements to be true simultaneously. Some (badly designed) prep company questions do not observe that principle, but every real GMAT question does.
_________________
GMAT Tutor in Toronto
If you are looking for online GMAT math tutoring, or if you are interested in buying my advanced Quant books and problem sets, please contact me at ianstewartgmat at gmail.com



Director
Joined: 17 Dec 2012
Posts: 629
Location: India

Data Sufficiency: different answers but both correct
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Mar 2019, 16:59
Can you definitively say that something cannot have two values simultaneously ? The gist of my post was that we can have a real life situation where n can have two values at the same time and math should be able to reflect that reality. Instructions for the DS questions do not foreclose the possibility of n with two different values simultaneously.
_________________
Srinivasan Vaidyaraman Sravna Test Prep http://www.sravnatestprep.comHolistic and Systematic Approach



Director
Joined: 17 Dec 2012
Posts: 629
Location: India

Re: Data Sufficiency: different answers but both correct
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Mar 2019, 17:34
Consider this point also. We use some fundamental information to solve a problem. Why not use it to fill in the missing info? When it is given that n=4 and n=4 we use our common sense math knowledge that n^2 =16 and this leads to the bizarre situation that I elaborated in my earlier post. My question is whether DS instructions rule out a" letter" representing more than one value.
_________________
Srinivasan Vaidyaraman Sravna Test Prep http://www.sravnatestprep.comHolistic and Systematic Approach



VP
Joined: 23 Feb 2015
Posts: 1211

Re: Data Sufficiency: different answers but both correct
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Mar 2019, 17:56
AsadAbu wrote: SravnaTestPrep wrote: IanStewart wrote: Those statements do contradict each other no matter what you know about n. n cannot be equal to two different numbers simultaneously; if n is a square root of 16, then n is equal either to 4 or to 4, not to both at the same time. Two equally objective persons may deduce logically the value of the same variable in a different way. It may later be resolved. In this sense, there is no precise value for a variable even simultaneously. So you may take the value of n arrived by 2 independent persons which an be resolved and both be used in a consistent way using a single formulation. In other words they produce exactly the same effects. But, how do you come up with 2 different values simultaneously?Are you talking about the following example? What is the value of n?1) \(n=4\) 2) \(n^2=16\) Here statement 2 gives 2 values (e.g., 4,4). Statement 1 directly says n=4. So, Why different people take the value of n=4 in statement 2? Thanks__ Hi SravnaTestPrep, Did you miss my question?
_________________
“The heights by great men reached and kept were not attained in sudden flight but, they while their companions slept, they were toiling upwards in the night.”― Henry Wadsworth LongfellowDo you need official questions for Quant?3700 Unique Official GMAT Quant Questions SEARCH FOR ALL TAGSGMAT Club Tests



Director
Joined: 17 Dec 2012
Posts: 629
Location: India

Data Sufficiency: different answers but both correct
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Mar 2019, 18:02
Dear Asadabu, I definitely think you raised a very valid point. The DS instructions are not properly framed and it is possible to interpret them differently from what GMAC wants them to be.
_________________
Srinivasan Vaidyaraman Sravna Test Prep http://www.sravnatestprep.comHolistic and Systematic Approach




Data Sufficiency: different answers but both correct
[#permalink]
09 Mar 2019, 18:02



Go to page
Previous
1 2
[ 38 posts ]



