Bunuel
Economist: A recent survey found that in countries with higher rates of internet censorship, there are also higher rates of internet usage per capita. This seems counterintuitive because one might expect that restrictions on internet content would deter usage.
Which of the following, if true and known by the residents of these countries, would best help explain the paradoxical results of the survey?
(A) Many residents in countries with higher internet censorship use the internet primarily for work-related purposes, which are not affected by censorship policies.
(B) Residents in countries with high internet censorship often use proxy servers and VPNs, which allow them to bypass restrictions and access a broader range of content online.
(C) There is an observed trend in the data collection methodology where internet usage metrics might include both direct and indirect engagement metrics, which vary significantly between surveyed regions.
(D) Countries with high rates of internet censorship often have higher populations, thus naturally leading to a higher total number of internet users.
(E) The survey included responses from a disproportionate number of young people, who tend to use the internet more frequently regardless of censorship levels.
(A) Many residents in countries with higher internet censorship use the internet primarily for work-related purposes, which are not affected by censorship policies.
One sided information! It might be that other countries also use the internet for work related purposes. It does not justify that the usage is higher per capita.
(B) Residents in countries with high internet censorship often use proxy servers and VPNs, which allow them to bypass restrictions and access a broader range of content online.
Not bad! Let's keep it.
(C) There is an observed trend in the data collection methodology where internet usage metrics might include both direct and indirect engagement metrics, which vary significantly between surveyed regions.
Okay, but that doesn't impact the argument or help us resolve the paradox in any way.
(D) Countries with high rates of internet censorship often have higher populations, thus naturally leading to a higher total number of internet users.
Total population is not relevant. We are comparing the per capita internet usage.
(E) The survey included responses from a disproportionate number of young people, who tend to use the internet more frequently regardless of censorship levels.
Selected sample is unrepresentative of the total population. This helps resolve the paradox.
Comparing B and E,
B might not help justify the high internet usage per capita as not all users use VPNs to bypass the restrictions, meaning that there is a detered usage.
E would be a better choice.