The myth of the noble savage has long dominated the social sciences. A

Question

The myth of the noble savage has long dominated the social sciences. According to this myth, man in his natural state lived in perfect harmony with both his fellow men and with nature. It is only the corrupting specter of modernity, with its capitalistic rat-race and exploitative mindset, that leads to war and destruction. While somewhat reassuring as a theory of human nature, the fact of the matter is that the noble savage has not ever existed.

Consider the extinction of the moa bird, an ostrich-like species indigenous to New Zealand ranging in size from 3 to 10 feet tall and weighing from 40 to 500 pounds. The last moa bird died roughly 800 hundred years ago, after inhabiting New Zealand for hundreds of thousands of years. It was not a climatic calamity that wiped the birds out. Nor was it a new disease or a catastrophic event such as a volcanic eruption. The moa went extinct a mere 200 years after the arrival of the Polynesian Maoris.

Defenders of the noble savage myth may argue that the Maoris were not responsible for hunting the moa to extinction, but the evidence suggests otherwise. Carbon dating of moa birds shows conclusively that all known species of moa were present when the Maori arrived in New Zealand. And most striking, archeologists have uncovered Maori sites containing between 100 to 500 thousand moa skeletons, roughly 10 times the number of moa living at any one time. The Maori did not live in peaceful harmony with the environment; instead, they engaged in full-scale genocide of the moa.   1 
 1. The primary purpose of the passage is to

A. argue for the conservation of endangered species
B. debunk a misconception
C. describe Maori hunting practices
D. criticize the imposition of modernity on other cultures
E. question the impact of man on animal extinctions

2 
 2. The discovery of the moa skeletons suggests that

A. the Maori not only ate the moa but used their bones in certain rituals
B. the moa were the primary staple of the Maori diet
C. the moa had no other predators besides the Maori
D. Maori society had advanced burial rituals
E. the Maori had been hunting the moa for many generations
 3 
 3 The author most likely mentions “climatic calamity...volcanic eruption,” in order to

A. rule out possible natural causes of the moa extinction
B. cite common explanations for animal extinctions
C. suggest that extinctions are an inevitable part of biological history
D. argue that the moa was resistant to most diseases and natural disasters
E. mock those who hold to the belief of the noble savage

Source: McGraw-Hill's GMAT

dvishal387 · Accepted Answer

1. The primary purpose of the passage is to

A. argue for the conservation of endangered species- The author talks about a bird which is already extinct and there
 is no mention of the conservation of endangered species

B. debunk a misconception- The author starts the 2nd para to debunk the misconception he introduces in 1st para.This is 
the correct choice.
C. describe Maori hunting practices- The author does not describe this.
D. criticize the imposition of modernity on other cultures - Irrelevant
E. question the impact of man on animal extinctions - Although the author speaks about animal getting extinct because
of human actions this is not the primary purpose.

2. The discovery of the moa skeletons suggests that

A. the Maori not only ate the moa but used their bones in certain rituals - No such mention made.
B. the moa were the primary staple of the Maori diet- The author does not mention purpose of killing of the birds.
C. the moa had no other predators besides the Maori- Cannot be concluded
D. Maori society had advanced burial rituals-Cannot be concluded
E. the Maori had been hunting the moa for many generations- The lines "And most striking, archeologists have
 uncovered Maori sites containing between 100 to 500 thousand moa skeletons, roughly 10 times the number of moa 
living at any one time" suggest that the killing continued for generations. Correct choice.

3 The author most likely mentions “climatic calamity...volcanic eruption,” in order to

A. rule out possible natural causes of the moa extinction - The author gives examples of possible causes and rules 
“climatic calamity...volcanic eruption,” out. This is the correct choice.
B. cite common explanations for animal extinctions-This is not the reason.
C. suggest that extinctions are an inevitable part of biological history- This is not the reason because the author talks
 about “climatic calamity...volcanic eruption,” in context of possible causes of extinction of the bird.
D. argue that the moa was resistant to most diseases and natural disasters - Too far a conclusion
E. mock those who hold to the belief of the noble savage - Irrelevant

Nikhil · Answer

+1 kudos to the posts containing answer explanations of all questions

tarunanandani · Answer

Para 1: Describes a myth and discredits it.
Para 2: Illustrates an example to support the claim, disproving the above misconception.
Para 3: Gives evidence to strengthen the claim made through the example.

1. The primary purpose of the passage is to

A. argue for the conservation of endangered species  ---Incorrect , extinction of a species is only used only as an example.
B. debunk a misconception  ---Correct , as per our summary of the passage.
C. describe Maori hunting practices  ---Incorrect , again only an example, a minor detail.
D. criticize the imposition of modernity on other cultures  ---Incorrect , out of scope, not discussed in the passage.
E. question the impact of man on animal extinctions  ---Incorrect , same as A.

2. The discovery of the moa skeletons suggests that

A. the Maori not only ate the moa but used their bones in certain rituals  ---Incorrect , usage of moa is not mentioned in the passage.
B. the moa were the primary staple of the Maori diet  ---Incorrect , no mention of diet.
C. the moa had no other predators besides the Maori  ---Incorrect , Hold it, after option E this option can be eliminated.
D. Maori society had advanced burial rituals  ---Incorrect , burial rituals are not mentioned in the passage.
E. the Maori had been hunting the moa for many generations  ---Correct , 'The Maori did not live in peaceful harmony with the environment; instead, they engaged in full-scale genocide of the moa.' this last sentence from the passage along with the previous lines suggests that the Maori were hunting moa for a long time.

3 The author most likely mentions “climatic calamity...volcanic eruption,” in order to

A. rule out possible natural causes of the moa extinction  ---Correct , because the author wants to highlight people as the cause of moa extinction.
B. cite common explanations for animal extinctions  ---Incorrect , too generic
C. suggest that extinctions are an inevitable part of biological history  ---Incorrect , same as B.
D. argue that the moa was resistant to most diseases and natural disasters  ---Incorrect , no comparison between these two.
E. mock those who hold to the belief of the noble savage  ---Incorrect

honneeey · Answer

Fairly easy one.

Took 3:22 minutes and got all correct!

1. The primary purpose of the passage is to

A. argue for the conservation of endangered species-Nopes, conservation is nowhere mentioned.
B. debunk a misconception- Correct,  refer "fact of the matter is that the noble savage has not ever existed". The entire passage revolves around debunking the myth of noble savage by examples of Moa bird and evidences of culling of Moa bird by Maori.
C. describe Maori hunting practices-Partial Scope
D. criticize the imposition of modernity on other cultures-OFS
E. question the impact of man on animal extinctions-Partial scope probably third para at max.

2. The discovery of the moa skeletons suggests that

A. the Maori not only ate the moa but used their bones in certain rituals-Could be true but refer the text which says skeletons more than 10 times the population of Moa bird were found but not solid enough!
B. the moa were the primary staple of the Maori diet-Can be true! but not properly substantiated by argument. Reject!
C. the moa had no other predators besides the Maori-OFS
D. Maori society had advanced burial rituals-OFS
E. the Maori had been hunting the moa for many generations-Bingo! that is what we can infer from this excerpt" archeologists have uncovered Maori sites containing between 100 to 500 thousand moa skeletons,  roughly 10 times the number  of moa living at any one time".

3 The author most likely mentions “climatic calamity...volcanic eruption,” in order to

A. rule out possible natural causes of the moa extinction- True! correct answer!  To prove that noble savage is a myth and despite living in harmony population of Moa birds got extinct!
B. cite common explanations for animal extinctions-OFS, MOA bird is only mentioned! cant be generalized!
C. suggest that extinctions are an inevitable part of biological history-OFS
D. argue that the moa was resistant to most diseases and natural disaster-OFS
E. mock those who hold to the belief of the noble savage-Too strong! Author doesn't mock them but carefully lays down the postulates to prove that the noble savage is a myth.

hiranmay · Answer

Summary :
P1: 
Background/Myth: noble savage was there and men used to live in harmony w/ others and w/ nature. 
Author conclusion/opinion/claim: the noble savage has never existed i.e. men never lived in harmony w/ nature.(-)

P2: supported author conclusion using example of "moa bird extinction"(-)
P3: further supported w/ data (-)
 
1. The primary purpose of the passage is to( main point Q )

A. argue for the conservation of endangered species -->  discuss about the extinction of bird to support his conclusion. did't argue to conserve the species 
B. debunk a misconception -->  correct: it was a misconception that the noble savage has ever existed and prove that w/ example 
C. describe Maori hunting practices -->  this is just part of the passage, not the main point 
D. criticize the imposition of modernity on other cultures -->  this is just a comment in P1, not the main point 
E. question the impact of man on animal extinctions -->  he talked about the impact of man on animal extinctions. He didn't question. Also this is not the main point

2. The discovery of the moa skeletons suggests that ( inference Q )

A. the Maori not only ate the moa but used their bones in certain rituals -->  we don't know about the diet or rituals of Maori people 
B. the moa were the primary staple of the Maori diet -->  same as A 
C. the moa had no other predators besides the Maori -->  we don't know this from the passage 
D. Maori society had advanced burial rituals -->  same as A 
E. the Maori had been hunting the moa for many generations -->  correct: "10 times the number at one time" means Maori people gathered them for long time i.e. for many generations > "archeologists have uncovered Maori sites containing between 100 to 500 thousand moa skeletons, roughly  10 times  the  number  of moa living at any one time"

3 The author most likely mentions “climatic calamity...volcanic eruption,” in order to( method of resoning Q )

A. rule out possible natural causes of the moa extinction -->  correct: we need to strengthen/prove that "Maori people are the reason for moa bird extinction". so author used “climatic calamity...volcanic eruption,” in order to remove/rule out any possible alternative of this. 
B. cite common explanations for animal extinctions -->  no, author didn't use this for generic purpose, he used this to rule out any possible alternative 
C. suggest that extinctions are an inevitable part of biological history -->  no, then it will weaken the argument. So author didn't use this to weaken the argument 
D. argue that the moa was resistant to most diseases and natural disasters -->  no author didn't use this for this purpose 
E. mock those who hold to the belief of the noble savage-->  no author didn't use this for this purpose

VerbalBot · Answer

Hello from the GMAT Club VerbalBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.

The myth of the noble savage has long dominated the social sciences. A

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Reading Comprehension (RC) Questions

The myth of the noble savage has long dominated the social sciences. A

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards