Hi Experts,
GMATNinja VeritasKarishmaegmatI went through all the explanation multiple times and still not convinced with the explanation for Q1 and Q3.
For Q1: According to the “conventional view” referred to in line 13 of the passage, brighter carotenoid-based coloration in certain species suggests that an individual
(C) has a superior immune system
(D) possesses superior foraging capacity
My understanding of conventional view : healthier males can forage for more of the pigments than can their inferior counterparts
The comparison is between healthier males and unhealthier males. Acc. to passage, healthier males have the capability to forage for more pigments. Now how healthier males capability of foraging would be meaningful in the context of mate selection.
Because they are healthier, they have the capability of foraging for more pigments or Because they can forage for more pigments, they are healthier. So ultimately males are healthier and therefore have a good immune system.
If answer is D, why conventional view has mentioned "healthier males" comparison?
I think how conventional view "rare" is related to mate selection was unclear from the passage. The clarity might help to resolve the confusion btw C and D.
Q3: 3. The passage suggests that relatively bright carotenoid-based coloration is a signal of which of the following characteristics in males of certain animal species?
Acc to question, bright carotenoid-based is signal of "characteristics in males"
The reason used to select A over E was based on female behaviour (GMAT Ninja explanation - The passage makes clear that females prefer bright coloration when choosing a mate. Presumably, that coloration is indicative of a male’s fitness as a mate. Otherwise, females would not prefer it. With that in mind, (E) is the correct answer to question 3.)
(A) Readiness for mating behavior
In the last 2 line of the passage, it is mentioned that males can use carotenoid either to boost immunity or attract females. If males are choosing to advertise that they are genetically resistant, the intention is to attract females by bright coloration instead of boosting immunity. This reason suggests that males are showing willingness for mating behaviour compared to other males who choose to boost immunity.
(E) Fitness as a mate
Please help me to understand where I went wrong.
Thanks in advance.