iMyself wrote:
AbdurRakib wrote:
According to the question Correct answer will say "this fee would be fair" or "FAA's plan is good" or something like that.
Correct answer is C because it says something like "FAA's plan is good,fair & helpful for all travelers(by reducing the number of delayed flights)"
Answer Choice E is wrong for presenting irrelevant information to this argument.This answer choice is giving new information from outside the scope of the argument(appointing president).
Thanks
in the weaken question, the correct answer always come form 'out of scope of the argument'. In C, the words ''delayed flights'' come from out of scope of the argument. There was no discussion about ''delayed flights'' in the discussion. So, will you say that C is wrong because ''delayed flights' is out of scope? obviously not.
In E, the option is irrelevant that does not mean that it is out scope because the words "appointing president'' was not discussed in the argument. E is wrong for another reason not for being ''out of scope''
I believe,I got your point and you understood weaken question & out of scope answers differently than mine.And the problem of understating lies on it
In
Weaken Question,the answer choices are accepted as given,even if they include "new" information.your task is to determine which answer choice best attacks the argument in the stimulus.
Out of scope Answers simply miss the point of the argument and raise issues that are not related to the argument, a choice containing a statement that is too broad,too narrow,or beyond the purview of the stimulus.(may see ref.: Powerscore CR bible)
May I know how you know and understand weaken questions and out of scope answers?How you eliminated E and chose C?
Thanks